Originally posted by: Sxotty
Originally posted by: Insane3D
I don't claim to know the full circumstances surrounding that incident, but I think the questions surround the level of return fire from the tank. These coalition troops were in the most powerful tank in the world, and I don't know for sure, but I would imagine a sniper with a rifle is little or no danger to a tank. They returned fire to a supposed sniper with a rifle with a full tank cannon round. Most of the questions surrounding that incident are because of the level of return fire to a guy with a rifle. That being said, the reporters in Iraq should understand they are taking a risk, and had the chance to get out before it started. I guess it will just be chalked up to an unfortunate result of war.
Now not to be rude but every at all credible report says there were infantry there as well with no armor. It is not unusual that the tank fired, in fact that is what they do it is much more effective than a hollywood sniper duel.
The problem is that no one is sure if they were actually being fired upon.
IMHO it could easily have been flash bulbs going off from photographers, and a sniper somewhere else so they thought the fire came from there, they were under fire, that is not in doubt. There was danger, and they responded.
The only questions are whether the fire was actually from the hotel.
It is sad that more innocents died, but it would be equally sad if an infrantryman died because they did not respond.