I have a Pelican Eclipse... It's "ok", but not as good as a Controller -S, imho. The only real complaint that I have is that you have to push the buttons too hard to get them to react.
I'd love to try the Logitech (since Logitech rocks, and all...), but I find it hard to justify the $70 for it.
I'll just stick with my -S and an extension cable.
