X58 boards have issues with the Xeon CPU'S ?

jaggerwild

Guest
Sep 14, 2007
430
0
0
I figured I'd ask about this as Anandtech doesn't seem to care about it or the fact that the Giogabyte X58 Extreme and EVGA X58/Classified have issue's with certain power supply's.

Anybody who has these or had them care to chime in and share anything you have learned, or issue's you are having with them? I have read over at the "E" forum that Intel does not certify the EVGA board for the W3540 Xeon CPU'S, so if you buy this combo and the CPU should die on you then your SOL as far as they are concerned.
Not trying to flame or bad mouth ANY COMPANY! but as we spend the money for this stuff we should be kept in the loop or atleast made aware of these issue's. Matter of fact I think the two company's I mentioned as some of the best hardware company's out there, and both have gone out of there way to make me a happy consumer. So props to both of you!!!!
I can not say the same for Intel, as they sell these chips know ing they will be over clocked and done things with that we should not do, but then they pull the rug out on us when we need there help. Let's face it, there products are the most expensive we buy, so If I buy a $600 cpu and it craps out on me cause I put it in a certain board then yeah I think I should get a replacement or money back.
Iggy me if you must, I am NOT trying to stir to pot merely help my fellow geeks out and maybe save them a few head aches along the way. So we work together to better everybody all the way around, and we learn stuff as well.
Regards!
 

armstrda

Senior member
Sep 15, 2006
426
0
0
Considering the boards say they support Core i7 CPUs, that doesn't seem to encompass the W35xx Xeon series, so I would need to agree with the motherboard/CPU manufacturers in this case...
 

Beanie46

Senior member
Feb 16, 2009
527
0
0
Still don't understand what the OP is trying to say.....Intel's bad because they don't support/guarantee a cpu that's been run in a board that specifically isn't compatible and doesn't support said cpu? How horrible!

NOT!

You play with cpus that aren't specifically listed as compatible with specific boards and you're on your own completely and wholly responsible for anything that happens.....Intel's not.

 

jaggerwild

Guest
Sep 14, 2007
430
0
0
Originally posted by: Beanie46
Still don't understand what the OP is trying to say.....Intel's bad because they don't support/guarantee a cpu that's been run in a board that specifically isn't compatible and doesn't support said cpu? How horrible!

NOT!

You play with cpus that aren't specifically listed as compatible with specific boards and you're on your own completely and wholly responsible for anything that happens.....Intel's not.

How are they playing with them it's the same socket, I don't have one but had plained on getting one till now.
Only thing I was trying to say is people are having issue's not just the Xeon CPU, there is also the power supply problem. I'm not crying wolf just trying to be of help to those who may be having issue's and bad mouthing Intel too.
Regards!
 

PowerEngineer

Diamond Member
Oct 22, 2001
3,598
774
136

Well, the title on this thread was just what I was looking for.

I've only been recently put on to the fact that the W3520 Xeon is effectively identical to the Core i7 920. It's tempting (at least to me) to go with the Xeon as a way to ensure I get a D0 stepping CPU (the difference in price is only $30 at Newegg). It's also claimed that the Xeons are "higher binned", which I understand to mean that a higher proportion of the better performing chips are used for Xeon production. It's claimed that a 4 Ghz overclock with minimal voltage changes and heat are common.

As OP points out, however, none of the desktop X58 boards (that I know of) officially support the Xeon chip (although the new BIOS's open up overclocking and even recognize the chip in some cases). So we are taking something of a risk by pairing them up, but it seems (at least to me) to be similar to the risk we take when overclocking in the first place. Still, the thought of having an experience like the OP's has me "on the fence".

I was wonder how many people in the forums might already have taken this route. As I'm looking at the GA-EX58-UDP3, I'd be particularly interested in Gigabyte/W3520 experiences.

I'm also hoping that the OP will describe the power supply problems he alluded to.