YACT: damn... AAA contracted roadside assistance tried to screw me over

NeoPTLD

Platinum Member
Nov 23, 2001
2,544
2
81
It seems like they really try to screw you over unless you are aware of your legal rights. No signs of showing ethical obligation.

I had to get my lock popped and the AAA contract tow truck guy slim jimmed to get in. In the process, he used some cut apart milk jug pieces between the door frame and the door to keep from scratching (what a professional tool huh?), but he was too careless and went outside the covered area.

I could see he wasn't too careful to begin with. I could see him bumping his tool into the side of my door and I was getting pi$$ed off. Fortunately, no damage to outer shell, but he did manage to scrape off an area of paint in the inner side of my door to the primer.

So, I noted the damage on the ticket on site, and notified AAA to document the damage. This towing company, then try to get me to have me fix my car at THEIR affiliate bodyshop.. uh no, not sure if I want them working on my car and I was moving out of that town (end of school year). AAA documented the incident, but they said the service operator is in indepedent contractor and they're fully responsible for the damage they caused.

I told them I will send them an estimate and they are responsible for the full amount. They kept insisted on arranging the payment with the bodyshop themselves. I faxed them the estimate which was around $250. The bodyshop says they do not handle direct billing and third party has to pay me first but the towing company kept insisting on paying the bodyshop directly.

When I called them up again, they again insisted on paying the shop directly. I asked "My understanding is that in State of Oregon, I'm legally entitled to compensation in an amount equal to the cost of having it repaired by a licensed contractor, is this not correct?" They said "yes it is correct, but are you even getting it fixed? If I have to settle on cash payment, I could send you maybe $150". I then asked "Are you telliing me I'm legally entitled to less than the full amount for the cost of damage your company is liable for?"
This is when they're like "well, I don't know if AAA policy allows cash settlement..." (if that's the case what was the $150 he offered contradicts himself), he said he will have to check with AAA.

I immediately called AAA and I was told that AAA does not have such a policy regulating between their contracted contractors and drivers. I got a call back from AAA saying they(the contractor) will be sending a check and I got the check for full amount in a few days, but I never heard from them.

Looks like they were trying to act like they're NOT legally liable for the damage unless I get it fixed right away, which is sooo not true.
 

smack Down

Diamond Member
Sep 10, 2005
4,507
0
0
I'm surprised they didn't make you sign a wavior before they started to work on your car.
 

NeoPTLD

Platinum Member
Nov 23, 2001
2,544
2
81
Originally posted by: smack Down
I'm surprised they didn't make you sign a wavior before they started to work on your car.

What kind of crappy "lock out" service charges money and denies liability? The art of lock picking is opening without a damage.

If you're going to let them get away with $250 paint damage, you might as well smash out the window yourself.
 

dman

Diamond Member
Nov 2, 1999
9,110
0
76
Y'know, I'm sure they didn't diliberately damage your car. Careless, perhaps, but deliberate, no.

You could have gotten a few estimates for repair and sent the lowest or middle one to them. Also, just because a shop is affiliated with a company doesn't mean it's owned by the same people, it's very possible that the towing company repair shop would do a decent job. Sure, you don't have to use them, nor are you required to do anything 'extra' to solve this, but, you are here talking about them being unethical...



 

DurocShark

Lifer
Apr 18, 2001
15,708
5
56
They were hassling you hoping you'd just give up. Then throwing the $150 amount out there was hoping you'd just take it.

Good job keeping on it.

You know that what happened was AAA called and said that if they didn't make you happy, AAA was cancelling the contract. All of a sudden you get a check. heh
 

smack Down

Diamond Member
Sep 10, 2005
4,507
0
0
Originally posted by: NeoPTLD
Originally posted by: smack Down
I'm surprised they didn't make you sign a wavior before they started to work on your car.

What kind of crappy "lock out" service charges money and denies liability? The art of lock picking is opening without a damage.

If you're going to let them get away with $250 paint damage, you might as well smash out the window yourself.

The ones that are smart enought to knew that doors were not desinged to have metal object shoved down them to open the lock.
 

NeoPTLD

Platinum Member
Nov 23, 2001
2,544
2
81
Originally posted by: dman
Y'know, I'm sure they didn't diliberately damage your car. Careless, perhaps, but deliberate, no.
This wans't someone helping you out to be a helpful guy. This is a commercial business charging a considerable amount of money for their service. (which I have access to with my AAA membership) Why woudln't I expect full compensation when they're doing this for money? A contractor working for profit is expected to pay for all damage they cause in full.


You could have gotten a few estimates for repair and sent the lowest or middle one to them. Also, just because a shop is affiliated with a company doesn't mean it's owned by the same people, it's very possible that the towing company repair shop would do a decent job. Sure, you don't have to use them, nor are you required to do anything 'extra' to solve this, but, you are here talking about them being unethical...

They didn't suggest I take it to that shop, they basically ordered me to take it to xxx body shop and "they'll get it fixed for you". I'm being unethical, because I'm busy and won't have time to get it fixed right away, but expect to get compensated? My time isn't free.