Windows XP - Bad Disc?

RossAdamBaker

Member
Jun 10, 2004
25
0
0
Hello o gurus,

One more question on my struggle to build a new computer, this time hardware related. It all started while I was feeling noble and decided to actually purchase a real, full version of Windows XP Pro. I have a academic version from my local college, but wanted a good version. So, I picked a Windows XP Professional Full SP1 OEM disc/keycode up for 100 bucks on the net. I got it, the disc looks great, all the holographics and genuine and fady border and everything is right - so I'm under the impression it is indeed a real disc.

So, I pop it in. After fixing some memory errors first off (That's another story.) I got the install to work. Setup initially copies all files over and then asks me to reboot the first time. The system comes back up, the fancy Windows XP loading bar screen passes, and it goes into the fancy GUI portion of the setup. It stares at me for a couple minutes, and pops the error: "An error has ben encountered that prevents setup from continuing. one of the components that windows needs to continue setup could not be installed: F:\I386\ASMS"

I'm like... wha? I've tried it a bunch of times with the same effect. So, I tried popping my old academic version in just for laughs. That one works fine, XP installed and good to go. So, my conclusion was that it was a bad disc. I put it in a different working computer and looked through the CD, found that I386/ASMS folder, and everything seemed to look fine. As per advice of another forum, I tried to copy the entire CD to the hard drive to see if there were corrupt files. It was doing all good until it got into the I386 folder, when the cd drive started making funny noises and half locked up my computer. Eventually it gave me the old "cannot copy source file" error. I tried the same thing with my academic version, but that one had no problem copying the files to the hard drive.

Getting to the point, it seems to me like the real CD is corrupt somehow. Have any of you heard of this kind of thing? Or maybe is it some fancy cd protection that the academic version doesn't have on it? The guy I bought it from has no problem giving me a new disc as long as I send mine back, so I could try to go that route... but I'd rather not wait 2 weeks and pay shipping costs if theres nothing actually wrong with the disc. But who could I get an opinion from? How about them crazy computer gurus on Anandtech? You guys always seem to have the answers. You got me this far, is anybody nice enough to help me go the last step? Thanks a million!

*It would be awesome if one of you out there with the same WXP Pro SP1 Full OEM disc could try copying that I386 folder to your hard drive and tell me if it works or not. That would be the easiest way to tell if my disc is bad or not!*

Ross Adam Baker
 

RossAdamBaker

Member
Jun 10, 2004
25
0
0
Hardware, eh? I was sent an antennae thing... nothing fancy, I think it had to be included so I could get the software at OEM price. Why do you ask?

And an update, I downloaded "CDCheck" and am running it now... it's found 34 of them "Data Error (Cyclic redundancy check)" things on the disc so far. I think it's bad... what do you think?

Ross Adam Baker
 

Smilin

Diamond Member
Mar 4, 2002
7,357
0
0
Sounds like a bunk disc alright.

Doesn't sound like the most reputable dealer based on the price either. At least he's willing to send you a new disc.

 

RossAdamBaker

Member
Jun 10, 2004
25
0
0
As I feared.

Bummer!

I'll try to get a new disc... and maybe even have him check it before he sends it to me. I just couldn't resist the price. That'll teach me. Do you think the disc is a pirated copy, or just a one-in-a-million legitimate bad burn? Are there counterfeit XP cds floating around?

Ross Adam Baker
 

cy7878

Senior member
Jul 2, 2003
394
0
0
you technically bought the rights to a copy of XP. You can just get any other "backup" disc, install and put in your Serial number to activate. It isn't disc specific. As long as the number is legit, you're set. You can also call MS to verify the the serial number is real.
 

VirtualLarry

No Lifer
Aug 25, 2001
56,571
10,206
126
I've actually had bunk discs before, even legit real original MS ones. Also music CDs that were bad, shrink-wrapped, brand new in the case. It's relatively rare, but it does happen. They literally just don't make CDs like they used to. I have some original video-game CDs, made in the early 90s, and you can visibly see how much better-mfg'd they are compared to most modern discs. I've even had DVDs have issues with blotches, apparently the glue that they used between the layers isn't always the best.

In any case, if the vendor is willing to do an exchange, then go for it. That's what I would recommend.