WoW trial keys if anybody wants them

Page 3 - Seeking answers? Join the AnandTech community: where nearly half-a-million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.

cKGunslinger

Lifer
Nov 29, 1999
16,408
57
91
Originally posted by: TheUnk
Originally posted by: pontifex
what mmo doesn't have "childish" graphics? they are all cartoony...

Most MMOs don't.

You know there is a huge difference visually when a developer attempts to make a game look realistic vs. one who attemps to make a game look cartoony.

I understand what you mean about cartoony graphics, but all the Warcraft games have been designed that way - it's a stylized choice on the designers' part. I realize some people are turned off by such, as it's simply a matter of personal taste.

To me, the graphics offer a much more thematic, clean, and consistent look than any other MMORPG. EQ2 may have "more realistic" graphics, but to me they are still jutty, blocky, and drab - they do more to detract from the game than to enhance it.

Also, I would guess that the "cartoony" style has a greater longevity than a "realistic" style. Compare Oblivion's graphics to EQ2. Realistic graphics continously improve, making only slightly-older games look like crap in comparison. Now compare Oblivion to WoW. The thing is, you really can't because they are two totally different styles, therefore it's harder to make WoW look "dated" by ever-changing technology.

I'm not sure if this was done on purpose or not, but it makes Blizzard geniuses, IMO. And for updates, rather than having to go back and update all teh model's poly-counts and textures, they can keep everything the same and add other elements, like the recent weather effects and additional spell-effect graphics.
 

TheUnk

Golden Member
Jun 24, 2005
1,810
0
71
I still think WoW could have looked a lot better while still maintaining it's style.


I really don't know.. If this is how they wanted WarCraft to always be, then why make the cutscenes in previous games look so realistic and completely different to what they are now?

Was it truely a style or a business move to make the game playable on a much wider range of hardware and therefore make more money..

Either way, they ripped off Warhammers art style in the first place =p
 

pontifex

Lifer
Dec 5, 2000
43,804
46
91
Originally posted by: TheUnk
Originally posted by: pontifex
what mmo doesn't have "childish" graphics? they are all cartoony...

Most MMOs don't.

You know there is a huge difference visually when a developer attempts to make a game look realistic vs. one who attemps to make a game look cartoony.

EQ2 - Gumby, claymation characters
DAOC - cartoony
CoH/CoV - comic book cartoony
Final Fantasy XI - anime-sh cartoony
AA - cartoony
AO - cartoony
DDO - cartoony
RFO - anime-sh cartoony
Lineage 2 - anime-ish cartoony
MXO - cartoony
SWG - cartoony

shall i continue?
 

TheUnk

Golden Member
Jun 24, 2005
1,810
0
71
Originally posted by: pontifex

EQ2 - Gumby, claymation characters
DAOC - cartoony
CoH/CoV - comic book cartoony
Final Fantasy XI - anime-sh cartoony
AA - cartoony
AO - cartoony
DDO - cartoony
RFO - anime-sh cartoony
Lineage 2 - anime-ish cartoony
MXO - cartoony
SWG - cartoony

shall i continue?


Hense the reason for calling WoW childish cartoony and not just cartoony, is that what you are saying?
 

pontifex

Lifer
Dec 5, 2000
43,804
46
91
Originally posted by: TheUnk
Originally posted by: pontifex

EQ2 - Gumby, claymation characters
DAOC - cartoony
CoH/CoV - comic book cartoony
Final Fantasy XI - anime-sh cartoony
AA - cartoony
AO - cartoony
DDO - cartoony
RFO - anime-sh cartoony
Lineage 2 - anime-ish cartoony
MXO - cartoony
SWG - cartoony

shall i continue?


Hense the reason for calling WoW childish cartoony and not just cartoony, is that what you are saying?

but i thought "cartoons are made for children" hence, they are childish?
 

TheUnk

Golden Member
Jun 24, 2005
1,810
0
71
Originally posted by: pontifex
but i thought "cartoons are made for children" hence, they are childish?

Pretty sure another guy said that, not me.

I said the graphics were childish, which they are. Hell even the orcs are on the verge of being cuddly. Zug Zug, aww give us a hug. And the undead could easily be found in an episode of Scooby Doo.
 

TheUnk

Golden Member
Jun 24, 2005
1,810
0
71
Also, I would guess that the "cartoony" style has a greater longevity than a "realistic" style. Compare Oblivion's graphics to EQ2. Realistic graphics continously improve, making only slightly-older games look like crap in comparison. Now compare Oblivion to WoW. The thing is, you really can't because they are two totally different styles, therefore it's harder to make WoW look "dated" by ever-changing technology.


WoW looks dated to me:

Warhammer Ork vs. WoW Orc


Warhammer Ork vs. WoW Orc

I will admit though that the 2nd WoW orc does not look as bad as what I saw in game. The 1st one seems to be more accurate to what I have seen.