Originally posted by: Concillian
Unless you consider level 55 'low level' I don't think I am comparing very low level characters. You're simply way off base with your 4x comment.
You *can* do damge faster, but overall killing rate is also dependent on mana regen. And it's not like a holy or disc preist pulls with a wand. MB or MB+ Smite frontloads significant damage as well.
I urge you to try it out before making rash comments.
I provide below two logs. The first is using mindblast, sw

and wand to kill a mob in caster form. This takes 40 seconds, but the character in question still has +10% to shadow damage, 2 extra ticks of SW

and a decent chunk of extra damage from shadow weaving and +140 shadow damage. ( I was going to do a respecced comparison from test but the char copy was down ) The second log is using mindblast, sw

, then mindflay to kill an identical mob - time taken 13 seconds.
I know you might *think* that wanding is comparable to mindflay, but consider than even the level 44 mindflay does 155 damage a second, and a good wand at level 50 does 40.
For mobs that can heal, the lack of silence throws the comparison even further out of line.
I have also, for amusement's sake, included as the third log, killing a +2 level elite, using no potions or external buffs. For that kind of situation the difference is not between 13 seconds and 40 seconds, but more the difference between easily done and not a chance in hell.
----
9/3 14:04:19.750 Your Mind Blast hits Saltwater Snapjaw for 220. (220 resisted)
9/3 14:04:20.625 Saltwater Snapjaw is afflicted by Shadow Word: Pain.
9/3 14:04:22.765 Your Shoot hits Saltwater Snapjaw for 54.
9/3 14:04:23.281 Saltwater Snapjaw suffers 123 Shadow damage from your Shadow Word: Pain.
9/3 14:04:23.906 Your Shoot hits Saltwater Snapjaw for 39.
9/3 14:04:25.437 Your Shoot was resisted by Saltwater Snapjaw.
9/3 14:04:26.265 Saltwater Snapjaw suffers 123 Shadow damage from your Shadow Word: Pain.
9/3 14:04:26.828 Your Shoot hits Saltwater Snapjaw for 56.
9/3 14:04:28.171 Your Shoot hits Saltwater Snapjaw for 52.
9/3 14:04:29.421 Saltwater Snapjaw suffers 123 Shadow damage from your Shadow Word: Pain.
9/3 14:04:29.765 Your Shoot hits Saltwater Snapjaw for 55.
9/3 14:04:31.265 Your Shoot hits Saltwater Snapjaw for 47.
9/3 14:04:32.375 Saltwater Snapjaw suffers 123 Shadow damage from your Shadow Word: Pain.
9/3 14:04:35.171 Your Mind Blast hits Saltwater Snapjaw for 472.
9/3 14:04:35.328 Saltwater Snapjaw suffers 126 Shadow damage from your Shadow Word: Pain.
9/3 14:04:36.953 Your Shoot hits Saltwater Snapjaw for 51.
9/3 14:04:38.390 Saltwater Snapjaw suffers 127 Shadow damage from your Shadow Word: Pain.
9/3 14:04:38.390 Your Shoot hits Saltwater Snapjaw for 41.
9/3 14:04:40.078 Your Shoot hits Saltwater Snapjaw for 63.
9/3 14:04:41.406 Saltwater Snapjaw suffers 126 Shadow damage from your Shadow Word: Pain.
9/3 14:04:41.734 Your Shoot hits Saltwater Snapjaw for 50.
9/3 14:04:43.109 Your Shoot hits Saltwater Snapjaw for 39.
9/3 14:04:44.406 Saltwater Snapjaw suffers 126 Shadow damage from your Shadow Word: Pain.
9/3 14:04:44.406 Your Shoot hits Saltwater Snapjaw for 48.
9/3 14:04:44.796 Shadow Word: Pain fades from Saltwater Snapjaw.
9/3 14:04:46.515 Your Shoot hits Saltwater Snapjaw for 46.
9/3 14:04:48.265 Your Shoot was resisted by Saltwater Snapjaw.
9/3 14:04:49.625 Your Shoot hits Saltwater Snapjaw for 59.
9/3 14:04:50.375 Shadow Vulnerability fades from Saltwater Snapjaw.
9/3 14:04:51.140 Your Shoot hits Saltwater Snapjaw for 68.
9/3 14:04:52.484 Your Shoot hits Saltwater Snapjaw for 49. (16 resisted)
9/3 14:04:54.296 Your Shoot hits Saltwater Snapjaw for 65.
9/3 14:04:58.953 Your Mind Blast hits Saltwater Snapjaw for 443.
9/3 14:04:58.953 Saltwater Snapjaw dies, you gain 628 experience. (+314 exp Rested bonus)
9/3 14:04:59.171 You gain Spirit Tap.
---
9/3 14:01:51.812 Your Mind Blast hits Saltwater Snapjaw for 514.
9/3 14:01:52.218 Saltwater Snapjaw is afflicted by Shadow Vulnerability.
9/3 14:01:52.437 Saltwater Snapjaw is afflicted by Shadow Word: Pain.
9/3 14:01:53.687 Saltwater Snapjaw is afflicted by Mind Flay.
9/3 14:01:54.609 Saltwater Snapjaw suffers 146 Shadow damage from your Mind Flay.
9/3 14:01:55.156 Saltwater Snapjaw suffers 145 Shadow damage from your Shadow Word: Pain.
9/3 14:01:55.765 Saltwater Snapjaw suffers 145 Shadow damage from your Mind Flay.
9/3 14:01:56.593 Saltwater Snapjaw suffers 146 Shadow damage from your Mind Flay.
9/3 14:01:56.953 Saltwater Snapjaw attacks. You absorb all the damage.
9/3 14:01:58.000 Saltwater Snapjaw suffers 149 Shadow damage from your Mind Flay.
9/3 14:01:58.187 Saltwater Snapjaw suffers 149 Shadow damage from your Shadow Word: Pain.
9/3 14:01:58.718 Saltwater Snapjaw suffers 149 Shadow damage from your Mind Flay.
9/3 14:01:59.093 Saltwater Snapjaw attacks. You absorb all the damage.
9/3 14:01:59.843 Saltwater Snapjaw suffers 149 Shadow damage from your Mind Flay.
9/3 14:02:00.187 Mind Flay fades from Saltwater Snapjaw.
9/3 14:02:00.453 Saltwater Snapjaw is afflicted by Mind Flay.
9/3 14:02:00.921 Saltwater Snapjaw attacks. You absorb all the damage.
9/3 14:02:01.093 Saltwater Snapjaw suffers 153 Shadow damage from your Shadow Word: Pain.
9/3 14:02:01.093 Saltwater Snapjaw suffers 153 Shadow damage from your Mind Flay.
9/3 14:02:02.218 Saltwater Snapjaw suffers 153 Shadow damage from your Mind Flay.
9/3 14:02:02.906 Saltwater Snapjaw attacks. You absorb all the damage.
9/3 14:02:03.078 Saltwater Snapjaw suffers 153 Shadow damage from your Mind Flay.
9/3 14:02:03.281 Mind Flay fades from Saltwater Snapjaw.
9/3 14:02:04.515 Saltwater Snapjaw is afflicted by Mind Flay.
9/3 14:02:04.515 Saltwater Snapjaw suffers 154 Shadow damage from your Shadow Word: Pain.
9/3 14:02:04.515 Saltwater Snapjaw suffers 153 Shadow damage from your Mind Flay.
9/3 14:02:05.140 Saltwater Snapjaw attacks. You absorb all the damage.
9/3 14:02:05.312 Saltwater Snapjaw suffers 153 Shadow damage from your Mind Flay.
9/3 14:02:06.484 Saltwater Snapjaw suffers 154 Shadow damage from your Mind Flay.
9/3 14:02:06.484 Saltwater Snapjaw dies.
---
9/3 13:42:28.140 Your Mind Blast hits Cliff Giant for 511.
9/3 13:42:30.671 Your Shadow Vulnerability was resisted by Cliff Giant.
9/3 13:42:31.015 Cliff Giant is afflicted by Mind Flay.
9/3 13:42:31.250 Cliff Giant is afflicted by Blackout.
9/3 13:42:31.437 Cliff Giant suffers 141 Shadow damage from your Shadow Word: Pain.
9/3 13:42:31.625 Cliff Giant suffers 142 Shadow damage from your Mind Flay.
9/3 13:42:32.625 Cliff Giant suffers 141 Shadow damage from your Mind Flay.
9/3 13:42:33.484 Cliff Giant suffers 142 Shadow damage from your Mind Flay.
9/3 13:42:33.812 Mind Flay fades from Cliff Giant.
9/3 13:42:34.156 Cliff Giant is afflicted by Mind Flay.
9/3 13:42:34.156 Blackout fades from Cliff Giant.
9/3 13:42:34.625 Cliff Giant suffers 145 Shadow damage from your Shadow Word: Pain.
9/3 13:42:34.812 Cliff Giant suffers 145 Shadow damage from your Mind Flay.
9/3 13:42:35.843 Cliff Giant suffers 146 Shadow damage from your Mind Flay.
9/3 13:42:36.656 Cliff Giant suffers 145 Shadow damage from your Mind Flay.
9/3 13:42:37.015 Mind Flay fades from Cliff Giant.
9/3 13:42:37.453 Your Blackout was resisted by Cliff Giant.
9/3 13:42:37.750 Cliff Giant suffers 149 Shadow damage from your Shadow Word: Pain.
9/3 13:42:37.765 Cliff Giant is afflicted by Mind Flay.
9/3 13:42:38.078 Cliff Giant attacks. You absorb all the damage.
9/3 13:42:38.859 Cliff Giant suffers 149 Shadow damage from your Mind Flay.
9/3 13:42:39.328 Cliff Giant suffers 149 Shadow damage from your Mind Flay.
9/3 13:42:40.593 Mind Flay fades from Cliff Giant.
9/3 13:42:40.593 Cliff Giant suffers 153 Shadow damage from your Shadow Word: Pain.
9/3 13:42:40.796 Cliff Giant attacks. You absorb all the damage.
9/3 13:42:40.984 Cliff Giant is afflicted by Mind Flay.
9/3 13:42:41.515 Cliff Giant suffers 153 Shadow damage from your Mind Flay.
9/3 13:42:42.093 Weakened Soul fades from you.
9/3 13:42:42.515 Cliff Giant suffers 153 Shadow damage from your Mind Flay.
9/3 13:42:43.437 Cliff Giant suffers 153 Shadow damage from your Shadow Word: Pain.
9/3 13:42:43.625 Cliff Giant attacks. You absorb all the damage.
9/3 13:42:43.625 Cliff Giant suffers 153 Shadow damage from your Mind Flay.
9/3 13:42:43.796 Mind Flay fades from Cliff Giant.
9/3 13:42:46.375 Cliff Giant attacks. You absorb all the damage.
9/3 13:42:46.625 Cliff Giant suffers 153 Shadow damage from your Shadow Word: Pain.
9/3 13:42:46.921 You are afflicted by Weakened Soul.
9/3 13:42:47.640 You fail to cast Mind Flay: Not yet recovered.
9/3 13:42:48.937 Cliff Giant attacks. You absorb all the damage.
9/3 13:42:49.578 Cliff Giant suffers 153 Shadow damage from your Shadow Word: Pain.
9/3 13:42:49.734 Cliff Giant is afflicted by Mind Flay.
9/3 13:42:50.328 Cliff Giant suffers 153 Shadow damage from your Mind Flay.
9/3 13:42:51.484 Cliff Giant suffers 153 Shadow damage from your Mind Flay.
9/3 13:42:51.656 Cliff Giant misses you.
9/3 13:42:52.359 Cliff Giant suffers 153 Shadow damage from your Mind Flay.
9/3 13:42:52.531 Cliff Giant suffers 115 Shadow damage from your Shadow Word: Pain. (33 resisted)
9/3 13:42:52.531 Shadow Word: Pain fades from Cliff Giant.
9/3 13:42:52.531 Mind Flay fades from Cliff Giant.
9/3 13:42:53.046 Cliff Giant is afflicted by Mind Flay.
9/3 13:42:53.328 Cliff Giant is afflicted by Blackout.
9/3 13:42:53.718 Cliff Giant suffers 153 Shadow damage from your Mind Flay.
9/3 13:42:54.578 Cliff Giant suffers 153 Shadow damage from your Mind Flay.
9/3 13:42:55.531 Cliff Giant suffers 153 Shadow damage from your Mind Flay.
9/3 13:42:56.031 Mind Flay fades from Cliff Giant.
9/3 13:42:56.328 Blackout fades from Cliff Giant.
9/3 13:42:56.531 Cliff Giant attacks. You absorb all the damage.
9/3 13:42:56.890 Cliff Giant is afflicted by Shadow Word: Pain.
9/3 13:42:58.250 Cliff Giant is afflicted by Mind Flay.
9/3 13:42:58.750 Cliff Giant suffers 153 Shadow damage from your Mind Flay.
9/3 13:42:59.765 Cliff Giant suffers 153 Shadow damage from your Shadow Word: Pain.
9/3 13:42:59.765 Cliff Giant hits you for 129. (25 absorbed)
9/3 13:42:59.781 Power Word: Shield fades from you.
9/3 13:42:59.781 Cliff Giant suffers 153 Shadow damage from your Mind Flay.
9/3 13:43:00.359 Mind Flay fades from Cliff Giant.
9/3 13:43:02.156 Cliff Giant is afflicted by Psychic Scream.
9/3 13:43:02.468 Cliff Giant suffers 153 Shadow damage from your Shadow Word: Pain.
9/3 13:43:04.156 Cliff Giant is afflicted by Mind Flay.
9/3 13:43:04.609 Cliff Giant is afflicted by Blackout.
9/3 13:43:04.953 Cliff Giant suffers 153 Shadow damage from your Mind Flay.
9/3 13:43:05.312 Cliff Giant suffers 153 Shadow damage from your Shadow Word: Pain.
9/3 13:43:05.828 Blackout fades from Cliff Giant.
9/3 13:43:05.828 Cliff Giant suffers 154 Shadow damage from your Mind Flay.
9/3 13:43:06.843 Your Shadow Vulnerability was resisted by Cliff Giant.
9/3 13:43:07.984 Cliff Giant suffers 154 Shadow damage from your Mind Flay.
9/3 13:43:08.359 Cliff Giant suffers 153 Shadow damage from your Shadow Word: Pain.
9/3 13:43:08.906 Psychic Scream fades from Cliff Giant.
9/3 13:43:08.906 Cliff Giant suffers 153 Shadow damage from your Mind Flay.
9/3 13:43:09.796 Cliff Giant suffers 153 Shadow damage from your Mind Flay.
9/3 13:43:10.453 Mind Flay fades from Cliff Giant.
9/3 13:43:10.625 Cliff Giant is afflicted by Mind Flay.
9/3 13:43:11.171 Cliff Giant suffers 153 Shadow damage from your Shadow Word: Pain.
9/3 13:43:11.328 Cliff Giant suffers 153 Shadow damage from your Mind Flay.
9/3 13:43:11.828 Weakened Soul fades from you.
9/3 13:43:12.375 Cliff Giant suffers 153 Shadow damage from your Mind Flay.
9/3 13:43:13.218 Cliff Giant suffers 154 Shadow damage from your Mind Flay.
9/3 13:43:13.578 Mind Flay fades from Cliff Giant.
9/3 13:43:13.796 Cliff Giant is afflicted by Mind Flay.
9/3 13:43:14.328 Cliff Giant suffers 153 Shadow damage from your Shadow Word: Pain.
9/3 13:43:14.609 Cliff Giant dies.