Windows 8 as a Daily Driver

Collider

Senior member
Jan 20, 2008
522
7
81
About to do a re-install on my main machine, trying to decide if I should go w/ Windows 8 at this point.

Usage/software:
- Dev stuff (VS/SQL/etc)
- Adobe stuff(Ps/Ai/..)
- gaming
- normal usage (web/office/etc)

Specs are of the 1st machine in the signature.

Basically the main concern is stability, I've been running Win8 on my HTPC and have noticed minor stability issues that I'm not used to seeing w/ Windows 7, but at the same time Win8 brings some improvements.

Would be great to hear what people think.

Thanks.

Moved from SfW to OSes
-ViRGE
 
Last edited by a moderator:

colonelciller

Senior member
Sep 29, 2012
915
0
0
Basically the main concern is stability.

the main problem that some users of Adobe CS6 experience with windows8 is a flashing screen when they move the mouse cursor. that is a known risk with win 8 and CS6.

do you have a problem currently with windows 7 and constant security issues such as hacks and intrusions? my guess is no,and thus the security 'enhancements' are pretty much a non-issue for pretty much anyone... but it is great marketing.

if you care about things like privacy and obvious concepts such as not granting microsoft the right to scan your harddrive contents and remotely delete applications (as per the win8 TOS) then windows 7 is a clear winner... if you like the idea of microsoft spying on your computer usage and deleting applications from your system at their whimsy then windows 8 is the clear winner.

some thoughts to consider
 

BrightCandle

Diamond Member
Mar 15, 2007
4,762
0
76
I used Windows 8 as a developer for 2 months. I have ended up on Windows 7 again, I wouldn't bother. Its not worth it for a desktop computer, it gets in the way a lot and while I wouldn't say it makes much if any real difference in terms of productivity it clearly does have many issues on the desktop. There are a lot of things to like in it as well, but they come bundled with some really blunders that just make common things a lot slower and more annoying. In the end I considered it a wash, not worth paying for if you already own W7.
 

Collider

Senior member
Jan 20, 2008
522
7
81
Thanks guys this pretty much confirms my concerns..

If they dont fix that stuff in next SP the fear is that Win 8 will be the Vista remix and then 9 will be good again..
 

Ken g6

Programming Moderator, Elite Member
Moderator
Dec 11, 1999
16,711
4,671
75
The deleting apps thing looks like it only applies to the Windows app store. Where's this hard drive scanning thing anyway?
 

douglasb

Diamond Member
Apr 11, 2005
3,157
0
76
I used Windows 8 as a developer for 2 months. I have ended up on Windows 7 again, I wouldn't bother. Its not worth it for a desktop computer, it gets in the way a lot and while I wouldn't say it makes much if any real difference in terms of productivity it clearly does have many issues on the desktop. There are a lot of things to like in it as well, but they come bundled with some really blunders that just make common things a lot slower and more annoying. In the end I considered it a wash, not worth paying for if you already own W7.

Similar situation here, except I only made it barely over one month on my desktop (which is my "power" machine that I do 99% of my development on).

I started off with every intention of using Windows 8 "as-is", without any registry hacks, start menu replacements, etc. I pretty much immediately found replacements for all of the default "Metro/Modern/whatever-the-hell-they-are-calling-it-this-month" apps and changed my defaults so I would never have to see a full-screen "Modern UI" app. At this point, I'm still trying to give Windows 8 a fair shake, even if it means steering clear of the new UI. I never really had any "where the hell is ____?!?" moments because the Windows 8 Start screen's Search function is very powerful. I also liked the new file copy dialog.

After about 2 weeks, I was editing group policies and the registry to get rid of annoyances like the lock screen (Why, Microsoft, WHY?!?!). It just killed me to go to my computer, see the lock screen, click, see the login screen, enter my credentials, see the start screen, click the desktop icon, and finally get to my desktop. On Windows 7, I turn the computer on, enter my credentials, and get straight to the desktop. I was able to eventually get this same behavior on Windows 8, but it took multiple hacks.

After maybe another 2 weeks, I got tired of the Start screen and the fact that going to Start completely destroyed whatever context I was working in. It just messed with me mentally, going from having a dozen windows open to suddenly having none open and forgetting what the hell I was trying to do in the first place. I ended up with a Start Menu replacement (Classic Shell), which obviously doesn't work as well as the real, built-in Start Menu in Windows 7.

I stayed with Windows 8 for another 2 weeks or so before giving up on it and going back to 7. What really did it for me was the fact that I had a few programs and games that just didn't run well (or at all) in 8, and I was getting WAY more random crashes than I ever got in 7. The crashes were probably due to the fact that the OS was basically hacked to pieces at this point, but I shouldn't have to do that to get an acceptable user experience on a desktop computer used for productivity.
 

sourceninja

Diamond Member
Mar 8, 2005
8,805
65
91
I have to say I like windows 8. I feel the flow of 8 is better with the keyboard shortcuts and it fits my workflows better. I'm ok with no start button and it really shines in allowing me to work without touching my mouse.

There are things I would change, but overall I like 8 a bit better than 7.
 

Collider

Senior member
Jan 20, 2008
522
7
81
Are you on touch ?

I have to say I like windows 8. I feel the flow of 8 is better with the keyboard shortcuts and it fits my workflows better. I'm ok with no start button and it really shines in allowing me to work without touching my mouse.

There are things I would change, but overall I like 8 a bit better than 7.[/QUOTE
 

Snoop

Golden Member
Oct 11, 1999
1,424
0
76
I use windows 8 for dev (Database, Visual Studio, VMWare) work. Stock with metro UI I wouldn't consider, with Start8, its been smooth sailing.
 

xSauronx

Lifer
Jul 14, 2000
19,582
4
81
Nope. Works perfect with just a keyboard.

yeah, im happy with it, been using it for a couple of months. some of the defaults and touch screen setup is dumb but its for things i pretty much never deal with. its set up fo rme like win 7 was: all of my programs pinned to the taskbar, always looking at a desktop with several windows open

runs like a charm, but i have beefy hardware.