Will there ever be an effective way of combating hurricanes?

Page 2 - Seeking answers? Join the AnandTech community: where nearly half-a-million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.

captains

Diamond Member
Mar 27, 2003
4,065
1
0
throwing a bunch of trailer parks and poor people in the path tend to slow them down
 

Gibsons

Lifer
Aug 14, 2001
12,530
35
91
Originally posted by: captains
throwing a bunch of trailer parks and poor people in the path tend to slow them down

build an artificial island way out in the north atlantic, cover it in trailer parks. It will attract hurricanes up from the gulf, the colder water will dissipate their energy.
 

captains

Diamond Member
Mar 27, 2003
4,065
1
0
Originally posted by: Gibsons
Originally posted by: captains
throwing a bunch of trailer parks and poor people in the path tend to slow them down

build an artificial island way out in the north atlantic, cover it in trailer parks. It will attract hurricanes up from the gulf, the colder water will dissipate their energy.

hahahahahahahahahaha
 

CKent

Diamond Member
Aug 17, 2005
9,020
0
0
There are building designs which can better withstand the winds, and possibly room for improvement in drainage & *** systems... but thoroughly preventing them is a long way off, if ever.
 

Rogue

Banned
Jan 28, 2000
5,774
0
0
Superman. He could fly the opposite direction of the rotation to eventually stop the hurricane. I saw it somewhere before. ;)
 

captains

Diamond Member
Mar 27, 2003
4,065
1
0
hes dead....and even he was still alive he wouldnt be able to leap tall buildings to get there in time
 

Ipno

Golden Member
Apr 30, 2001
1,047
0
0
Load an airplane full of politicians and fly it right into the worst part of the hurricane.

It might not stop the hurricane, but it will ultimately make everyone else feel better.
 

cjgallen

Diamond Member
Jan 20, 2003
6,419
0
0
Originally posted by: Ipno
Load an airplane full of politicians and fly it right into the worst part of the hurricane.

It might not stop the hurricane, but it will ultimately make everyone else feel better.

No, all that hot air would only intensify the hurricane :Q
 

iroast

Golden Member
May 5, 2005
1,364
3
81
we generate enough garbage to create a giant wall. pour concrete over the wall and you have something cool haha
 

Drakkon

Diamond Member
Aug 14, 2001
8,401
1
0
Originally posted by: FoBoT
hurricanes are a feature, not a bug.
get used to it

or move to missouri like i did

so now instead of hurricanes you get tornados?

move to AZ...no crazy weather...unless you consider hot as hell "crazy" :p
 

marvdmartian

Diamond Member
Apr 12, 2002
5,444
27
91
Stop hurricanes? You might as well try to stop the rotation of the earth. While it might be possible, it's not likely to happen any time in the near future!

A better idea would be to FORCE the people who lose houses & other buildings to hurricanes & tornadoes to rebuild with reinforced concrete. Of course, being American, it's their right to build with matchbook covers if they want to, right? However, if the insurance companies will only offer affordable insurance to people with reinforced concrete buildings & storm shutters, and the banks will only finance to insured people, then they really have not much choice at all, do they?

The government & insurance companies did this exact thing on Guam, not quite 30 years ago, when super typhoon Pamela hit there, and pretty much wiped out the island (in 1976). A lot of people that survived that one remembered super typhoon Karen in 1962, and said, "To heck with this!!", and changed the building codes. Nowadays, if you want to build with wood, you're on your own. You will not get insurance, and you will not get a bank loan to build.

Sound harsh? Then consider that when super typhoon Paka hit Guam in December of 97, and the north end of the island was being thrashed with 180+mph sustained winds, with gusts of over 200mph, that not one person was killed, and the damage to property for people with reinforced concrete structures (probably 98% of the island now) was minimal (there were a few houses on the navy base that had roofs start to peel back.....these were 40+ year old concrete houses that should have been demolished 10 years before, and rebuilt; there were also some really cheap concrete houses, built way below the recommended wall & roof thickness, with substandard materials, that sustained some minor damage). Frankly, going out after the storm, I was amazed. The Bank of Guam building had replaced all their regular glass pane windows a few years before with laminated glass windows (like your car's windshield, but beefier/thicker), and their tower, which goes up something like 8 stories high, sustained ZERO damage, even to the windows!! :shocked:

So yes, there is a way to build, that will shield people from hurricane force winds. Add to that the fact that levees and sea walls can be built to hold the sea back, and we can make the entire gulf coast and eastern seaboard that sees hurricanes just as safe as it's possible to be, and a heckuva lot safer than they are now. Will it cost? Sure, but if you do it like I said, and replace damaged buildings, then in 40 years you'll be like Guam is now, and you won't hear about damage like you saw after Katrina. :)
 

FM2n

Senior member
Aug 10, 2005
563
0
0
There are many ways to combat a hurricane. I will list a few and hopefully we can talk about them.

1. Don't be black
2. Don't be poor
3. Be white
4. Be rich

(taken from the San Diego Union Tribune)
 

Rubycon

Madame President
Aug 10, 2005
17,768
485
126
Originally posted by: Drakkon
Originally posted by: FoBoT
hurricanes are a feature, not a bug.
get used to it

or move to missouri like i did

so now instead of hurricanes you get tornados?

move to AZ...no crazy weather...unless you consider hot as hell "crazy" :p



The mid atlantic is officially a *natural* disaster free zone. Prior to 9/11 it was not necessary to emphasize natural but...

They have hurricane proof houses. They look like water towers. Typically three floors however the lowest floor is filled with "ballast water" before a major storm approaches to increase stability from overturning. Either way you're high and dry. Sure you can build underground but flooding is a real problem. Even if you're welded in a safe area you better make sure your CO2 scrubbers hold up for the duration.
 

DrPizza

Administrator Elite Member Goat Whisperer
Mar 5, 2001
49,601
167
111
www.slatebrookfarm.com
Originally posted by: marvdmartian
Stop hurricanes? You might as well try to stop the rotation of the earth. While it might be possible, it's not likely to happen any time in the near future!

A better idea would be to FORCE the people who lose houses & other buildings to hurricanes & tornadoes to rebuild with reinforced concrete. Of course, being American, it's their right to build with matchbook covers if they want to, right? However, if the insurance companies will only offer affordable insurance to people with reinforced concrete buildings & storm shutters, and the banks will only finance to insured people, then they really have not much choice at all, do they?

The government & insurance companies did this exact thing on Guam, not quite 30 years ago, when super typhoon Pamela hit there, and pretty much wiped out the island (in 1976). A lot of people that survived that one remembered super typhoon Karen in 1962, and said, "To heck with this!!", and changed the building codes. Nowadays, if you want to build with wood, you're on your own. You will not get insurance, and you will not get a bank loan to build.

Sound harsh? Then consider that when super typhoon Paka hit Guam in December of 97, and the north end of the island was being thrashed with 180+mph sustained winds, with gusts of over 200mph, that not one person was killed, and the damage to property for people with reinforced concrete structures (probably 98% of the island now) was minimal (there were a few houses on the navy base that had roofs start to peel back.....these were 40+ year old concrete houses that should have been demolished 10 years before, and rebuilt; there were also some really cheap concrete houses, built way below the recommended wall & roof thickness, with substandard materials, that sustained some minor damage). Frankly, going out after the storm, I was amazed. The Bank of Guam building had replaced all their regular glass pane windows a few years before with laminated glass windows (like your car's windshield, but beefier/thicker), and their tower, which goes up something like 8 stories high, sustained ZERO damage, even to the windows!! :shocked:

So yes, there is a way to build, that will shield people from hurricane force winds. Add to that the fact that levees and sea walls can be built to hold the sea back, and we can make the entire gulf coast and eastern seaboard that sees hurricanes just as safe as it's possible to be, and a heckuva lot safer than they are now. Will it cost? Sure, but if you do it like I said, and replace damaged buildings, then in 40 years you'll be like Guam is now, and you won't hear about damage like you saw after Katrina. :)

But, but, but, I want my house to have a nice view of the coast. I don't want a wall. I want my house built on stilts right at the water's edge. I want one of those straw roofs that look really nice and tropical. I want, I want, I want. And, I want the insurance company to replace it every 5 years when it succumbs to a storm.
 

oogabooga

Diamond Member
Jan 14, 2003
7,806
3
81
Originally posted by: DrPizza
Originally posted by: marvdmartian
Stop hurricanes? You might as well try to stop the rotation of the earth. While it might be possible, it's not likely to happen any time in the near future!

A better idea would be to FORCE the people who lose houses & other buildings to hurricanes & tornadoes to rebuild with reinforced concrete. Of course, being American, it's their right to build with matchbook covers if they want to, right? However, if the insurance companies will only offer affordable insurance to people with reinforced concrete buildings & storm shutters, and the banks will only finance to insured people, then they really have not much choice at all, do they?

The government & insurance companies did this exact thing on Guam, not quite 30 years ago, when super typhoon Pamela hit there, and pretty much wiped out the island (in 1976). A lot of people that survived that one remembered super typhoon Karen in 1962, and said, "To heck with this!!", and changed the building codes. Nowadays, if you want to build with wood, you're on your own. You will not get insurance, and you will not get a bank loan to build.

Sound harsh? Then consider that when super typhoon Paka hit Guam in December of 97, and the north end of the island was being thrashed with 180+mph sustained winds, with gusts of over 200mph, that not one person was killed, and the damage to property for people with reinforced concrete structures (probably 98% of the island now) was minimal (there were a few houses on the navy base that had roofs start to peel back.....these were 40+ year old concrete houses that should have been demolished 10 years before, and rebuilt; there were also some really cheap concrete houses, built way below the recommended wall & roof thickness, with substandard materials, that sustained some minor damage). Frankly, going out after the storm, I was amazed. The Bank of Guam building had replaced all their regular glass pane windows a few years before with laminated glass windows (like your car's windshield, but beefier/thicker), and their tower, which goes up something like 8 stories high, sustained ZERO damage, even to the windows!! :shocked:

So yes, there is a way to build, that will shield people from hurricane force winds. Add to that the fact that levees and sea walls can be built to hold the sea back, and we can make the entire gulf coast and eastern seaboard that sees hurricanes just as safe as it's possible to be, and a heckuva lot safer than they are now. Will it cost? Sure, but if you do it like I said, and replace damaged buildings, then in 40 years you'll be like Guam is now, and you won't hear about damage like you saw after Katrina. :)

But, but, but, I want my house to have a nice view of the coast. I don't want a wall. I want my house built on stilts right at the water's edge. I want one of those straw roofs that look really nice and tropical. I want, I want, I want. And, I want the insurance company to replace it every 5 years when it succumbs to a storm.

You're living a fantasy world. I want mine replaced every 9 months.
 

Boxxcar

Senior member
Mar 19, 2002
364
0
0
I vaguely remember an article about this a number of years ago. Something about Bush directing the entire crew of an aircraft carrier lay down on the top deck and similtaneously burn their farts into the eye.
 

Mill

Lifer
Oct 10, 1999
28,558
3
81
Originally posted by: RBachman
There are building designs which can better withstand the winds, and possibly room for improvement in drainage & *** systems... but thoroughly preventing them is a long way off, if ever.