Why on earth do people choose certain professions? (rant and a story)

glenn1

Lifer
Sep 6, 2000
25,383
1,013
126
This is a subject i've thought about before, but i was just reminded of today when i met a guy who is a M.D., and Podiatrist.

Now, i'm not talking about people who do certain unsavory work just to put food on the table, say a single parent. Then i would completely understand you taking whatever work you could find. No, i'm talking about people who make good money, professionals even, who choose to do things which are just, let's say, nasty. Sorry, but i just don't get it.

Take my new acquaintence the podiatrist. You're bright enough to get accepted to, and graduate from medical school, yet you choose a specialty where you look at nasty, rotting, stinky feet all day. Yeah, i know that any doctor will pretty much make good money, but i don't see how helping Esther with her ingrown toenail problem can be a satisfying way to spend my time.

I mean, certain jobs just make me wonder, "what in the hell were you thinking?" Perhaps my favorite has to be one from my military days. Our Group Commander, an old-school Special Forces Colonel, tells of a deployment he went on once. It was a long trip, and the flight stopped to refuel enroute, on a tiny little Air Force base called Thule, in Northern Greenland. For those of you who haven't had the pleasure of visiting there, here's an idea of where it's located: (map), and here's its homepage.

Anyways, like i said, the aircraft had a layover there to refuel and such. Everything went fairly smoothly at first, and all that was left to be done before the aircraft would be ready to depart, was have the sumps for the onboard latrines vacated. Hours went on, with the passengers and crew getting more and more pissed off, after all, layovers aren't much fun in any event, much less in that particular location. After a couple of hours, a young enlisted man, probably not much older than 18, finally pulls up in the septic truck, obviously in no hurry. Well, this p!ssed the Colonel off to no end. He jumped up, goes over to him, and starts cussing up a storm. "You lousy #!@#U)@!!! Get your @##@!@ in gear!!" and so on.

The young guy just waited for him to finish his tirade, stared blankly back at the Colonel and calmly responded, "Sir, i'm 19 years old, i have no stripes for you to bust, and i'm driving a sh!t sucker truck in Greenland. What punishment do you think you could possibly threaten me with?"

The Colonel, absolutely dumbfounded, thought about it for a minute, and responded, "I don't know," and quietly got back on the plane.



Anyway, that story proves one thing.... this took place after the draft, so the guy enlisted of his own free will and CHOSE his MOS (Military Occupational Specialty). Now, if i couldn't understand why someone would chose to be a podiatrist, i sure as heck don't understand why you'd choose to drive that truck. But to get back to my question, can anyone explain why on earth people would voluntarily choose to do some of these whacked jobs?
 

fr

Diamond Member
Oct 10, 1999
6,408
2
81
Someone has to do it. The foot thing might be some fetish. I can't imagine the trucker with the same feeling for his truck though.
 

Sluggo

Lifer
Jun 12, 2000
15,488
5
81
Maybe the doctors mother had horrible foot problems that caused her great amounts of pain, he hated to see his mother suffer like this, and vowed at an early age to do everything he could to help her, and anyone who might have the same problems.

You never know why some people choose the professions they do, probably most of them do it for the same reason people bought AMC Gremlins............it just happened to turn out that way.
 

Aenygma

Platinum Member
Mar 21, 2001
2,427
1
0
Who knows why, unless they have an IQ of 105 then they become a cop, since thats the avg IQ of one nationwide, as released by a study that was commisioned last year for a federal lawsuit.
 

rgwalt

Diamond Member
Apr 22, 2000
7,393
0
0
Are you sure the kid chose to drive the truck? I mean, sure you get to pick your occupation if you enlist, but they still need someone to drive the poop truck. He just might have gotten lucky.

Recruiter: Sign right here son, and you'll see the world.

Boy: Won't have to drive the poop truck will I?

Recruiter: Poop truck? Heavens no... *crosses fingers*

Sorry, I would never enlist unless I knew I was being drafted, or I was homeless/starving. I mean I'm sure the military would *try* to give you the job that you requested, but if they needed a poop truck man, then you might have the luck of the draw to be it.

Ryan
 

compuwiz1

Admin Emeritus Elite Member
Oct 9, 1999
27,112
925
126
BTW, last time I checked, podiatrists were not real doctors, but more along the lines of a chiropractor level, only dealing with feet. They do not have the same level of education as an M.D. Someone correct me if I'm wrong. ;)
 

etech

Lifer
Oct 9, 1999
10,597
0
0
stats.bls.gov

Colleges of podiatric medicine offer a 4-year program whose core curriculum is similar to that in other schools of medicine. During the first 2 years, students receive classroom instruction in basic sciences, including anatomy, chemistry, pathology, and pharmacology. Third- and fourth-year students have clinical rotations in private practices, hospitals, and clinics. During these rotations, they learn how to take general and podiatric histories, perform routine physical examinations, interpret tests and findings, make diagnoses, and perform therapeutic procedures. Graduates receive the doctor of podiatric medicine (DPM) degree.

A limited number of job openings for podiatrists is expected because the occupation is small and most podiatrists remain in the occupation until they retire.

Most podiatrists are solo practitioners, although more are entering partnerships and multi-specialty group practices.

-->>>Podiatrists enjoy very high earnings. <<<--

That may answer your question Glenn.
 

BoberFett

Lifer
Oct 9, 1999
37,563
9
81
glenn

Funny story, but I should point out that I've never heard of the Sh1t Pumper MOS. :) I'm sure he signed up under some general repair crew MOS and after boot got assigned that wonderful job.
 

dcdomain

Diamond Member
Jan 30, 2000
5,158
0
71
Yes I wonder why people choose certain professions too. Every night in studio while I'm drawing some damn fvcking contour lines and figuring out how water runs down a slope at 4 in the morning, I ask myself. Why? It's certainly not for the money ($35k a year? Give me a break, I pay that much a year to go to school, and for five years). It's not for the fame (how many architects can you name?). It's not for laid back work atmosphere (work = life). And it's not so I can become someone's CAD monkey...

Why oh why??? 2.8 more years to go...
 

pamchenko

Golden Member
Nov 28, 1999
1,213
0
0
the worse job to me? those that volunteer to be "professional actors" for med students to practice on...imagine getting your bum-hole looked and played with by a student...
 

glenn1

Lifer
Sep 6, 2000
25,383
1,013
126


<< I take it you don't have an interest in proctology... :D >>



You, Sir, are correct... proctology ranks right up there alongside driving the turd truck in professions i would just as soon avoid ;)
 

rudder

Lifer
Nov 9, 2000
19,441
85
91
Some people cannot help where they end up in life. You are obviously blessed with enough intelligence to know how to use a computer, so more than likely you will never have to drive a sh!t truck. In you example, realize that military people don't always get thier choice in jobs. Prior to enlisting, that person had to take a test. His score determined what jobs were available to him.(may have been different when you wre in).

I live in a town that has quite a few factories. Why would anyone choose to work on an assembly line and do mind numbing work for 8 hours? Some choose this life cause they do not want to goto college and want that cash for a new pickup. Many have no choice as they may be too uneducated to find anyother work.

My point, respect your fellow Americans and be thankful they at least have that job and that you do not have to do it.
 

glenn1

Lifer
Sep 6, 2000
25,383
1,013
126


<< My point, respect your fellow Americans and be thankful they at least have that job and that you do not have to do it. >>



Don't get me wrong. I am by no means trying disrespect anyone who goes and does any job. Just because i wouldn't want to do a particular job, doesn't mean i am putting down the person who does it. As somone else said, the job has to get done. To use some of the examples i did, i don't think that the podiatrist or proctologist or sump truck driver is any better or any worse than any other person out there doing a job. I'm just wondering in some cases what would lead a person to choose a certain career field. I mean, it's fairly easy to see what the attraction would be to a field like medicine, but the attraction for someone to choose podiatry simply eludes me.
 

skace

Lifer
Jan 23, 2001
14,488
7
81
*Raises hand*

Teacher, I know why!

There are many people in the world that want the job where their is no pressure. You remember high school, you remember how about 75% of the class HATED getting up and doing speeches / etc. A decent majority of people hate attention. The kid with the poop truck probably figured even though the job sucked, he would be far from anything important.

The foot doctor ... maybe he was pressured by his parents to become a doctor so picked one of the easier types of doctors? Maybe he just likes feet? I don't know about you, but most feet arn't nasty, stinky, rotting. An ingrown toe nail looks for the most part like a normal toe nail. I'd say foot problems would be less gross than say, ER, where you have to operate on people with gunshot wounds and blood splurting out their neck / etc. No one is going to die from an incorrect foot diagnosis.
 

glenn1

Lifer
Sep 6, 2000
25,383
1,013
126


<< The foot doctor ... maybe he was pressured by his parents to become a doctor so picked one of the easier types of doctors....No one is going to die from an incorrect foot diagnosis. >>



You may have a point... i didn't think of it from that perspective...
 

rmblam

Golden Member
Aug 24, 2000
1,237
0
0


<<

<< The foot doctor ... maybe he was pressured by his parents to become a doctor so picked one of the easier types of doctors....No one is going to die from an incorrect foot diagnosis. >>



You may have a point... i didn't think of it from that perspective...
>>




I went to school with 4 people who went on to Podiatry school back in 1992. Back then the medical schools in our area were flooded with applicants (probably still are) and had only limited seats.

As a result of the market demand and the pay predictions they decided to go to Dr Scholl College of Podiatric Medicine in Chicago. I sat in on a few classes with an ex g/f since she was one also attending. Good school.

It had little to do with ease of practice and more to do with money and how soon they could get on with their lives. Two of them went on to take their MD boards as well.



<< No one is going to die from an incorrect foot diagnosis >>



Why are Podiatrists trained similar to MD's? The example answer the school gave was in regards to a patient that visited one of the practicing professionals. The patient complained of a mark on their foot that none of the previous md's could help with.

It turned out to be Kapposi's Sarcoma; a type of cancer invoked by AIDS. The patient had AIDS and the podiatrist ID's it after the MD's overlooked it.


Podiatrists is some states can do surgery up to the knee. They are not all limited to the feet. With the number of diabetics and athletes/runners we have in the US it is a specialty profession with job security.


It is unfair to belittle any profession you know nothing about. Maybe the crap pumper you can though... ;)
 

skace

Lifer
Jan 23, 2001
14,488
7
81
"It is unfair to belittle any profession you know nothing about."

I didn't mean to belittle, only get the point across that their are many people who don't like nor know how to deal with pressure very well. A job without pressure therefor becomes that much more appealing.
 

ASK THE COMMUNITY