Question Why hasn't AMD announced desktop Renoir APUs?

Page 3 - Seeking answers? Join the AnandTech community: where nearly half-a-million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.

TheRookie

Junior Member
Aug 26, 2019
14
2
16
Why hasn't AMD announced desktop Renoir APUs?

AMD could simple release the same Renoir mobile processors on the desktop.

For example:

Ryzen 5 4600H --> Ryzen 5 3600G

Ryzen 7 4800H --> Ryzen 7 3700G/3800G
 

DrMrLordX

Lifer
Apr 27, 2000
15,439
4,229
136
@Shivansps

That seems plausible. I'm not convinced that they'll have an APU in the $300 or higher segment, though. $250 might be a stretch, or it might not last long at that price point due to market forces. Less than 6 months to Vermeer in all probability, and that will change the market value of a lot of things.
 

moinmoin

Golden Member
Jun 1, 2017
1,562
1,411
106
With Ryzen 3000 the APUs replaced the sub 6 cores offerings. I can see the same happening with sub 8 cores (sub 12 seems like too big a stretch) offerings as part of Ryzen 4000. Pricing will depend on how AMD intends to set up the range in the next round. But I suspect they'll do more of what they did with Ryzen 3000/Threadripper 3 where they essentially kept the Zen 1 prices at launch but extended the performance (thanks to Zen 2) and expanded the top end offerings with more cores. So we may see little changes which would mean Renoir costing the same as iGPU-less counterparts currently.
 
  • Like
Reactions: maddie

Gideon

Senior member
Nov 27, 2007
756
1,085
136
With Ryzen 3000 the APUs replaced the sub 6 cores offerings. I can see the same happening with sub 8 cores (sub 12 seems like too big a stretch) offerings as part of Ryzen 4000. Pricing will depend on how AMD intends to set up the range in the next round. But I suspect they'll do more of what they did with Ryzen 3000/Threadripper 3 where they essentially kept the Zen 1 prices at launch but extended the performance (thanks to Zen 2) and expanded the top end offerings with more cores. So we may see little changes which would mean Renoir costing the same as iGPU-less counterparts currently.
Phasing out 3600 and 3600x would be a very bad move, as the strong gaming performance of these chips really relies on the 2x16MB of L3 cache. The APU cuts it doen to 2x4MB.
 
  • Like
Reactions: lightmanek

maddie

Diamond Member
Jul 18, 2010
3,065
1,684
136
Phasing out 3600 and 3600x would be a very bad move, as the strong gaming performance of these chips really relies on the 2x16MB of L3 cache. The APU cuts it doen to 2x4MB.
Do we have any indication that the cache reduction will hurt a lot? I ask this as there is no chiplet penalty in APUs.
 

Gideon

Senior member
Nov 27, 2007
756
1,085
136
Do we have any indication that the cache reduction will hurt a lot? I ask this as there is no chiplet penalty in APUs.
That's actually a good point, didn't consider the fact that Renoir on desktop can improve memory latency noticably.

Still, according to AMD itself the added L3 cuts effective memory latency by (up to) 33ns:


Now I know it's a marketing slide (gamecache, eww), but even then this looks like a substantial increase (the L3 is quadroupled not doubled). Does anyone have the RZ3-15 endnotes slide to know the details of how AMD measured it?
 

moinmoin

Golden Member
Jun 1, 2017
1,562
1,411
106
Phasing out 3600 and 3600x would be a very bad move, as the strong gaming performance of these chips really relies on the 2x16MB of L3 cache. The APU cuts it doen to 2x4MB.
Older gens are not really phased out, they just don't get a non-APU successor in the new gen (like 4600, if that is still 6c/12t).

Regarding the influence of the cut L3 cache size on Renoir has on latency plenty folks seem to expect the worst. I expect it to be the first application of Zen 3's unified L3 cache, making it perform with similar latency just like AMD managed with the previous two APU gens despite their cut L3 caches.
 

DrMrLordX

Lifer
Apr 27, 2000
15,439
4,229
136
Phasing out 3600 and 3600x would be a very bad move, as the strong gaming performance of these chips really relies on the 2x16MB of L3 cache. The APU cuts it doen to 2x4MB.
Those chips will only be phased out when AMD releases Vermeer equivalents. Those will be even better as gaming chips.
 

ASK THE COMMUNITY