• We’re currently investigating an issue related to the forum theme and styling that is impacting page layout and visual formatting. The problem has been identified, and we are actively working on a resolution. There is no impact to user data or functionality, this is strictly a front-end display issue. We’ll post an update once the fix has been deployed. Thanks for your patience while we get this sorted.

XP has quit playing music CDs

KF

Golden Member
I put this here because it seems like it has to be something wrong with the Windows XP OS files or the registry.


Although I hadn't tried it in a couple of months, XP used to play music CDs. I want that for checking if music CDRs are burned correctly. But it doesn't play regular commercial music CDs either. Both the CDR and DVDROM still read data CDs with files on them normally. They both still autoplay and bring up Media Player 9 to play the music CDs when I insert one. "My Computer" changes what it lists for the CDROMs to "Audio CD" when a music CD is inserted in either, so XP knows a CD is there, and knows it is an audio CD. Media Player 9 says

"
The selected file has a file scheme that is not recoginzed by Windows
Media Player, but the Player may be able to play it. Because the
extension is unknown by the Player, you should be sure that the file
comes from a trustworthy source.


Do you want the Player to try to play the file?"

It ask that for each song on the CD, 18 times for 18 songs.

After this, if I click the play button, it says

"Windows Media Player cannot find the specified file. Be sure
the path is typed correctly. If it is, the file does not exist at the
specified location, or the computer where the file is stored is
offline."


If I go into "My Computer" and right click to bring up the menu, and select "Open", I get a list of files with names like "Track18.cda", each of which has a size of 1K, a type of CD Audio Trak, and a date modified of 12/31.1994 8:04 PM, for the CD I just put in, a commecial CD.

Both CDROMs are set to play music digitally in Device Manager

I can't find any reason XP does this. I have a multiple boot setup on this computer for testing purposes, and linux. If I boot a different installation of XP on a different partition, music CDs play normally, so it isn't a hardware problem. It is only the installation that I actually use which has this problem. If I double click on a CDROM, it goes through the Media Player routine.

Other players I have do the same thing. They won't recognize that music CDs have anything they can play.

This is a new installation of Windows Media Player 9 which I tried in the hope of curing the problem. Until this morning I had version 8.

Maybe I installed some Internet music playing program a few months ago, that some site wanted me to, so I could view some fancy media pizazz, and then uninstalled it. I don't really remember. Audio has been fine. I can still play MP3s and Wave files, and MPGs that have audio. I can burn music tracks onto CDs just fine. Games have normal audio. Music samples from Amazon.com play.

I guess reinstalling XP over itself might solve the problem. I am resisting that because I'll have to download for a couple of days to get back all the updates. Beside that, I'd like to figure this out. I just don't have any more ideas or clues. It has to be something minor because everything else is working. I hope some one has seen something like this.
 
Ummmm...that's really odd.

Dumb question --> You stated that "other" players can't recognize the music CDs. Does that include Winamp?

 
If you right click on the file that is on the music cd and get the properties window, does it list the cd as a music cd? And if so does it have the correct "open with" program?
 
>If you right click on the file that is on the music cd and get the properties window, does
> it list the cd as a music cd? And if so does it have the correct "open with" program?

Right click on "Audio CD (Y🙂" and I get

" Type: CD Drive
File system: CDFS"

AutoPlay tab has:

"Music Files" in the content type box

The "Actions" box has "Prompt each time to choose an action" selected.

This is the same as on a version of XP that works right with music CDs.

If I go to the files on the CD (like Track05.cda) and right click for properties, I get

"Type of file: Winamp media file

Opens with: Winamp3"

I just installed Winamp3, as BlueWeasel suggested, so that's logical. It is the same as with XP that works.


Now that I installed Winamp3, things are slightly different than before. I still don't hear anything playing, but Winamp3 doesn't complain about the file scheme like Media Player does. The position slider moves as if its playing the file. It correctly identifies the time of each track.

There is one difference in the display when Winamp3 plays the files in a version of XP that works.

CD TRACK 05 (CDDA:44KHZ 16BIT)

versus

CD TRACK (MCI)

for non-working.

 
Do you get sound when you plug headphones/speakers directly into the CD drive? Also, are you sure that you don't have the CD music muted?
 
>Do you get sound when you plug headphones/speakers directly into the CD drive?
Not when Winamp3 looks like it is playing it. The CD light is not on. I can open the CD door and Winamp goes right on as if it is playing.

I tried the following experiment. I copied the Track05.cda file to the desktop in a version of XP where CDs play OK. It is 44 bytes, so it contains no music. But if have Winamp play it, it acts exactly like where it seems to play in a non-working XP, including having that "CD TRACK (MCI) " display difference. It has the proper track time too. Winamp3 is just not playing anything, although it look like it is.

>Also, are you sure that you don't have the CD music muted?

The mixer does not have CD audio, Wave, or Volume muted. Only line in is muted.
 
I reinstalled XP over itself. That fixed nothing. Kind of surprised me.


But it did lead to a cascade of problems due to the fact that it took off those nice security patches I've been installing over the months, and may have reset some settings. It seems that the next time I connected to the Internet I got the Welchia worm. That may have protected me against the Blaster worm though. Welchia deletes Blaster. Since I got the Zone Alarm firewall, that probably kept the Blaster from getting on board.

Unfortunately my ISP went out of business without any notice. So I couldn't get on the Internet, which lead to another cascade of trouble.


IAC, I still can't play music CDs, just as in the original post.

bump
 
Back
Top