WTF Should I Do?

Ulfhednar

Golden Member
Jun 24, 2006
1,031
0
0
Hey guys,

Due to ridiculously poor planning and impulse control I am having a very slight dilemma in regards to my build, and I could use some (any) input as to what my next moves should probably be. I currently have my main rig (see signature) housed in an Akasa Eclipse case, but I also have a half-built HTPC housed in a Silverstone Sugo case.

The half-built HTPC in question has a good PSU, an AM2 X2 3800+ CPU, a Thermalright SI-128 cooler, 512MB Kingston DDR2-667, a great DVD+RW drive and a temporary IDE hard disk. The only things it's lacking is a motherboard and suitable graphics card.

I was planning to build both machines up seperately, network them, and use my main rig for gaming with my Samsung Syncmaster 206BW for output and use the HTPC purely for storing/watching DVD and HD quality media on a Samsung Bordeaux or similar HDTV. I have, however, hit a fork in the road and the following options are available to me: -

a.) Continue to build up the HTPC in the Sugo case, keeping my gaming machine and media machine seperate (but networked) with their own dedicated displays and functions. Syncmaster for the former and Bordeaux for the latter.

b.) Do away with the entire idea of building a HTPC and connect a Bordeaux to the spare DVI output on my 8800GTS, using this singular machine as both a gaming machine and a media machine.

c.) Gut my main system and put all the components into the Sugo with a decent µATX motherboard. I am willing to sacrifice quite a bit of overclock if it means a much smaller and more portable case, while still being able to use the Sugo as a main/gaiming machine as well as a media machine.

I should probably point out that the Sugo in question has been modified to comfortably fit a Thermalright SI-128 CPU cooler and any graphics card up to the size of an 8800GTX, so space and temperatures won't really be a huge issue and I am willing to clock back (reasonably) in the name of keeping things cool enough. Anything left over will be sold on the Member's Market for reasonable prices.

What do you guys think? The prospect of going purely small form factor is bery attractive to me, but maybe it would be best to simpy carry on building the HTPC as an independent machine? Any help would be appreciated as it's beginning to really drive me up the wall to be honest.

Sincerely yours,
Ulfhedjinn.
 

myocardia

Diamond Member
Jun 21, 2003
9,291
30
91
A or B would definitely be the best way to go, since as far as I know, they don't make µATX overclocking motherboards. You'd likely be reducing your overclock from 3.5 Ghz to around 2.0-2.2 Ghz at best, if you tried option C. Option A would be the best, though, since you'd be able to game, while you recorded something for viewing at a later time. It would also be the most expensive, if money matters much to you.
 

Ulfhednar

Golden Member
Jun 24, 2006
1,031
0
0
Ah right, I was hoping I wouldn't have to cut the overclock that much. 2.8GHz-3.0GHz would've been a reasonable concession, but going all the way back to 2.2GHz would mean I might as well sell half of my components as they'd be overkill (memory etc.)

The main reason I am thinking about converting my main system to a small form factor is because, to be honest, I am not very happy with the P5B Deluxe or the Akasa Eclipse yet which is pretty sad considering they're premium parts and cost a small fortune. I had a Gigabyte DS3 before the P5B Deluxe, and in contrast, the P5B Deluxe runs much hotter and requires much more voltage to get a stable overclock. This case also seems to rattle like crazy, but I could correct that with noise reducing foam kits etc. if I had to.

Finishing off the HTPC build shouldn't really be expensive if I can find a basic µATX motherboard and very cheap graphics card, as I am guessing that even a Geforce 7300 would be ample for viewing 720p video and watching DVDs. If I were to do that though I would have a little problem as I'm completely uninformed when it comes to µATX motherboards, especially for the AM2 socket, and I have no idea if I would need to go for a graphics card with some form of HDMI connector on it or stick with DVI. :confused:

I'm a true newbie to the world of the HTPC, as you can probably tell.
 

Ulfhednar

Golden Member
Jun 24, 2006
1,031
0
0
Update: I just bought an Abit NFM-2S motherboard and Point Of View 7100GS. It was kind of an impulse buy, but I'll be able to finish off my HTPC tomorrow and stop worrying about all this. Now all I need to do is download Ubuntu and Linux MCE again.
 

betasub

Platinum Member
Mar 22, 2006
2,677
0
0
Originally posted by: Ulfhednar
Update: I just bought an Abit NFM-2S motherboard and Point Of View 7100GS. It was kind of an impulse buy, but I'll be able to finish off my HTPC tomorrow and stop worrying about all this. Now all I need to do is download Ubuntu and Linux MCE again.

I guess that makes option A your winner then.