Wife support is the new child support?

Page 3 - Seeking answers? Join the AnandTech community: where nearly half-a-million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.

b0mbrman

Lifer
Jun 1, 2001
29,470
1
81
Originally posted by: Tom
This is none of our business. The guy agreed to pay that much.


I guess some of you aren't parents, or are just bad parents, but lots of parents want their kids to have the best life possible.

Some Fathers put their kids welfare above all the other bullshTt people spend money on, so why wouldn't a rich guy pay a lot of child support, and be glad too ?

Great, but give him the option.

Don't you think he'd be more glad if he were ordered to pay $1k and voluntary put $14k in a trust fund for the kid?
 

pinion9

Banned
May 5, 2005
1,201
0
0
Originally posted by: Tom
This is none of our business. The guy agreed to pay that much.
Then what exactly is our business? We are discussing child support as a whole with this as an ideal point. Have you never discussed on a public forum something that you thought was flawed, but obviously was not your business? Ever discussed abortion?

Originally posted by: Tom
I guess some of you aren't parents, or are just bad parents, but lots of parents want their kids to have the best life possible.
I am a good parent. My point is that if he WANTS to spend $15K/month on his child, he can do that. He should not be FORCED to do this. I'm sure he isn't thinking "I am so glad I have to spend this money every month!"


Originally posted by: Tom
Some Fathers put their kids welfare above all the other bullshTt people spend money on, so why wouldn't a rich guy pay a lot of child support, and be glad too ?

There is no conceivable way that you can spend $15K/month on a two year old child unless you are buying them a mansion for their bedroom and gold plated shoes. The point is that the wife is getting paid a lot of money under the guise of "child support."
 

b0mbrman

Lifer
Jun 1, 2001
29,470
1
81
Originally posted by: eakers
Originally posted by: pinion9
Originally posted by: eakers
Its probabley because the child is used to living a certain lifestyle and the courts want to be able to maintain that lifestyle.

Does it say anything aobut alimony?

Since when is it the COURTS repsonsibility to maintain someones lifestyle?

If I losy my job, who is going to pay me so I can maintain my lifestyle?

you're not a child who is about to lose a family.

Certainly, children whose mothers only receive $14k in child support must be even more heart-broken :brokenheart:


 

pinion9

Banned
May 5, 2005
1,201
0
0
Originally posted by: eakers
Originally posted by: pinion9
Originally posted by: eakers
Its probabley because the child is used to living a certain lifestyle and the courts want to be able to maintain that lifestyle.

Does it say anything aobut alimony?

Since when is it the COURTS repsonsibility to maintain someones lifestyle?

If I losy my job, who is going to pay me so I can maintain my lifestyle?

you're not a child who is about to lose a family.

Lose a family? The child doesn't lose the family. He still has a dad and mom. He loses some structure, sure, but no one is going away. Please try again.
 

b0mbrman

Lifer
Jun 1, 2001
29,470
1
81
Originally posted by: krunchykrome
Same thing happened to defensive end Michael Strahan of the New York Giants. His ugly divorce I think ended with his wife demanding a ton of money in alimony in order to keep up with her expensive lifestyle she had grown accustomed to.

Hmmm...I wonder if I could sue a credit card company for alimony. My $100k+ credit line has accustomed me to a lifestyle that I won't be able to continue without even more money...
 

pinion9

Banned
May 5, 2005
1,201
0
0
It is a persons responsibility to provide an adequate lifestyle for themselves and their children. It should not be the governments responsibility to ensure that children maintain a certain lifestyle above and beyond being educated, fed, and given a safe shelter. These 3 things can be done for less than $15K/month.
 

Tom

Lifer
Oct 9, 1999
13,293
1
76
Originally posted by: b0mbrman
Originally posted by: Tom
This is none of our business. The guy agreed to pay that much.


I guess some of you aren't parents, or are just bad parents, but lots of parents want their kids to have the best life possible.

Some Fathers put their kids welfare above all the other bullshTt people spend money on, so why wouldn't a rich guy pay a lot of child support, and be glad too ?

Great, but give him the option.

Don't you think he'd be more glad if he were ordered to pay $1k and voluntary put $14k in a trust fund for the kid?


You must read a lot more gossip rags than I do, since you know the details so well..

As far as I know, the guy agreed to pay that amount, where is your proof he was forced too ?


 

Tom

Lifer
Oct 9, 1999
13,293
1
76
Originally posted by: pinion9
Originally posted by: Tom
This is none of our business. The guy agreed to pay that much.
Then what exactly is our business? We are discussing child support as a whole with this as an ideal point. Have you never discussed on a public forum something that you thought was flawed, but obviously was not your business? Ever discussed abortion?

Originally posted by: Tom
I guess some of you aren't parents, or are just bad parents, but lots of parents want their kids to have the best life possible.
I am a good parent. My point is that if he WANTS to spend $15K/month on his child, he can do that. He should not be FORCED to do this. I'm sure he isn't thinking "I am so glad I have to spend this money every month!"


Originally posted by: Tom
Some Fathers put their kids welfare above all the other bullshTt people spend money on, so why wouldn't a rich guy pay a lot of child support, and be glad too ?

There is no conceivable way that you can spend $15K/month on a two year old child unless you are buying them a mansion for their bedroom and gold plated shoes. The point is that the wife is getting paid a lot of money under the guise of "child support."


Is there some reason why his kids are supposed to live a lesser lifestyle than he is ? How the hell do you know what his lifestyle costs per month ?

 

imported_weadjust

Golden Member
Apr 23, 2004
1,561
1
0
How much would Bill Gates have to pay in the same position as Joey? Gates worth about 53 Billion. Would a million a month cover the cost of one kid?
 

moshquerade

No Lifer
Nov 1, 2001
61,504
12
56
Originally posted by: PurdueRy
LOS ANGELES - After a little more than three years of marriage,
Matt LeBlanc's divorce has been finalized.

The 39-year-old former "Friends" star has been granted joint custody of his 2-year-old daughter with wife Melissa LeBlanc, according to court papers filed Wednesday. Melissa LeBlanc has two children from a previous marriage.

The LeBlancs filed for divorce on April 6, citing irreconcilable differences. They will be officially single again on Oct. 6.

Under the terms of the divorce, LeBlanc will be financially responsible for his daughter's education, nanny and other needs. He will also pay $15,000 a month in child support.

Calls to LeBlanc's attorney and his publicist after business hours Thursday were not immediately returned.

The pair married in a celebrity-studded wedding in Hawaii in 2003 with several of LeBlanc's "Friends" co-stars in attendance.

LeBlanc played struggling actor Joey Tribbiani in the long-running sit-com that ended in 2004. He reprised the character for the NBC spinoff "Joey," which was canceled in May after two seasons.

Now I have no doubt that the man can afford this...but doesn't that seem a bit...excessive? I can't imagine any child would cost $15,000 per month....He shouldn't have to pay for the other children that weren't his no?

Is it just me or is this "child support" more like "wife support" so his former wife can keep living the life she was when they were married?
it's income based. you make more you pay more.

i didn't know their marriage went down the tubes. i believe she was a bit older than him which surprised me at the time.

 

b0mbrman

Lifer
Jun 1, 2001
29,470
1
81
Originally posted by: Tom
Originally posted by: b0mbrman
Originally posted by: Tom
This is none of our business. The guy agreed to pay that much.


I guess some of you aren't parents, or are just bad parents, but lots of parents want their kids to have the best life possible.

Some Fathers put their kids welfare above all the other bullshTt people spend money on, so why wouldn't a rich guy pay a lot of child support, and be glad too ?

Great, but give him the option.

Don't you think he'd be more glad if he were ordered to pay $1k and voluntary put $14k in a trust fund for the kid?


You must read a lot more gossip rags than I do, since you know the details so well..

As far as I know, the guy agreed to pay that amount, where is your proof he was forced too ?

I read none, unfortunately. None available out here...

Anyway, he is forced to, or will be. To the extent that I understand the law, one is not allowed to miss child support payments.
 

b0mbrman

Lifer
Jun 1, 2001
29,470
1
81
Originally posted by: Tom
Originally posted by: pinion9
Originally posted by: Tom
This is none of our business. The guy agreed to pay that much.
Then what exactly is our business? We are discussing child support as a whole with this as an ideal point. Have you never discussed on a public forum something that you thought was flawed, but obviously was not your business? Ever discussed abortion?

Originally posted by: Tom
I guess some of you aren't parents, or are just bad parents, but lots of parents want their kids to have the best life possible.
I am a good parent. My point is that if he WANTS to spend $15K/month on his child, he can do that. He should not be FORCED to do this. I'm sure he isn't thinking "I am so glad I have to spend this money every month!"


Originally posted by: Tom
Some Fathers put their kids welfare above all the other bullshTt people spend money on, so why wouldn't a rich guy pay a lot of child support, and be glad too ?

There is no conceivable way that you can spend $15K/month on a two year old child unless you are buying them a mansion for their bedroom and gold plated shoes. The point is that the wife is getting paid a lot of money under the guise of "child support."


Is there some reason why his kids are supposed to live a lesser lifestyle than he is ? How the hell do you know what his lifestyle costs per month ?

Can you point to the law that states his kids have to live the same lifestyle as he?

I left my big book of law at home with my gossip rags ;)
 

Tom

Lifer
Oct 9, 1999
13,293
1
76
Originally posted by: b0mbrman
Originally posted by: Tom
Originally posted by: b0mbrman
Originally posted by: Tom
This is none of our business. The guy agreed to pay that much.


I guess some of you aren't parents, or are just bad parents, but lots of parents want their kids to have the best life possible.

Some Fathers put their kids welfare above all the other bullshTt people spend money on, so why wouldn't a rich guy pay a lot of child support, and be glad too ?

Great, but give him the option.

Don't you think he'd be more glad if he were ordered to pay $1k and voluntary put $14k in a trust fund for the kid?


You must read a lot more gossip rags than I do, since you know the details so well..

As far as I know, the guy agreed to pay that amount, where is your proof he was forced too ?

I read none, unfortunately. None available out here...

Anyway, he is forced to, or will be. To the extent that I understand the law, one is not allowed to miss child support payments.


That is because he AGREED to make the payments. It's like any other AGREEMENT that settles a lawsuit, it has the force of law.

But that doesn't mean he was "forced" to make the AGREEMENT.


 

Tom

Lifer
Oct 9, 1999
13,293
1
76
Originally posted by: b0mbrman
Originally posted by: Tom
Originally posted by: pinion9
Originally posted by: Tom
This is none of our business. The guy agreed to pay that much.
Then what exactly is our business? We are discussing child support as a whole with this as an ideal point. Have you never discussed on a public forum something that you thought was flawed, but obviously was not your business? Ever discussed abortion?

Originally posted by: Tom
I guess some of you aren't parents, or are just bad parents, but lots of parents want their kids to have the best life possible.
I am a good parent. My point is that if he WANTS to spend $15K/month on his child, he can do that. He should not be FORCED to do this. I'm sure he isn't thinking "I am so glad I have to spend this money every month!"


Originally posted by: Tom
Some Fathers put their kids welfare above all the other bullshTt people spend money on, so why wouldn't a rich guy pay a lot of child support, and be glad too ?

There is no conceivable way that you can spend $15K/month on a two year old child unless you are buying them a mansion for their bedroom and gold plated shoes. The point is that the wife is getting paid a lot of money under the guise of "child support."


Is there some reason why his kids are supposed to live a lesser lifestyle than he is ? How the hell do you know what his lifestyle costs per month ?

Can you point to the law that states his kids have to live the same lifestyle as he?

I left my big book of law at home with my gossip rags ;)


I'm not talking about the law..

You say you are a good parent. Tell me why you think a rich man should live a better life style than his kids ?

 
Apr 17, 2003
37,622
0
76
well, the way you get a $ value for child support is by using a program called dissolution master where the value of all the assets from each party is entered and the program spits out a number so its comparable when both parties "value" is considered.
 
Apr 17, 2003
37,622
0
76
Originally posted by: b0mbrman
Originally posted by: Tom
Originally posted by: b0mbrman
Originally posted by: Tom
This is none of our business. The guy agreed to pay that much.


I guess some of you aren't parents, or are just bad parents, but lots of parents want their kids to have the best life possible.

Some Fathers put their kids welfare above all the other bullshTt people spend money on, so why wouldn't a rich guy pay a lot of child support, and be glad too ?

Great, but give him the option.

Don't you think he'd be more glad if he were ordered to pay $1k and voluntary put $14k in a trust fund for the kid?


You must read a lot more gossip rags than I do, since you know the details so well..

As far as I know, the guy agreed to pay that amount, where is your proof he was forced too ?

I read none, unfortunately. None available out here...

Anyway, he is forced to, or will be. To the extent that I understand the law, one is not allowed to miss child support payments.


Correct. He didnt agree to anything. Its mandatory. In fact, a custodial parent cannot waive payments.
 

moshquerade

No Lifer
Nov 1, 2001
61,504
12
56
Originally posted by: Corporate Thug
Originally posted by: b0mbrman
Originally posted by: Tom
Originally posted by: b0mbrman
Originally posted by: Tom
This is none of our business. The guy agreed to pay that much.


I guess some of you aren't parents, or are just bad parents, but lots of parents want their kids to have the best life possible.

Some Fathers put their kids welfare above all the other bullshTt people spend money on, so why wouldn't a rich guy pay a lot of child support, and be glad too ?

Great, but give him the option.

Don't you think he'd be more glad if he were ordered to pay $1k and voluntary put $14k in a trust fund for the kid?


You must read a lot more gossip rags than I do, since you know the details so well..

As far as I know, the guy agreed to pay that amount, where is your proof he was forced too ?

I read none, unfortunately. None available out here...

Anyway, he is forced to, or will be. To the extent that I understand the law, one is not allowed to miss child support payments.


Correct. He didnt agree to anything. Its mandatory. In fact, a custodial parent cannot waive payments.
how come you never defended yourself against all those saying your thread was shens?

http://forums.anandtech.com/messageview...&STARTPAGE=1&FTVAR_FORUMVIEWTMP=Linear
 
Apr 17, 2003
37,622
0
76
Originally posted by: Tom
Originally posted by: b0mbrman
Originally posted by: Tom
Originally posted by: pinion9
Originally posted by: Tom
This is none of our business. The guy agreed to pay that much.
Then what exactly is our business? We are discussing child support as a whole with this as an ideal point. Have you never discussed on a public forum something that you thought was flawed, but obviously was not your business? Ever discussed abortion?

Originally posted by: Tom
I guess some of you aren't parents, or are just bad parents, but lots of parents want their kids to have the best life possible.
I am a good parent. My point is that if he WANTS to spend $15K/month on his child, he can do that. He should not be FORCED to do this. I'm sure he isn't thinking "I am so glad I have to spend this money every month!"


Originally posted by: Tom
Some Fathers put their kids welfare above all the other bullshTt people spend money on, so why wouldn't a rich guy pay a lot of child support, and be glad too ?

There is no conceivable way that you can spend $15K/month on a two year old child unless you are buying them a mansion for their bedroom and gold plated shoes. The point is that the wife is getting paid a lot of money under the guise of "child support."


Is there some reason why his kids are supposed to live a lesser lifestyle than he is ? How the hell do you know what his lifestyle costs per month ?

Can you point to the law that states his kids have to live the same lifestyle as he?

I left my big book of law at home with my gossip rags ;)


I'm not talking about the law..

You say you are a good parent. Tell me why you think a rich man should live a better life style than his kids ?


I dont think thats necessarily a bad thing. for example, if i'm driving a mercedes, that doesnt mean that my kids are gonna get a mercedes from me.

Also, he does have joint custody, so i'm not sure if the lifestlye will suffer drastically.
 

b0mbrman

Lifer
Jun 1, 2001
29,470
1
81
Originally posted by: Tom
Originally posted by: b0mbrman
Originally posted by: Tom
Originally posted by: pinion9
Originally posted by: Tom
This is none of our business. The guy agreed to pay that much.
Then what exactly is our business? We are discussing child support as a whole with this as an ideal point. Have you never discussed on a public forum something that you thought was flawed, but obviously was not your business? Ever discussed abortion?

Originally posted by: Tom
I guess some of you aren't parents, or are just bad parents, but lots of parents want their kids to have the best life possible.
I am a good parent. My point is that if he WANTS to spend $15K/month on his child, he can do that. He should not be FORCED to do this. I'm sure he isn't thinking "I am so glad I have to spend this money every month!"


Originally posted by: Tom
Some Fathers put their kids welfare above all the other bullshTt people spend money on, so why wouldn't a rich guy pay a lot of child support, and be glad too ?

There is no conceivable way that you can spend $15K/month on a two year old child unless you are buying them a mansion for their bedroom and gold plated shoes. The point is that the wife is getting paid a lot of money under the guise of "child support."


Is there some reason why his kids are supposed to live a lesser lifestyle than he is ? How the hell do you know what his lifestyle costs per month ?

Can you point to the law that states his kids have to live the same lifestyle as he?

I left my big book of law at home with my gossip rags ;)


I'm not talking about the law..

You say you are a good parent. Tell me why you think a rich man should live a better life style than his kids ?

When did I say that?

Now, tell me why you think the law should enforce his children having the same lifestyle as his.
 

Tom

Lifer
Oct 9, 1999
13,293
1
76
Originally posted by: Corporate Thug
Originally posted by: b0mbrman
Originally posted by: Tom
Originally posted by: b0mbrman
Originally posted by: Tom
This is none of our business. The guy agreed to pay that much.


I guess some of you aren't parents, or are just bad parents, but lots of parents want their kids to have the best life possible.

Some Fathers put their kids welfare above all the other bullshTt people spend money on, so why wouldn't a rich guy pay a lot of child support, and be glad too ?

Great, but give him the option.

Don't you think he'd be more glad if he were ordered to pay $1k and voluntary put $14k in a trust fund for the kid?


You must read a lot more gossip rags than I do, since you know the details so well..

As far as I know, the guy agreed to pay that amount, where is your proof he was forced too ?

I read none, unfortunately. None available out here...

Anyway, he is forced to, or will be. To the extent that I understand the law, one is not allowed to miss child support payments.


Correct. He didnt agree to anything. Its mandatory. In fact, a custodial parent cannot waive payments.


You have proof that he didn't agree to the settlement ? Or do you even know what a lawsuit is ?

 

dquan97

Lifer
Jul 9, 2002
12,010
3
0
There's an easy reason for this: child support is not counted as income to the recipient, unlike alimony, which is taxed. Both parties come up with a deal...for him: joint custody and dirt-free divorce, for her: tax-free income
 

Tom

Lifer
Oct 9, 1999
13,293
1
76
Originally posted by: Corporate Thug
Originally posted by: Tom
Originally posted by: b0mbrman
Originally posted by: Tom
Originally posted by: pinion9
Originally posted by: Tom
This is none of our business. The guy agreed to pay that much.
Then what exactly is our business? We are discussing child support as a whole with this as an ideal point. Have you never discussed on a public forum something that you thought was flawed, but obviously was not your business? Ever discussed abortion?

Originally posted by: Tom
I guess some of you aren't parents, or are just bad parents, but lots of parents want their kids to have the best life possible.
I am a good parent. My point is that if he WANTS to spend $15K/month on his child, he can do that. He should not be FORCED to do this. I'm sure he isn't thinking "I am so glad I have to spend this money every month!"


Originally posted by: Tom
Some Fathers put their kids welfare above all the other bullshTt people spend money on, so why wouldn't a rich guy pay a lot of child support, and be glad too ?

There is no conceivable way that you can spend $15K/month on a two year old child unless you are buying them a mansion for their bedroom and gold plated shoes. The point is that the wife is getting paid a lot of money under the guise of "child support."


Is there some reason why his kids are supposed to live a lesser lifestyle than he is ? How the hell do you know what his lifestyle costs per month ?

Can you point to the law that states his kids have to live the same lifestyle as he?

I left my big book of law at home with my gossip rags ;)


I'm not talking about the law..

You say you are a good parent. Tell me why you think a rich man should live a better life style than his kids ?


I dont think thats necessarily a bad thing. for example, if i'm driving a mercedes, that doesnt mean that my kids are gonna get a mercedes from me.

Also, he does have joint custody, so i'm not sure if the lifestlye will suffer drastically.


Is that your idea of life style, the kind of car a person drives ?

 
Apr 17, 2003
37,622
0
76
Originally posted by: Tom
Originally posted by: Corporate Thug
Originally posted by: b0mbrman
Originally posted by: Tom
Originally posted by: b0mbrman
Originally posted by: Tom
This is none of our business. The guy agreed to pay that much.


I guess some of you aren't parents, or are just bad parents, but lots of parents want their kids to have the best life possible.

Some Fathers put their kids welfare above all the other bullshTt people spend money on, so why wouldn't a rich guy pay a lot of child support, and be glad too ?

Great, but give him the option.

Don't you think he'd be more glad if he were ordered to pay $1k and voluntary put $14k in a trust fund for the kid?


You must read a lot more gossip rags than I do, since you know the details so well..

As far as I know, the guy agreed to pay that amount, where is your proof he was forced too ?

I read none, unfortunately. None available out here...

Anyway, he is forced to, or will be. To the extent that I understand the law, one is not allowed to miss child support payments.


Correct. He didnt agree to anything. Its mandatory. In fact, a custodial parent cannot waive payments.


You have proof that he didn't agree to the settlement ? Or do you even know what a lawsuit is ?


sorry, i worded it incorrectly. Its more than possible that he didnt "agree" and is just fulfilling his obligation.
 
Apr 17, 2003
37,622
0
76
Originally posted by: Tom
Originally posted by: Corporate Thug
Originally posted by: Tom
Originally posted by: b0mbrman
Originally posted by: Tom
Originally posted by: pinion9
Originally posted by: Tom
This is none of our business. The guy agreed to pay that much.
Then what exactly is our business? We are discussing child support as a whole with this as an ideal point. Have you never discussed on a public forum something that you thought was flawed, but obviously was not your business? Ever discussed abortion?

Originally posted by: Tom
I guess some of you aren't parents, or are just bad parents, but lots of parents want their kids to have the best life possible.
I am a good parent. My point is that if he WANTS to spend $15K/month on his child, he can do that. He should not be FORCED to do this. I'm sure he isn't thinking "I am so glad I have to spend this money every month!"


Originally posted by: Tom
Some Fathers put their kids welfare above all the other bullshTt people spend money on, so why wouldn't a rich guy pay a lot of child support, and be glad too ?

There is no conceivable way that you can spend $15K/month on a two year old child unless you are buying them a mansion for their bedroom and gold plated shoes. The point is that the wife is getting paid a lot of money under the guise of "child support."


Is there some reason why his kids are supposed to live a lesser lifestyle than he is ? How the hell do you know what his lifestyle costs per month ?

Can you point to the law that states his kids have to live the same lifestyle as he?

I left my big book of law at home with my gossip rags ;)


I'm not talking about the law..

You say you are a good parent. Tell me why you think a rich man should live a better life style than his kids ?


I dont think thats necessarily a bad thing. for example, if i'm driving a mercedes, that doesnt mean that my kids are gonna get a mercedes from me.

Also, he does have joint custody, so i'm not sure if the lifestlye will suffer drastically.


Is that your idea of life style, the kind of car a person drives ?


Tom, just a quick example that i thought of. I dont have kids, and i dont want any in the near future. Obviously, lifestyle is much more encompassing than that.
 

Tom

Lifer
Oct 9, 1999
13,293
1
76
Originally posted by: b0mbrman
Originally posted by: Tom
Originally posted by: b0mbrman
Originally posted by: Tom
Originally posted by: pinion9
Originally posted by: Tom
This is none of our business. The guy agreed to pay that much.
Then what exactly is our business? We are discussing child support as a whole with this as an ideal point. Have you never discussed on a public forum something that you thought was flawed, but obviously was not your business? Ever discussed abortion?

Originally posted by: Tom
I guess some of you aren't parents, or are just bad parents, but lots of parents want their kids to have the best life possible.
I am a good parent. My point is that if he WANTS to spend $15K/month on his child, he can do that. He should not be FORCED to do this. I'm sure he isn't thinking "I am so glad I have to spend this money every month!"


Originally posted by: Tom
Some Fathers put their kids welfare above all the other bullshTt people spend money on, so why wouldn't a rich guy pay a lot of child support, and be glad too ?

There is no conceivable way that you can spend $15K/month on a two year old child unless you are buying them a mansion for their bedroom and gold plated shoes. The point is that the wife is getting paid a lot of money under the guise of "child support."


Is there some reason why his kids are supposed to live a lesser lifestyle than he is ? How the hell do you know what his lifestyle costs per month ?

Can you point to the law that states his kids have to live the same lifestyle as he?

I left my big book of law at home with my gossip rags ;)


I'm not talking about the law..

You say you are a good parent. Tell me why you think a rich man should live a better life style than his kids ?

When did I say that?

Now, tell me why you think the law should enforce his children having the same lifestyle as his.


If it was up to me, he and his wife would be in prison, but that isn't relevant.