Why are vehicle enthusiasts attracted to LOUD vehicles?

Page 6 - Seeking answers? Join the AnandTech community: where nearly half-a-million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.

Apex

Diamond Member
Oct 11, 1999
6,511
1
71
www.gotapex.com
Originally posted by: JulesMaximus
Originally posted by: AMDZen
Originally posted by: EyeMWing
Originally posted by: AMDZen
Originally posted by: 91TTZ
Originally posted by: AMDZen
Originally posted by: 91TTZ
My car is modded but it's still fairly quiet. The turbos really help muffle the sound. And it doesn't sound restricted at WOT either.

Ummm, yea. If you have turbos (plural) and the car is quiet, then yes you are restricting something somewhere. And turbo car's are normally louder, not quieter, then their naturally aspirated equivelant. There is no way in he|| you could not be restricting a car thats turbo charged, if its quiet. Besides, chances are that you don't have turbo's (plural).

That is 100% false. Turbocharged cars will ALWAYS be quieter than their naturally aspirated equivalents because the turbine section of the turbo is in the exhaust stream, mulling the exhaust pulses. An NA engine will have a louder, raspier exhaust note with the same exhaust system.

Read and learn.

Depends on if your going to run the turbos CORRECTLY. If their running at a decent amout of boost, you always have to have a BOV. Have you ever heard a BOV? Its loud. Besides, if you turbo your car, you usually free up the exhaust, because if your after more power then why would you be restricting it? Turbo cars become louder BECAUSE their normally bolted onto cars. I'm not talking about turbo cars that came from the factory with a much lower compression.

BOVs are not loud, unless you get a pansyass one with a very restricted flow. "PFFT" every time it clutches isn't bad. A bus venting air brakes is louder. Or you're overly sensitive.

I seriously can't believe how so many people on this board have no idea what they're talking about when it comes to cars.

I can hear my Friends Evo VIII from 5 BLOCKS AWAY+++. I know exactly when he's coming, first you hear the Turbo-charged four running through the down pipe out the exhaust, and right before the shift you hear a huge WSHHHHHHHHHHHSHHHHHH. Maybe the BOV's you here aren't loud, but those people probably aren't running a big enough intercooler's at high enough boost to even NEED a BOV in the first place.

That's probably because he put a useless aftermarket BOV on it. :roll: Trust me, if he's stock he doesn't need a BOV. You don't need a BOV until you are making over 20lbs of boost. I don't know how it is with the Evo but if it's like the WRX-STi it has a recirculation valve which is almost inaudible when you let off the gas between shifts.

He paid $200 for absolutely no reason other than to make his car go Whooosh between shifts. Your friend=moron.

To add to that:

Bypass valve > BOV

Especially for MAS type systems. With MAP, the difference is smaller.
 

Twista

Diamond Member
Jun 19, 2003
9,646
1
0
;) dnuno but i love the cars. Getting my mustang this month ;) so happy! loud car owners unite!
 

Iron Woode

Elite Member
Super Moderator
Oct 10, 1999
31,328
12,838
136
Originally posted by: IGBT
..many communities have established motor vehicle noise standards that are enforceable and withstood court challenges and there's movement towards noise standards enforced by the EPA via smog checks ie.OEM muffler equipment must be maintained and off road exhaust equipment found on vehicles/cycles registered for street use will be subject to fines and must be returned to OEM otherwise it can't be registered. I recall a biker in my hood that was very noisy..he finally got pulled over..I don't know what the ticket was for but I don't hear that noisy POS any more..so relief is on the way.
Actually as long as aftermarket parts are approved by CARB and licensed by SEMA there is no EPA violation.

Noise standards are a local issue.

If I put a Walker muffler on a car to replace the OEM muffler, there is no violation. Even if it is louder than stock. Free enterprise allows this. Noise is not the concern of the EPA. As long as emmisions aren't changed for the worse, its a legal replacement.
 

cmdrmoocow

Golden Member
Jul 22, 2004
1,503
0
0
Honda? Mustang?

I still love my Caravan with it's 3.3 V6. Fast enough to keep me happy, silent to please the neighbors, and slow enough to keep me from getting pulled over!


158hp @ 4850 RPM
203lb-ft @ 3250 RPM
4000+lb curb weight
 

cbehnken

Golden Member
Aug 23, 2004
1,402
0
0
Originally posted by: AMDZen
Originally posted by: 91TTZ
My car is modded but it's still fairly quiet. The turbos really help muffle the sound. And it doesn't sound restricted at WOT either.

Ummm, yea. If you have turbos (plural) and the car is quiet, then yes you are restricting something somewhere. And turbo car's are normally louder, not quieter, then their naturally aspirated equivelant. There is no way in he|| you could not be restricting a car thats turbo charged, if its quiet. Besides, chances are that you don't have turbo's (plural).

You're an idiot.

Turbochargers themselve convert energy (heat and SOUND) into movement of the turbine wheel. The actual design of a turbo quiets the exhaust significantly. That's why turbo cars usually have less resonators and premufflers on them. My 95 Stealth R/T TT has 2 less premufflers than the NA car and it is just as quiet.

Why don't you read a little bit about turbos instead of staring at fart cans. It is very easy to make a fast, powerful car that really isn't that loud. You just can't be an idiot like yourself.
 
Jan 31, 2002
40,819
2
0
Originally posted by: cmdrmoocow
Honda? Mustang?

I still love my Caravan with it's 3.3 V6. Fast enough to keep me happy, silent to please the neighbors, and slow enough to keep me from getting pulled over!


158hp @ 4850 RPM
203lb-ft @ 3250 RPM
4000+lb curb weight

You're a soccermom, aren't you.

- M4H
 

Vic

Elite Member
Jun 12, 2001
50,422
14,337
136
Originally posted by: AMDZen
Originally posted by: 91TTZ
My car is modded but it's still fairly quiet. The turbos really help muffle the sound. And it doesn't sound restricted at WOT either.
Ummm, yea. If you have turbos (plural) and the car is quiet, then yes you are restricting something somewhere. And turbo car's are normally louder, not quieter, then their naturally aspirated equivelant. There is no way in he|| you could not be restricting a car thats turbo charged, if its quiet. Besides, chances are that you don't have turbo's (plural).
Wrong. The turbo charger itself always acts as a kind of muffler. How the fsck do you think it's spooled up but by harnessing energy from the exhaust?
You're no longer allowed to post like you know jack sh!t about cars, because you obviously don't. You made an absolute fool of yourself in this thread. Go back to your Civic, idiot.

Originally posted by: AMDZen
The Civic I have is merely one of the cars I have. I own 3 vehicles. You think your Z is so frickin hot?? My friends S2000 would totally spank it. And thats completely naturally aspirated. I love how people think they're hot stuff because their using forced induction, and get spanked by TRUE ENGINEERING, not the easy way to make power.
OMG what a fscking moron. You know more or less nothing about how engines work. Here's a clue. An engine is an air pump. The more air it can pump, the more power it can produce. There are 3 ways to push more air through a motor. The first (and most popular) is to increase the overall displacement, no power drawbacks just increased weight and fuel consumption. The second (which is Honda's way) is to increase the rpm redline to the moon, but this has the drawback of not increasing torque, as torque is created through displacement. The third is to use forced induction, which acts like instant displacement and increases both torque and power, and the only drawback is waiting for the supercharger to spool up.
Of the 3 ways to increase power, Honda's "all motor" technique is the most inferior BY FAR. It is essentially nothing more than a fancy lumpy cam system.


Back on topic. I think cars should have a well-tuned sound. Not too loud, not too quiet. All I want to do is hear it, I don't really care if anyone else does.

For the record, my WRX has a catless uppipe plus TurboXS Stealthback turbo back exhaust (4" thermal-coated bellmouth downpipe plus 3" high flow cat and center pipe) with a Prodrive axleback muffler. Nice low rumble under normal driving circumstances, not too loud WOT, and no louder than stock cruising on the highway. Great looking too... the entire axleback is polished stainless steel with a rolled edge oval tip.
 

exodus454

Senior member
Apr 11, 2004
465
0
0
Originally posted by: JulesMaximus
Originally posted by: CraigRT
I like teh sound of a nice sounding car /exhaust!

ok fine, enjoy your ford taurus, i'll take my Ferrari with NO radio just to listen to the sound teh car makes, ANY DAY OF THE WEEK!
MUSIC TO MY EARS!

a true car buff understands this.

Well, a Ferrari is music to the ears.

A fart canned Honda Civic is only annoying. A GTO with open exhaust is equally annoying...especially at 4AM.


a nicely tuned V12 is just about one of the most musical things you could ever hear.
 

exodus454

Senior member
Apr 11, 2004
465
0
0
Originally posted by: AMDZen
Originally posted by: 91TTZ
Originally posted by: AMDZen
Originally posted by: 91TTZ
My car is modded but it's still fairly quiet. The turbos really help muffle the sound. And it doesn't sound restricted at WOT either.

Ummm, yea. If you have turbos (plural) and the car is quiet, then yes you are restricting something somewhere. And turbo car's are normally louder, not quieter, then their naturally aspirated equivelant. There is no way in he|| you could not be restricting a car thats turbo charged, if its quiet. Besides, chances are that you don't have turbo's (plural).

That is 100% false. Turbocharged cars will ALWAYS be quieter than their naturally aspirated equivalents because the turbine section of the turbo is in the exhaust stream, mulling the exhaust pulses. An NA engine will have a louder, raspier exhaust note with the same exhaust system.

Read and learn.

Depends on if your going to run the turbos CORRECTLY. If their running at a decent amout of boost, you always have to have a BOV. Have you ever heard a BOV? Its loud. Besides, if you turbo your car, you usually free up the exhaust, because if your after more power then why would you be restricting it? Turbo cars become louder BECAUSE their normally bolted onto cars. I'm not talking about turbo cars that came from the factory with a much lower compression.


BOV's dont always have to be loud, the ones that dump the extra boost back into the exhaust are silent, and there is no need for these rice rocket jackasses with the screaming BOVs.. its useless and completely "look at me" imo.
 

Vic

Elite Member
Jun 12, 2001
50,422
14,337
136
Originally posted by: exodus454
BOV's dont always have to be loud, the ones that dump the extra boost back into the exhaust are silent, and there is no need for these rice rocket jackasses with the screaming BOVs.. its useless and completely "look at me" imo.
You are correct. They're called recirculating bypass valves. Except they dump back into the intake, not the exhaust. The wastegate is what dumps back into the exhaust.

Screaming BOV's on street cars are exclusively for bling, and can actually reduce performance and/or harm the engine because they can screw with the A/F ratios.
 

Amused

Elite Member
Apr 14, 2001
57,452
19,913
146
To some, the sound of an engine is music to their ears. And some people like loud music.

:D
 

cmdrmoocow

Golden Member
Jul 22, 2004
1,503
0
0
Originally posted by: MercenaryForHire
Originally posted by: cmdrmoocow
Honda? Mustang?

I still love my Caravan with it's 3.3 V6. Fast enough to keep me happy, silent to please the neighbors, and slow enough to keep me from getting pulled over!


158hp @ 4850 RPM
203lb-ft @ 3250 RPM
4000+lb curb weight

You're a soccermom, aren't you.

- M4H

18yo college kid :p

 
Jan 31, 2002
40,819
2
0
Originally posted by: cmdrmoocow
Originally posted by: MercenaryForHire
Originally posted by: cmdrmoocow
Honda? Mustang?

I still love my Caravan with it's 3.3 V6. Fast enough to keep me happy, silent to please the neighbors, and slow enough to keep me from getting pulled over!


158hp @ 4850 RPM
203lb-ft @ 3250 RPM
4000+lb curb weight

You're a soccermom, aren't you.

- M4H

18yo college kid :p

Minivan PowAh!

/also drives an 03 Odyssey

Props for not ricing it out like I'm sure your friends tell you to. And I concur - nothing like being invisible to the "College Kid Radar" that comes standard on police cars. ;)

- M4H
 

PHiuR

Diamond Member
Apr 24, 2001
9,539
2
76
amdzen: just cause your car has turbos doesnt mean it has to have LOUD BOVs...my friends s4 doesnt even have BOVs. (btw running 17-18psi)
 

Vic

Elite Member
Jun 12, 2001
50,422
14,337
136
Originally posted by: Amused
To some, the sound of an engine is music to their ears. And some people like loud music.

:D
Heh. True that. I'm often torn between the stereo and the exhaust. The way it should be IMO.

:beer:
 

Demon-Xanth

Lifer
Feb 15, 2000
20,551
2
81
As far as "peak power is what is important" is concerned, compare that more than once, I have had a Celica GTS fail to keep up with my truck. 180HP, 2700LBs=15LBs/HP. 230HP, 4200LBs=18.3LBs/HP.

...shouldn't I have lost? Why didn't I? Why did they have to spin the tires at launch and I didn't?

Simple: They have a very narrow, high up power band, and I have a wide one that is well within normal driving conditions.

The SRT-4 (230HP) and WRX (227HP, non-STI for this example) all have wider power bands than the the RSX, Celica GTS, and others that would be in thier class. But the performance isn't even close. The dyno charts I have seen for the SRT-4s have really suprized, and impressed me. The performance from the WRX impresses me. The RSX and Celica GTS to me are prime examples of peak number focus.

Another example of the peril of high RPM tuning:
S2000:
0-60 5.5 seconds. Not bad.
5-60 6.9 seconds. Not that good.
For 240HP and 2900LBs, that last number is flat out awful. It means that to perform well, you have to flog it. Taking off from a roll costs you a second and a half.

Neon SRT-4, 230HP, 3000LBs. The S2000 SHOULD beat it. Hell, the S2000 even has RWD!
0-60: 5.3 seconds. It's close
5-60: 5.7 seconds. The S2000 got SERVED!

Unless you like burning the tires and clutch on the street, a wider, lower band can pay off in dividends.
 

Concillian

Diamond Member
May 26, 2004
3,751
8
81
HAHAHAHA this thread is great, if for no other reason than to laugh at AMDZen and his automobile engine "knowledge"

He is perhaps the ideal example to the OP as to why people like loud cars.... because they are CLUELESS and think a loud exhaust = more power and that a loud BOV = more power.

Loud = loud. Loud =! power.

A well engineered exhaust system is not terribly loud OR restrictive enough to reduce power significantly over a completely muffler-less exhaust. And a BOV that vents back to the intake offers no performance penalty over a BOV that vents to atmosphere and sounds obnoxious.
 

Iron Woode

Elite Member
Super Moderator
Oct 10, 1999
31,328
12,838
136
I nominate AMDzen for stupidest post/reply of the year award.

He reminds me of the guy that brags how fast his car is, but never races it against anyone he brags to. Then when you do finally see his "car", its a worn out 1984 Firebird with a big hood scoop and big rear tires on cragar SS rims. And gets his a$$ spanked by the first 318 diplomat that pulls up beside him.

Seriously, we knew a guy just like that.
 

SelArom

Senior member
Sep 28, 2004
872
0
0
www.djselarom.com
Originally posted by: SunnyD
I've noticed an increasing trend, both amongst the hardcore car enthusiasts, the ricers, and the hog/crotch-rocket riders...

I'm sorry to say, louder is NOT better.

It annoying enough when the ghangstahs drive by and you can hear all the loose parts of their car vibrating cause of the base - and you can't even hear your own radio with the windows rolled up.

WHY do people insist on making loud vehicles? I mean, I prefer a car that purrs, so damn smooth that you can't even tell it's running. Not something that shakes the walls of my house as you drive by on the road no less than 50 feet from me.

It's called a MUFFLER. Ever hear of it? Without it, your car sounds like an untuned piece of junk...

Or in the case of the ricers, it makes it sound like you put in a little 50cc engine and you're riding a rice-rocket!

Rant off...

I AGREE 100%