WTF is with all of the BS "medicine" at Whole Foods.

Page 2 - Seeking answers? Join the AnandTech community: where nearly half-a-million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.

freegeeks

Diamond Member
May 7, 2001
5,460
1
81
I would assume it's because people might not know there's a medicine for their issue... or might be taking one med, which has some weird side effects, and aren't aware there's an alternative for it.

well, a doc tells me what the issue is and then prescribes the treatment, that's why you go to see a doc in the first place. I really don't see the point in ads for prescribtion meds
 

HeavyD

Senior member
Jul 2, 2007
204
0
0
It still comes down to choice, no one is forcing anyone to buy homeopathic medicine. If you don't like it then don't buy it.
 

Jeff7

Lifer
Jan 4, 2001
41,596
19
81
Not all of it is "voodoo"
Homeopathic is. That whole thing follows the idea that the more something is diluted, the more potent its effects, because the solvent allegedly "remembers" the properties of what it passed through. By that line of thinking, the water we ingest daily would remember a lot of things, such as exposure to mercury, arsenic, the digestive tracts of various dinosaurs and insects, some guy's ass, and dirt, among other things.
And it's so heavily diluted that calling it "diluted" isn't really accurate. It's more like a drawn-out filtration process which ends up removing nearly all, with the exception of a few molecules, of the desired substance.

The only thing it contains in abundance is a placebo effect, as well as the socially-damaging idea that such things are actually effective.
 
Last edited:

EagleKeeper

Discussion Club Moderator<br>Elite Member
Staff member
Oct 30, 2000
42,589
5
0
Price of their products is also very very high for the "Organics"

Forgot to get a couple of items when at Kroger earlier yesterday so stopped by the Whole Foods down the street from the hotel.

1 large Lemon
1 Large Tomato
1 Head lettuce

$6.31.


I can live with non-organically grown veggies at that price.
 

EagleKeeper

Discussion Club Moderator<br>Elite Member
Staff member
Oct 30, 2000
42,589
5
0
Fresh Market > Whole Foods

I would agree whole heart.

Have a Sunflower Market about 3 miles from house - much nicer place.

But people may not have much choice for comparisons.
 

LegendKiller

Lifer
Mar 5, 2001
18,256
68
86
Fresh Market > Whole Foods

Absolutely. FM has the best meat. Fruit and veggies are far better. Everything isn't even priced that far outside of a regular supermarket.

As far as WF being a "major chain", it is a major chain. It may be a niche market but comparing it to 7/11 or Krogers is silly, they don't operate in the same spectrum. Any stock analyst or business analyst would agree that WF is a major chain. They are national, they dominate their sector and are hugely popular.

The supplement market is just proof positive that a completely "free market" does nothing but screw consumers. If it were regulated by the FDA you'd see 95&#37; of those companies go out of business. There is marginal scientific evidence of that stuff helping, most "evidence" is anecdotal.
 
Last edited:

TheSlamma

Diamond Member
Sep 6, 2005
7,625
5
81
People demand cures. They get bullshit that is sold to them as cures and not the real cure. They assume the bullshit = real deal, but it's actually worthless. People do not buy this stuff going, "Oh this won't work." They buy it thinking, "This will work." But it never does ANYTHING but placebo effect. (Read: not a cure)

:colbert:
I totally agree with the placebo effect on the herb routine, but don't tell me there are REAL CURES in western medicine for anything out there either, there are just things that COVER UP problems.

Where is the cure for asthma, diabetics, cancer (remission doesn't count), the common cold, the flu, heck they don't even cure ED, all those pills do is give guys a 4 hour boner on the spot.. they stop taking them and they are a limp noodle.
 

Bignate603

Lifer
Sep 5, 2000
13,897
1
0
I would agree whole heart.

Have a Sunflower Market about 3 miles from house - much nicer place.

But people may not have much choice for comparisons.

We've got a sunflower nearby also. Less overpriced stuff yuppies will buy because it's the next hot new health food, more real tasty food at good prices. They sell these flour tortillas from a local company, they're the best that I've ever eaten that weren't handmade. Also, their thick cut bacon from the butcher's counter is amazingly good.
 

shortylickens

No Lifer
Jul 15, 2003
80,287
17,078
136
actually, thats one of the things I don't understand, what's the value of advertising prescription meds. Do people really go to the doc in the US and demand a med because they saw an ad for it?

this baffles my mind

Actually yes.
And most of the drugs they ask for dont cure anything and could be safely ignored if they lived a healthier lifestyle.
We spend billions to make ourselves fat then spend tens of billions to fix our fat asses.
No shit.
 

HeXen

Diamond Member
Dec 13, 2009
7,828
37
91
The only thing it contains in abundance is a placebo effect, as well as the socially-damaging idea that such things are actually effective.

placebo or not, what is the end result for the person?...it works. Even if it really doesnt really do anything, the persons brain is doing it for the drug, if thats what it takes to get someone by in life happy, then wtf does it matter if the drug really works or not? its the end result for the individual that matters.

I took some Ibuprofine this morning. Did it really do anything for me? i dunno.
Did my neck stop hurting....You bet:awe:
was the end result a placebo?...dont really give a crap now that it stopped hurting do i.
 

Bignate603

Lifer
Sep 5, 2000
13,897
1
0
Where is the cure for asthma, diabetics, cancer (remission doesn't count), the common cold, the flu, heck they don't even cure ED, all those pills do is give guys a 4 hour boner on the spot.. they stop taking them and they are a limp noodle.

So you're not happy with things that let people get back to living their lives?

Sorry, but the treatments have immense value. They improve people's lives and often save them. For instance, diabetics used to go blind, have their limbs slowly rot while still attached to them, then die a long painful death. On current meds they can live long, enjoyable lives.

The fact of the matter is that cures for the stuff you listed are ridiculously hard and have thus far eluded discovery, even after huge amounts of research and effort. Treatments in general are easier to find then cures. If you've convinced yourself that we don't have "cures" because it's some conspiracy to make more money go ahead and put on your tin foil hat. Just because you don't understand something doesn't suddenly make it easy.
 

DrPizza

Administrator Elite Member Goat Whisperer
Mar 5, 2001
49,601
166
111
www.slatebrookfarm.com
I totally agree with the placebo effect on the herb routine, but don't tell me there are REAL CURES in western medicine for anything out there either, there are just things that COVER UP problems.

Where is the cure for asthma, diabetics, cancer (remission doesn't count), the common cold, the flu, heck they don't even cure ED, all those pills do is give guys a 4 hour boner on the spot.. they stop taking them and they are a limp noodle.

Where's the homeopathic or natural cure for asthma, diabetes, cancer, etc.? Remission = "may be cured, may not be cured. It's undetectable, may not come back, may come back."

And, by the way, in case you're one of the idiots who thinks that pharmaceutical companies would sit on a cure for "cancer", (or for the idiots out there who would believe it) - anyone coming up with a cure will be able to dictate price until their patent runs out, and is going to make so much money, it's ridiculous. I use "cancer" in quotes, because it's more of a class of diseases with similarities, rather than just one thing that can be cured.
 
Last edited:

CZroe

Lifer
Jun 24, 2001
24,195
857
126
I totally agree with the placebo effect on the herb routine, but don't tell me there are REAL CURES in western medicine for anything out there either, there are just things that COVER UP problems.

Where is the cure for asthma, diabetics, cancer (remission doesn't count), the common cold, the flu, heck they don't even cure ED, all those pills do is give guys a 4 hour boner on the spot.. they stop taking them and they are a limp noodle.

Are you ignorant? Antibiotics cure infections all the time. Antifungal and antiparisitic "cures" exist too. If I have tapeworms and I deworm myself with western medicine, am I not cured?
 

Zebo

Elite Member
Jul 29, 2001
39,398
19
81
Some of that stuff works for me. Not from whole foods though, internet FTW.

I am a larger man who runs 6x a week.

I use DMSO on my frequent injuries and calves. Heals much faster.

I piss a glow stick from vitamins I take, feel groggy when I don't take them.

I take a MSM/condriotin supplement for my knees and I think it's like lube. No more grinding.

YMMV
 

nanette1985

Diamond Member
Oct 12, 2005
4,209
2
0
That just sounds funny to actually say that. What have we become where organic and natural things are a niche and not standard.

If you grew up on a farm, as I did, you'd know that Whole Foods' version of "organic and natural" isn't what you get from nature.
 
Last edited:

qliveur

Diamond Member
Mar 25, 2007
4,086
70
91
Some of that stuff works for me. Not from whole foods though, internet FTW.

I am a larger man who runs 6x a week.

I use DMSO on my frequent injuries and calves. Heals much faster.

I piss a glow stick from vitamins I take, feel groggy when I don't take them.

I take a MSM/condriotin supplement for my knees and I think it's like lube. No more grinding.

YMMV
I use royal jelly to control my psoriasis.
 

Cerb

Elite Member
Aug 26, 2000
17,484
33
86
Um. I'm gonna say that although the pharmaceutical industry is not morally pure... it is far more effective than homeopathy.(>0)
Strawman, as usual. Because some people are dumb enough to buy into homeopathy, and Whole Foods is willing to make money off of them, the other 99&#37; is also bunk, despite having proven ingredients (though, even some that aren't just water are placebo :)), that just happen to on the food side of the FDA's lists, because our laws do not have a quality middle ground?

Really, the core problem is that our laws are based on large companies creating goods to market, not science. If US medicinal laws and regulations were based on science, the government would foot the bill for further tests, and have genuinely independent panels making pass/fail/Rx-only decisions (no fast tracking, either), if a scientist were to figure out that <chemical X> does <something good>, and needed to go that step further to be able to say it should be allowed for use as a treatment. Also, many controlled substances would never have been allowed to become such. Our system is designed around deep pockets and conflicts of interest. Good can and does come from it, but it is not the only source, and the best we can do, apparently, is leave a gaping hole open.

It's not that pharmaceuticals do not work, but that they are not the only thing that works, and one way or another, people want to allow things that do work to remain available. Everything that is edible and not junk food is analogous to a medicine.

Many of us also have no problems with people being stupid. How is it my problem that other people want to remain ignorant, and trust in placebo? I fail to see a problem:
a) You know very well it is BS, but are in denial, for unknown reasons.
b) You are gullible enough to believe someone, and not check your facts, which is easy to do, for this kind of thing.
c) You are a complete moron.
In all cases, a licensed medical professional is not consulted, nor did they do any research on their own about what ails them, nor about the proposed remedy (even a good food or supplement to use as a remedy may have side effects, which the web makes insanely easy to find out about). Children represent the only gray area, where legal protection could be defensible.

You cannot find most of the stuff you can get at Whole Foods at Waldbaums or Pathmark or Stop & Shop or Price Chopper.
Not exactly. Most of their canned and boxed goods are approximately the same as high-end brands sold in other super markets, and many are no better than what I commonly find at bargain stores. Produce is an exception (though, in my area, non-Organic produce from Fresh Market and Publix is every bit as good, there just isn't as much exotic stuff at either place, compared to a typical WF).
 
Last edited:

zinfamous

No Lifer
Jul 12, 2006
111,095
30,041
146
Went to Whole Foods today and for the first time decided to look at the so called "medicine" isle. Almost nothing but bullshit remedies. The worst was this large section for so called homeopathic "medicine". I cannot believe a major chain is peddling this garbage.

Whole Foods is a massive scam. Those that dig homeopathy truly believe that Whole Foods deals with legit organics.
 

zinfamous

No Lifer
Jul 12, 2006
111,095
30,041
146
maybe in New Zealand where there's only 1 or 2 supermarkets that's a major chain..

but here in the USA.. it's not

The Kroger Co. is a $76.7 Billion company with 3,619 stores. And they're not even national.
Safeway is a $40.9 Billion company with 1,501 stores in the United States and 224 stores in Canada.

Whole Foods is a minor, niche player.

It's a niche market, relatively speaking, within the Grocery market, but they dominate that market. They've bought up nearly all of their competitors. They are coast to coast--not sure how you can consider them bit players.

:hmm:
 

Jeff7

Lifer
Jan 4, 2001
41,596
19
81
placebo or not, what is the end result for the person?...it works. Even if it really doesnt really do anything, the persons brain is doing it for the drug, if thats what it takes to get someone by in life happy, then wtf does it matter if the drug really works or not?
It's bad because people are merely meant to believe that they're actually getting genuine medicine, which can be dangerous because then they're more likely not to pursue options grounded in real medical science. Sometimes it's a minor thing, like a bit of a headache. Then there's no problem. But if you're pursuing a homeopathic remedy for, let's say a bite from an inland taipan, you're probably not going to be buying much of anything anymore.
Wasting money and industry on these things is also a drain on society's resources, as well as a detriment to real science.
I'll let James Randi continue. :)

On the other hand, it's also yet another example of a free-market tax on stupidity/ignorance. It's better than snake oil! It's magic!



its the end result for the individual that matters.
The ends don't always justify the means.



I took some Ibuprofine this morning. Did it really do anything for me? i dunno.
Did my neck stop hurting....You bet:awe:
was the end result a placebo?...dont really give a crap now that it stopped hurting do i.
One way to find out would be a blind test with placebos. If it's a placebo effect, you might as well swap out the ibuprofen with a multivitamin.



I totally agree with the placebo effect on the herb routine, but don't tell me there are REAL CURES in western medicine for anything out there either, there are just things that COVER UP problems.

Where is the cure for asthma, diabetics, cancer (remission doesn't count), the common cold, the flu, heck they don't even cure ED, all those pills do is give guys a 4 hour boner on the spot.. they stop taking them and they are a limp noodle.
If only evolution were a lie too - then at least curing the cold and flu would be fairly easy. :awe:
 
Last edited: