Why is it that these psychos are called 'Mentally Ill'?

[Maximilian]

wat?

 

[mammador]

I hate how they label some murderers as mentally ill and then they get off easy. I don't care what they are, if they comitted a crime they should be punished equally. They had enough thought process going on in their brain to go forward with the murder. If a dog bites someone we put it down, even though the dog may not understand what happened and why it was bad. Why should we treat mentally ill any different? They still did the crime, they should do the time. It's not nice to say, but do we really want those people in the gene pool anyway? Lock em up if they murder someone.

they are locked up. Though it depends on the facts of each case. If they get a lower sentence, so what? So you oppose the concept of manslaughter, since it's based on the same rationale?

 

[God Mode]

Being a predatory shitbag isn't a mental disease and should never be allow as an excuse for such.

 

[mammador]

No seriously what are you trying to argue?

Psychiatric medicine is just the treatment and diagnosis of mental illness.

You can argue that it could be better but I'd be interested to hear how you'd do that.

Edit; I posted three questions earlier, they are not leading questions and they are pretty simple. Why not answer them?

Edit 2; wait those aren't really your answers are they?

I simply don't trust the "profession".

It's based on the 19th century mentality. And frankly most people in modern society are ill per the psyhiatrists' definitions.

 

[WelshBloke]

I simply don't trust the "profession".

All of it?

What are your better ideas for treatment and diagnosis? Or should we just give up on it?

 

[mammador]

Mental illness is a false concept.

The diagnoses don't even make sense, and it's just a tool to oppress people. haha..

 

[WelshBloke]

Mental illness is a false concept...

So schizophrenia doesnt exist, sufferers are just faking it?

What about dementia? Alzheimer's?

 

[who?]

A psychopath is legally sane but not normal. Back in the 1980s a person with schizophrenia murdered a woman he met in group therapy. He was ruled to be legally sane and guilty and sent to prison for life.

 

[mammador]

So schizophrenia doesnt exist, sufferers are just faking it?

What about dementia? Alzheimer's?

Yes. Well what defines normal? Normality is subjective.

 

[WelshBloke]

Yes. Well what defines normal? Normality is subjective.

So schizophrenia doesnt exist, sufferers are just faking it?

What about dementia? Alzheimer's?

How about you address the previous point before sliding off to the next one?

 

[1234555aaa]

No any "evil" in the world

 

[Pray To Jesus]

LoL @ AT's resident jester and clown mammador.