Why is it that certain DVD Players only accept certain kinds of CD's?

MrCodeDude

Lifer
Jun 23, 2001
13,674
1
76
As I found out yesterday in a previous thread, my Onkyo SP500 DVD player only likes Ritek CD-R's (haven't tried TY's yet). All the other manufacturors, CMC, Leads Data and another one that I can't remember aren't read as the correct type of CD. CMC and Ritek use the same kind of dye it appears, so why would my DVD player like one over the other?
-- mrcodedude
 

Zim Hosein

Super Moderator | Elite Member
Super Moderator
Nov 27, 1999
65,230
401
126
If you are having difficulty playing back Recordable Compact Discs (CDRs) on your DVD player, you may be experiencing an incompatibility between CDR media and the DVD player you are using for playback.

DVD players need to be rated as "MultiRead" compatible -- specifically designed for CDR playback -- to guarantee performance with CDRs. This incompatibility does not affect every player and disc but does seem to be a recurring issue with many combinations. Standard mass-produced (replicated) CDs are not affected by this problem.

Technically, the problem occurs because DVDs use a smaller pit spacing than CDs, which requires the DVD playback laser to be tuned to a higher frequency. In addition, DVDs can be single- or dual-layer per side, which requires a different focusing mechanism than a CD player uses. DVD player manufacturers have compensated for these differences with CDs, but CDRs use a chemical-dye surface instead of an aluminum surface. The dye reflects light differently than the aluminum does and can cause an interference pattern with the playback laser, resulting in read errors.

Some manufacturers solve this problem by using dual playback lasers, others by using additional software in the player, but many players just can't handle the variation in media. If you are having trouble playing your CDRs on a DVD player try using a different model player (DVD-ROM drives appear to work better than DVD-Video units), or use a CD or CD-ROM player instead.

:)
 

SludgeFactory

Platinum Member
Sep 14, 2001
2,969
2
81
Originally posted by: MrCodeDude
As I found out yesterday in a previous thread, my Onkyo SP500 DVD player only likes Ritek CD-R's (haven't tried TY's yet). All the other manufacturors, CMC, Leads Data and another one that I can't remember aren't read as the correct type of CD. CMC and Ritek use the same kind of dye it appears, so why would my DVD player like one over the other?
-- mrcodedude
Well, apparently they aren't exactly the same. :p

If you have a substantial number of discs that won't play in your player, maybe it would be in your best interest to return or ebay the Onkyo and spend your time/money to buy a player that's not a picky bitch and will handle your existing collection, instead of buying and re-burning a bunch of CD's. IME, Pioneer DVD players (specifically an older model, the DV-333) have been able to play every variety of CD-R and CD-RW I've tried.

Just something to consider. :D