why is eating dogs despicable while eating other animals is not?

Page 2 - Seeking answers? Join the AnandTech community: where nearly half-a-million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.

Vic

Elite Member
Jun 12, 2001
50,422
14,337
136
Originally posted by: JSFLY
Originally posted by: Vic
Originally posted by: LongCoolMother
Originally posted by: Mo0o
Because Americans often keep dogs as pets and develop a strong relationship with them. Most AMericans dont have pet cows

/thread

thank you. that answers my question!
It's not the correct answer.

The correct answer is that, in general, predator mammals don't eat other predator mammals. There's something evolutionary about it, as other predators don't taste good to us while herbivores do.

Dogs are omnivores, like pigs, and are in fact closely related to pigs. Eating dogs is something that comes and goes depending on customs. For example, the Lewis & Clark expedition had a pet dog along (Lewis' Newfoundland named Seaman), but they also bought dogs to eat from the native American tribes. They even did this while encamped on the Pacific coast, much to the amusement of the local tribes, because most them did not like eating the local salmon.

So your saying Americans don't eat predatory animals like dogs and cats? That we like eating herbivors like cows? But what about horses, why aren't we eating them?

And why is it that people in asia do eat dogs and cats? Even when they've got enough herbivors to eat? Are people in asia are just not predatory enough?

Sorry but I think 1st answer was correct.
Go back 100 years and more. If a man ate his horse, how would he plow his fields? Not that people didn't eat horse, it was just frowned upon as a poor investment.
 

Phoenix86

Lifer
May 21, 2003
14,644
10
81
Originally posted by: JulesMaximus
Originally posted by: aidanjm
I agree with you on the cows thing - they are gentle, likeable creatures. Different cows have distinct personalities - some cows are adventurous, some are clever and inquisitive, some are gentle and shy. There is always one cow in every hurd that is smarter than the rest - this is the cow that will work out how to undo the gate latch with her horns, and lead the others to fresh pasture when she decides the time is right. I grew up on a beef farm, which is why I don't eat meat. ;)

What the hell is a hurd? :confused:

Nice edit, but I'll be nice and won't bust your ass about the horns.

<--- moo
 

BooGiMaN

Diamond Member
Jul 5, 2001
7,955
0
0
you wrote "Cows are not like lions or tigers, they are not fierce and malicious. Killing and eating tigers should be okay-- they deserve it at least. "

explain to me how lions or tigers are malicious...umm hello they are predators....they eat other animals

they are built to efficiently hunt and eat prey...usually herbivores..there is nothing malicious about what they do..

didnt you ever learn the whole cycle of life thing...maybe you need to watch the Lion King.....
 

JulesMaximus

No Lifer
Jul 3, 2003
74,599
1,001
126
Originally posted by: aidanjm
Originally posted by: JulesMaximus
Originally posted by: aidanjm
I agree with you on the cows thing - they are gentle, likeable creatures. Different cows have distinct personalities - some cows are adventurous, some are clever and inquisitive, some are gentle and shy. There is always one cow in every hurd that is smarter than the rest - this is the cow that will work out how to undo the gate latch with her horns, and lead the others to fresh pasture when she decides the time is right. I grew up on a beef farm, which is why I don't eat meat. ;)

Cows don't have horns genius. And what the hell is a hurd? :confused:

a hurd is a revolutionary kernel being developed by the GNU/ free software people. IT will eventually replace Torvald's 'linux' kernel.

a herd (in this context) is a group of cows.

I skipped my meds this morning, which possibly explains why I mixed the two up. :)

And yes, some cows do have horns. Altho many (most?) farmer will de-horn their cows/ calves to reduce chance of being skewered by an irritated cow.

Some do. I've never seen one though.

Decided to google it after I posted just to check. I admit, I was wrong. :eek:
 

torpid

Lifer
Sep 14, 2003
11,631
11
76
The predator theory fails on certain animals, like gators, which are eaten without disgust. Well, not MUCH disgust, anyway.
 

JSFLY

Golden Member
Mar 24, 2006
1,068
0
0
Originally posted by: Vic
Originally posted by: JSFLY
Originally posted by: Vic
Originally posted by: LongCoolMother
Originally posted by: Mo0o
Because Americans often keep dogs as pets and develop a strong relationship with them. Most AMericans dont have pet cows

/thread

thank you. that answers my question!
It's not the correct answer.

The correct answer is that, in general, predator mammals don't eat other predator mammals. There's something evolutionary about it, as other predators don't taste good to us while herbivores do.

Dogs are omnivores, like pigs, and are in fact closely related to pigs. Eating dogs is something that comes and goes depending on customs. For example, the Lewis & Clark expedition had a pet dog along (Lewis' Newfoundland named Seaman), but they also bought dogs to eat from the native American tribes. They even did this while encamped on the Pacific coast, much to the amusement of the local tribes, because most them did not like eating the local salmon.

So your saying Americans don't eat predatory animals like dogs and cats? That we like eating herbivors like cows? But what about horses, why aren't we eating them?

And why is it that people in asia do eat dogs and cats? Even when they've got enough herbivors to eat? Are people in asia are just not predatory enough?

Sorry but I think 1st answer was correct.
Go back 100 years and more. If a man ate his horse, how would he plow his fields? Not that people didn't eat horse, it was just frowned upon as a poor investment.


What about now? I don't think farmers plow their fields using his horse anymore, unless he is amish.

So why don't we eat horses now? Because we've developed a relationship with them through riding and befriending them. Just as we have done with cats and dogs minus the riding part.

and you still havent addressed why people in asia continue to eat so called "predatory animals" while we in the west dont.
 

torpid

Lifer
Sep 14, 2003
11,631
11
76
Originally posted by: JulesMaximus
Originally posted by: aidanjm
Originally posted by: JulesMaximus
Originally posted by: aidanjm
I agree with you on the cows thing - they are gentle, likeable creatures. Different cows have distinct personalities - some cows are adventurous, some are clever and inquisitive, some are gentle and shy. There is always one cow in every hurd that is smarter than the rest - this is the cow that will work out how to undo the gate latch with her horns, and lead the others to fresh pasture when she decides the time is right. I grew up on a beef farm, which is why I don't eat meat. ;)

Cows don't have horns genius. And what the hell is a hurd? :confused:

a hurd is a revolutionary kernel being developed by the GNU/ free software people. IT will eventually replace Torvald's 'linux' kernel.

a herd (in this context) is a group of cows.

I skipped my meds this morning, which possibly explains why I mixed the two up. :)

And yes, some cows do have horns. Altho many (most?) farmer will de-horn their cows/ calves to reduce chance of being skewered by an irritated cow.

Some do. I've never seen one though.

Decided to google it after I posted just to check. I admit, I was wrong. :eek:

Time to head to the san diego zoo!!
 

ggnl

Diamond Member
Jul 2, 2004
5,095
1
0
Vincent: How about a dog? Dogs eats its own feces.

Jules: I don't eat dog either.

Vincent: Yeah, but do you consider a dog to be a filthy animal?

Jules: I wouldn't go so far as to call a dog filthy but they're definitely dirty. But, a dog's got personality. Personality goes a long way.

Vincent: Ah, so by that rationale, if a pig had a better personality, he would cease to be a filthy animal. Is that true?

Jules: Well we'd have to be talkin' about one charmin' motherfuckin' pig. I mean he'd have to be ten times more charmin' than that Arnold on Green Acres, you know what I'm sayin'?
 

herkulease

Diamond Member
Jul 6, 2001
3,923
0
0
I don't buy the predator thing.

we grind up cows, chickens, pigs and feed them to cows, chicken and pigs.

You could argue that's man's doing and not nature but they ahve no problem eating them.

for me I like it. cows eat grinded up cows. that's double the beef. :)
 

Dacalo

Diamond Member
Mar 31, 2000
8,778
4
76
Originally posted by: Vic
Go back 100 years and more. If a man ate his horse, how would he plow his fields? Not that people didn't eat horse, it was just frowned upon as a poor investment.

Uh, weren't cows used to plow fields?
 

gsellis

Diamond Member
Dec 4, 2003
6,061
0
0
There are some smells that you can remember. I would not eat dog because:

A) I don't eat pets.

B) The smell of roasting dog is farking awful. I lived in the Philippines when I was 3-5. I remember when the old kids in the neighborhood captured, beat to death with a board with nails in it, skinned and gutted, and roasted a dog. I did not like them killing the dog, but that did not bother me like the smell. There are times I smell something like it and it makes me just go - EWWWWWWWWWWWW!!!
 

Eli

Super Moderator | Elite Member
Oct 9, 1999
50,419
8
81
Originally posted by: herkulease
I don't buy the predator thing.

we grind up cows, chickens, pigs and feed them to cows, chicken and pigs.

You could argue that's man's doing and not nature but they ahve no problem eating them.

for me I like it. cows eat grinded up cows. that's double the beef. :)
AFAIK it is against the law to do that now.

Or they're looking into legislation regarding it, or something.
 

Number1

Diamond Member
Feb 24, 2006
7,881
549
126
Originally posted by: Vic
Rabbits are kept as pets.

Rabits have no prsonality. Rabits don't make good pets, however they are delicious.
I love rabits meat.
 

Vic

Elite Member
Jun 12, 2001
50,422
14,337
136
Originally posted by: Number1
Originally posted by: Vic
Rabbits are kept as pets.

Rabits have no prsonality. Rabits don't make good pets, however they are delicious.
I love rabits meat.
And why don't rabbits have any personality? Because they're a herbivore version of a domestic cat. It doesn't take personality or intelligence to stalk your dinner when your dinner is a blade of grass.
 

vi edit

Elite Member
Super Moderator
Oct 28, 1999
62,484
8,345
126
Underlying evolutionary factors or not, modern civilization views dogs as household pets. To many people they are replacements for children and are pampered as such. They don't do that with pigs, they don't do that with rabbits, they don't do that with cows. None of these animals *typically* sleep in your home or even in your own bed.

The reason we don't eat a lot of the "predators" anymore is because they are in rare numbers. We have laws that limit the times we can hunt predators (with the exception of coyotes) if we are even allowed to hunt them at all.

How many lions are there to gazelle? How many pumas are there to wild pigs?

Plus with most predators, the amount of food you must feed them vs. what you get in return just doesn't pay off. They consume far more than they provide.

But in this age, it still comes down to societal taboos. In this country, and many civilized countries, it's a taboo to eat dogs. We just are too emotially attached to them.
 

Number1

Diamond Member
Feb 24, 2006
7,881
549
126
Most people would not have cows, pigs, chickens or turkeys as pets because they simply would not be good pets to have around in or around the house. On the other hand, dogs and cats are sized right for our houses, have personalities, can be easily trained, are excellent company and display unconditional love to us humans.

It's a no brainer. We developed strong relationship with our pets and that is why we don't eat them.

Unfortunately for the cows, pigs, chickens and turkeys, we, as human being need to eat. In other countries not as fortunate as ours, they also eat dogs and cats because other meat is not always available. When you are poor, you?ll eat anything. Over the years, eating dogs and cats then becomes a routine part of life and you learn not to become attached to them.
 

Number1

Diamond Member
Feb 24, 2006
7,881
549
126
Originally posted by: Vic
Originally posted by: Number1
Originally posted by: Vic
Rabbits are kept as pets.

Rabits have no prsonality. Rabits don't make good pets, however they are delicious.
I love rabits meat.
And why don't rabbits have any personality? Because they're a herbivore version of a domestic cat. It doesn't take personality or intelligence to stalk your dinner when your dinner is a blade of grass.

And unfortunatly for them, it makes them borring.
 

hehatedme

Member
Jul 10, 2005
72
0
0
I think a lot of it has to do with perception, like what a lot of people have already said. Its similar to all these campaigns to save baby seals and what not because they are cuter than other animals, even though their imporatance may not be.

Also another argument is that is very efficient to process beef versus other meats. Probably a lot more than smaller more individualistic animals.
 

OMoT

Member
May 17, 2006
137
0
0
Here a question: Wouldnt you rather eat your dog that has passed away, knowing that s/he lived a fulfilling and happy life, or what you rather eat a cow/chicken/pig/etc. that lived a short life and was raised in a barn with no windows and artificial fattening supplements, and was tortured before its death?


BTW, Im not a vegetarian
 

marincounty

Diamond Member
Nov 16, 2005
3,227
5
76
It's just a societal taboo because we love our dogs here in America.
But enjoy your dogburger.