Things appear to have been fixed. I removed the Remote Access/VPN role and reinstalled it.
Duron 1300
Abit NF7
128mb DDR (Yes, I know. More is on the way, this was an unexpected transition from a simple Linux router)
10gb HDD
NICs: 2x RTL8139 (Local, load balanced), 1x nVidia nForce NIC (Internet)