Why do auto-repair workshops have the highest concentration of scumbags in the world?

Status
Not open for further replies.

nublikescake

Senior member
Jul 23, 2008
890
0
0
So I recently bought a used car and decided to take it to the relevant dealership to have it looked at (I guess that was my first mistake!). My main concern is the rear shock absorbers which I knew at the time of buying, needed to be replaced. That's why I got the car a little cheap.

This morning I drive it to the local dealership in the hope that the "experts" at the dealership would be able to identify the exact problem and suggest the best solution as dealership mechanics supposedly have specialized knowledge/training w.r.t. to the particular manufacturer's vehicles. I was also thinking of asking them for an overall checkup just to see if everything is ok with the car. So I mention to the guy that I got the car used and that other than the shocks, it would be nice to have the entire car looked at. He shows me this form with a big checklist of items that they can check for as part of their standard "32-point" inspection or whatever the hell they call it. It includes a free oil/filter change. Guess what the price tag is? $400!!! Remember, this is just an inspection of the car with a free oil change. No thanks! You can take the filter and shove it up your greasy behind!

Of course I decline the full inspection and ask him to check the shocks only. I told him earlier that the shocks are a bit noisy and the car feels bouncy for a while after going over a bump (telltale sign of failed shock absorbers). The douchebags puts this down as two separate items on the bill! Yes, that's right, checking for noise is one item AND checking for bounce is another! I noticed this douchebaggery just when I was about to sign the work-order. After some arguing, he agreed to combine the two and treat them as one billable item.

I ended up agreeing to pay an amount for which an average mechanic would be willing to do the entire inspection, including shocks: $70.

*Sigh* The auto-repair scumbags have never disappointed me....


Should have taken the car to a regular garage. I can't send your car there, but I can send this thread to The Garage. -Anandtech Moderator DrPizza
 

theflyingpig

Banned
Mar 9, 2008
5,616
18
0
What's the difference between the "average mechanic" and auto-repair scumbags. Please tell me. I must know this.
 

RbSX

Diamond Member
Jan 18, 2002
8,351
1
76
They might be scum bags but they get away with it because idiots like you will see them.

Go find a good local mechanic.
 

nublikescake

Senior member
Jul 23, 2008
890
0
0
Originally posted by: theflyingpig
What's the difference between the "average mechanic" and auto-repair scumbags. Please tell me. I must know this.

An average "trusted" mechanic is what I really meant to say. You know one of those guys who have a smallish shop where you have to wait a while for service but end up getting the job done for cheap. The sad part is that I know one of these guys.
 

xanis

Lifer
Sep 11, 2005
17,571
8
0
Originally posted by: theflyingpig
What's the difference between the "average mechanic" and auto-repair scumbags. Please tell me. I must know this.

An "average mechanic" at a local repair shop is a lot less likely to rape you on repair costs, especially if you know him and you're planning on making repeat visits. I'm in the same boat as TallBill... my mechanic is awesome. My family has been taking their cars to him for a good 20+ years now and he's never once tried to scam us or get us to pay for things that we didn't need. Oh, and he gives free oil changes if you're getting other work done. :)
 

waggy

No Lifer
Dec 14, 2000
68,143
10
81
Originally posted by: Xanis
Originally posted by: theflyingpig
What's the difference between the "average mechanic" and auto-repair scumbags. Please tell me. I must know this.

An "average mechanic" at a local repair shop is a lot less likely to rape you on repair costs, especially if you know him and you're planning on making repeat visits. I'm in the same boat as TallBill... my mechanic is awesome. My family has been taking their cars to him for a good 20+ years now and he's never once tried to scam us or get us to pay for things that we didn't need. Oh, and he gives free oil changes if you're getting other work done. :)

true to a point. i have found the one i go to has been starting ot over charge me.

i used to take the car in and drop it off and just say fix it. i would get a good price on the work done.

last time i went in they said it ow uld be more then what they said and they "fixed" some stuff i didnt say they could.

it pissed me off and i am changing places.
 

Sea Moose

Diamond Member
May 12, 2009
6,933
7
76
I trusted my mechanic. I would give him my car over the weekend and it would be ready monday. He was a one man mobile business so he didnt have time for bs

If i had shock problems, my mechanic knew who to go to, and who to avoid, so he would take it to the specialists


Wait, you know about the secret handshake right?
 

episodic

Lifer
Feb 7, 2004
11,088
2
81
Usually when I move into a town, I find the 'old school' auto parts store in town. . . usually NAPA or the like. . . family owned better.

Go in and look for the owner/manager - or a grizzled guy that just reeks of knowing his stuff. . .

Mention to him you are looking for a good mechanic that does work on the side and you were wondering if he could point you in the right direction. . . 9/10 times they will do just that.

I prefer guys that know their stuff and like to make extra cash on the side. Many will bring their tools and ramps to your house and fix it for less than what the dealer or local mechanics will charge - many are moonlighting from those same jobs.

In the last 15 years, I've never once spent more than $3000 dollars on a car and every car I've bought ran from 3-5 years without major trouble - just by having guys like this go over it for me. . .

Just bought my wife a 96 Taurus that had a an engine dropped in it with only 37,000 miles. The rear struts were soft -- I knew that going in. I had the guy locate an engine from a rear ended wreck - and found the body in craigslist ad for car with no engine. Basically the car runs like new - total cost? 300$ for the body - and the guy I hired pulled and installed the engine and put new struts in for $800 dollars inclusive. The car runs like new. . .

 

MrMatt

Banned
Mar 3, 2009
3,905
7
0
This is why I'm glad my dad's been in the field either as an autobody repair-man, or mechanic, for 38 years now. First job he got, and he hasn't left.
 

dudeman007

Diamond Member
Apr 6, 2004
3,243
0
0
Originally posted by: episodic

Just bought my wife a 96 Taurus that had a an engine dropped in it with only 37,000 miles. The rear struts were soft -- I knew that going in. I had the guy locate an engine from a rear ended wreck - and found the body in craigslist ad for car with no engine. Basically the car runs like new - total cost? 300$ for the body - and the guy I hired pulled and installed the engine and put new struts in for $800 dollars inclusive. The car runs like new. . .


That's some cool beans
 

boomerang

Lifer
Jun 19, 2000
18,883
641
126
OP, if you brought your car into my place of business with that attitude, I'd politely ask you to leave.

It's clear from your post that you consider mechanics to be second class citizens. You're entitled to that opinion, but it wouldn't fly with me. I would suddenly be booked for weeks ahead.
 

bruceb

Diamond Member
Aug 20, 2004
8,874
111
106
Most mechanics I have dealt with, either private or dealership techs, know what to fix and how to do it properly.
The issuses mainly are the very high rates dealerships charge for labor and parts markup and the service manager
always trying to upsell additional services (some of which may genuinely needed at the time, others optional)
So I try to find a trusted local mechanic when I can. I have one place near me, Euro Tire, which is excellent for
stuff like, brakes, suspension, wheel bearings work. Labor rate varies, depending on if you bring the parts or
they order them for you. But the work is top notch.
 

mztykal

Diamond Member
Apr 21, 2000
6,709
48
91
You sound kinda condescending, if you knew the struts/shocks were bad, why not just have them changed? Why bother having them inspected? Also 400 to have and ENTIRE car looked at, at the DEALER isn't that bad of a price. Time is money...
 
Status
Not open for further replies.