• We’re currently investigating an issue related to the forum theme and styling that is impacting page layout and visual formatting. The problem has been identified, and we are actively working on a resolution. There is no impact to user data or functionality, this is strictly a front-end display issue. We’ll post an update once the fix has been deployed. Thanks for your patience while we get this sorted.

Wow...just wow!

TheChort

Diamond Member
EDIT: PLEASE AVOID turning this into an anti-islamic debate
But feel free to make fun of the government officials involved 😀

http://news.yahoo.com/s/nm/20060327/od_nm/india_religion_dc
NEW DELHI (Reuters) - A Muslim couple in India has been told by local Islamic leaders they must separate after the husband "divorced" his wife in his sleep, the Press Trust of India reported.

ADVERTISEMENT

Sohela Ansari told friends that her husband Aftab had uttered the word "talaq," or divorce, three times in his sleep, according to the report published in newspapers Monday.

When local Islamic leaders got to hear, they said Aftab's words constituted a divorce under an Islamic procedure known as "triple talaq." The couple, married for 11 years with three children, were told they had to split.

The religious leaders ruled that if the couple wanted to remarry they would have to wait at least 100 days. Sohela would also have to spend a night with another man and be divorced by him in turn.

The couple, who live in the eastern state of West Bengal, have refused to obey the order and the issue has been referred to a local family counseling center.

India's minority Muslim population is governed by Islamic personal laws on issues such as marriage, divorce and property inheritance.

"This is a totally unnecessary controversy and the local 'community leaders' or whosoever has said it are totally ignorant of Islamic law," said Zafarul-Islam Khan, an Islamic scholar and editor of The Milli Gazette, a popular Muslim newspaper.

"The law clearly says any action under compulsion or in a state of intoxication has no effect. The case of someone uttering something while asleep falls under this category and will have no impact whatsoever," Khan told Reuters.

[/speechless]
 
I'm sorry, but Islam is an insane religion. Scientology is worse, but Islam is a close second.

Yeah, the Bible has lots of crazy stuff in it just like the Koran, but too many Muslims take their book waaaaay too seriously
 
Originally posted by: Eeezee
I'm sorry, but Islam is an insane religion. Scientology is worse, but Islam is a close second.

Yeah, the Bible has lots of crazy stuff in it just like the Koran, but too many Muslims take their book waaaaay too seriously

you're a moron. any excessively religious person is a damn moron and blind to the real world.

i despise the haters on islam. people quickly forget the atrocities or even the ridiculous quirks of other religions...
 
An Indian woman that I worked with told me that a while back, but to me it just presents too many problems. Do they have to say talaq three times in quick succession? If so, how much time is allowed between utterances? If not, then can I say talaq three times over the course of three years and accomplish the same? Does my wife have to be present? What if she doesn't hear it?

A little silly, imo.
 
Originally posted by: maziwanka
Originally posted by: Eeezee
I'm sorry, but Islam is an insane religion. Scientology is worse, but Islam is a close second.

Yeah, the Bible has lots of crazy stuff in it just like the Koran, but too many Muslims take their book waaaaay too seriously

you're a moron. any excessively religious person is a damn moron and blind to the real world.

i despise the haters on islam. people quickly forget the atrocities or even the ridiculous quirks of other religions...

and other people pretend all ideologies are equal. let alone equally flawed when this is obviously false. its politically correct to try and claim allthings are equal, but they arent. its idiotic, and especially bad when used to cover up the problems of islam.
 
Originally posted by: maziwanka
Originally posted by: Eeezee
I'm sorry, but Islam is an insane religion. Scientology is worse, but Islam is a close second.

Yeah, the Bible has lots of crazy stuff in it just like the Koran, but too many Muslims take their book waaaaay too seriously

you're a moron. any excessively religious person is a damn moron and blind to the real world.

i despise the haters on islam. people quickly forget the atrocities or even the ridiculous quirks of other religions...

That's almost exactly what I said. The difference between Islam and Christianity is number of extremists, making Islam the worse religion. When the extremists have power your religion tends to suck. You can see this with Christianity throughout various periods in history.

In conclusion, you are an idiot.
 
Originally posted by: Eeezee
I'm sorry, but Islam is an insane religion. Scientology is worse, but Islam is a close second.

Yeah, the Bible has lots of crazy stuff in it just like the Koran, but too many Muslims take their book waaaaay too seriously

all religions are insane.
and west bengal...thats where I'm from. Im glad to see that the couple isnt following the ruling of the leaders.
 
Originally posted by: maziwanka
Originally posted by: Eeezee
I'm sorry, but Islam is an insane religion. Scientology is worse, but Islam is a close second.

Yeah, the Bible has lots of crazy stuff in it just like the Koran, but too many Muslims take their book waaaaay too seriously

you're a moron. any excessively religious person is a damn moron and blind to the real world.

i despise the haters on islam. people quickly forget the atrocities or even the ridiculous quirks of other religions...

I personally prefer secular rule to non- because people are much more willing to change their ways when they are not rooted in religion.

Still, why be concerned with what any religion made people do in the past? I'm most concerned with what religion will make people do in the future
 
This is the WTF of the week.

If only she heard it then how do the religious leaders know unless she told them?
If both of them wanted to stay together why the heck did they tell them?
 
This is a good illustration of the points made in the thread last week about the failure of islam. (edit: I guess that thread was in P&N.)
 
Originally posted by: Cooler
This is the WTF of the week.

If only she heard it then how do the religious leaders know unless she told them?
If both of them wanted to stay together why the heck did they tell them?

if you check the article again, you'll see the authorities found out through the newspaper article
I wouldn't be surprised if they just gossiped about it to their friends, and some nut at the paper got wind of it and decided to publish it
 
Originally posted by: Eeezee
Originally posted by: maziwanka
Originally posted by: Eeezee
I'm sorry, but Islam is an insane religion. Scientology is worse, but Islam is a close second.

Yeah, the Bible has lots of crazy stuff in it just like the Koran, but too many Muslims take their book waaaaay too seriously

you're a moron. any excessively religious person is a damn moron and blind to the real world.

i despise the haters on islam. people quickly forget the atrocities or even the ridiculous quirks of other religions...

That's almost exactly what I said. The difference between Islam and Christianity is number of extremists, making Islam the worse religion. When the extremists have power your religion tends to suck. You can see this with Christianity throughout various periods in history.

In conclusion, you are an idiot.

I agree. Another example in CNN.com today where hundreds of people are protesting in Afghanistan, calling for the death of the Christian convert.
 
Originally posted by: Astaroth33
Originally posted by: Eeezee
Originally posted by: maziwanka
Originally posted by: Eeezee
I'm sorry, but Islam is an insane religion. Scientology is worse, but Islam is a close second.

Yeah, the Bible has lots of crazy stuff in it just like the Koran, but too many Muslims take their book waaaaay too seriously

you're a moron. any excessively religious person is a damn moron and blind to the real world.

i despise the haters on islam. people quickly forget the atrocities or even the ridiculous quirks of other religions...

That's almost exactly what I said. The difference between Islam and Christianity is number of extremists, making Islam the worse religion. When the extremists have power your religion tends to suck. You can see this with Christianity throughout various periods in history.

In conclusion, you are an idiot.

I agree. Another example in CNN.com today where hundreds of people are protesting in Afghanistan, calling for the death of the Christian convert.
The USA should Air lift the guy out if he is acquitted he will be killed.
 
It just came to my realization that here we are worrying about what happens to a couple in western bengal. It just seems...silly? 😛
 
Originally posted by: everman
It just came to my realization that here we are worrying about what happens to a couple in western bengal. It just seems...silly? 😛

i like to think of it as ... broadening my perspectives 😛
 
Originally posted by: everman
It just came to my realization that here we are worrying about what happens to a couple in western bengal. It just seems...silly? 😛

It's a microcosm that reflects the entire Islamic world.
 
Back
Top