Why are some people so insistant that bose=quality?

Page 2 - Seeking answers? Join the AnandTech community: where nearly half-a-million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.

EatSpam

Diamond Member
May 1, 2005
6,423
0
0
Originally posted by: swaq
Bose is good. Bose is also very expensive. However, you can get better quality stuff for less. For car audio, I'd say Bose would be pretty high end for a factory system, but not that astounding for aftermarket.

In terms of sound and build quality, Bose seems to be right on the level of Koss, Craig, or any other Wal-mart level brand made in the dingiest sweatshop in China.
 

EatSpam

Diamond Member
May 1, 2005
6,423
0
0
Originally posted by: Mo0o
Originally posted by: jagec
Originally posted by: Mo0o
But I think given the choice of Bose or generic cheapies, you'd choose Bose if it was free. Obviously the price they garner is comes alot of marketing

Of course...Bose *is* better than generic, but if I had decided I was going to spend decent money on audio equipment, I'd take the time to do some research first.
Agreed. But the OP is definitely wrong in saying they're garbage. I'd be happy if i received a set of Bose speakers

Me, too! I'd sell them to some yuppie and buy something good!
 

mercanucaribe

Banned
Oct 20, 2004
9,763
1
0
Originally posted by: rhino56
bose had a heavy bass sound to the speakers, but like most PAPER speakers they suck in no time.

The bass SUCKS. I keep thinking the bass is turned up in my friend's Infiniti I30, but it's just the BOSE.
 

mercanucaribe

Banned
Oct 20, 2004
9,763
1
0
Originally posted by: Turkish
Originally posted by: goku
I get into arguements about the exact same thing every single time with the SAME PEOPLE, bose... These guys I know claim that bose makes the highest quality product and I have to keep reminding them how they're garbage and extremely overpriced. When they ask for other companies that are 'good' most say nothing except one or two who say 'those are UUBER good but REALLY EXPENSIVE' (Highly doubtful) and then they backup their statement saying bose is really good for their price. I just laugh my ass of each and everytime yet frustrated at the same time, I try to remind them that I own some bose equipment and after having it, I'd never buy it again..

Arguing goes on and on and they b1tch about how I should listen to their 'killer bose in car sound system'.... :roll:

:|

Then you truly are an idiot yourself :) Bose may be extremly overpriced, but calling it garbage is just idiotic :)

Based on y our logic, nothing is garbage--- just overpriced.
 

Turkish

Lifer
May 26, 2003
15,547
1
81
Originally posted by: mercanucaribe
Originally posted by: Turkish
Originally posted by: goku
I get into arguements about the exact same thing every single time with the SAME PEOPLE, bose... These guys I know claim that bose makes the highest quality product and I have to keep reminding them how they're garbage and extremely overpriced. When they ask for other companies that are 'good' most say nothing except one or two who say 'those are UUBER good but REALLY EXPENSIVE' (Highly doubtful) and then they backup their statement saying bose is really good for their price. I just laugh my ass of each and everytime yet frustrated at the same time, I try to remind them that I own some bose equipment and after having it, I'd never buy it again..

Arguing goes on and on and they b1tch about how I should listen to their 'killer bose in car sound system'.... :roll:

:|

Then you truly are an idiot yourself :) Bose may be extremly overpriced, but calling it garbage is just idiotic :)

Based on y our logic, nothing is garbage--- just overpriced.

Based on your logic, a Ferrari is garbage--- and overpriced :)
 

Turkish

Lifer
May 26, 2003
15,547
1
81
Originally posted by: EatSpam
Originally posted by: swaq
Bose is good. Bose is also very expensive. However, you can get better quality stuff for less. For car audio, I'd say Bose would be pretty high end for a factory system, but not that astounding for aftermarket.

In terms of sound and build quality, Bose seems to be right on the level of Koss, Craig, or any other Wal-mart level brand made in the dingiest sweatshop in China.

Yeah, right :roll:
 

NanoStuff

Banned
Mar 23, 2006
2,981
1
0
Originally posted by: Turkish
Originally posted by: EatSpam
Originally posted by: swaq
Bose is good. Bose is also very expensive. However, you can get better quality stuff for less. For car audio, I'd say Bose would be pretty high end for a factory system, but not that astounding for aftermarket.

In terms of sound and build quality, Bose seems to be right on the level of Koss, Craig, or any other Wal-mart level brand made in the dingiest sweatshop in China.

Yeah, right :roll:
I think we are in the presence of a naive Bose customer fellas.
 
Jun 27, 2005
19,216
1
61
<--- 15 years in the custom home theater business.

Bose is crap. They can't buy a review in a respected audio magazine. Most of the good reviews they get come out of those well respected bastians of audiophile knowledge, Popular Mechanics and Golf Digest. Their subwoofers tend to roll off at ~40Hz and their satellites roll off at ~16KHz. ("No highs, no lows, it must be Bose" is not just a clever jab) They don't utilize any processing other than their own "proprietary" systems which means they don't utilize Dolby's 5.1 processor. I could go on and on...

That having been said, I would have them in my store to appease the uneducated idiot who refuses to listen to reason and just has to have Bose. The only problem there is that Bose litterally attempts to take over your store. They tell you what your product mix is going to be. They tell you when and where and how often to advertise. They even take extraordinary measures to control the pricing of their product. Ever wonder why Bose is always excluded from those store-wide 10% off sales at Sears? Because Bose will revoke your dealership if they catch you discounting their product. They're a bunch of retail nazis.

Bose is not a good product. Their stuff won't sound bad to the untrained ear but that is a far cry from saying that it sounds good. They use third rate materials, second rate technology and refuse to comply with the same standards as everyone else (they use RF remote controls and refuse to use Dolby Digital or DTS processing) making their product almost impossible to integrate with anything else. Their speakers are poorly conceived and just as poorly engineered. As is most of the rest of what they sell.

And for all of that... they still manage to command a premium price. Unbelievable.

 
Nov 10, 2005
67
0
0

Why is it that we need a new "bose blows" topic every single week? I know that I am going to be pummeled with 31337 @udi0phi13 psychobabble for this but: For the most part, isn't "sound" be completely subjective? I own a pair of Bose triport headphones and love them. They are much more comfortable than any other pair of headphone's I have tried, and they passively reduce outside noise better as well. I have compared them to many other headphones(Grado S60's, Sony V6's, Various Sennies) and have never said to myself "Wow, the sound quality is so much better on pair X." However I have noticed a HUGE difference in the amount of outside noise I hear, as well as comfort.

*Flame Shield Up*
 

imported_bum

Golden Member
Jan 15, 2005
1,402
1
0
I would have flamed you, but the shield is blocking me :(.

In all honestly, though, if you have tried other headphones and still like those, what's the big deal? You may not be getting the "best" or most accurate sound but it your money and your ears. At least you aren't being a zombie for Bose marketing and refusing to even try out other products.
 

James3shin

Diamond Member
Apr 5, 2004
4,426
0
76
b/c they listen to it and think it is good, the problem is they are comparing bose to stock. Put them up against some Martin Logan, or M&K and then they will be shocked. The general consumer has no idea what's out there.
 

NanoStuff

Banned
Mar 23, 2006
2,981
1
0
Originally posted by: PoisonCandyGram
For the most part, isn't "sound" be completely subjective?
Nope, not when it comes to reproduction. There is the good kind (output close in fidelity to input), and the bad kind (output poorly representing input).

That doesn't necessarily imply one cannot like 'bad' sound. Some people just have a very poor sense for quality and revert to immediate excitational perceptions to judge their liking towards a certain product; particularly bass reproduction; as in more bass is better.
 

jonessoda

Golden Member
Aug 3, 2005
1,407
1
0
It's too bad somebody already said the "no highs? No lows?..." joke, so now I have to come up with an original comment.

Hey, what do you buy if you want a low-range mid-pass filter built into your speakers? Bose.
 

imported_goku

Diamond Member
Mar 28, 2004
7,613
3
0
Originally posted by: PoisonCandyGram

Why is it that we need a new "bose blows" topic every single week? I know that I am going to be pummeled with 31337 @udi0phi13 psychobabble for this but: For the most part, isn't "sound" be completely subjective? I own a pair of Bose triport headphones and love them. They are much more comfortable than any other pair of headphone's I have tried, and they passively reduce outside noise better as well. I have compared them to many other headphones(Grado S60's, Sony V6's, Various Sennies) and have never said to myself "Wow, the sound quality is so much better on pair X." However I have noticed a HUGE difference in the amount of outside noise I hear, as well as comfort.

*Flame Shield Up*

I bet you own an ipod :laugh:
 

James3shin

Diamond Member
Apr 5, 2004
4,426
0
76
yeah, the ipod headphone jack is some SH!T...line out FTW with some nice IC's to a moy amp to my E4C's would be nice.
 

Pacfanweb

Lifer
Jan 2, 2000
13,158
59
91
Originally posted by: PoisonCandyGram

Why is it that we need a new "bose blows" topic every single week?
For the same reason that Bose needs to keep advertising how good they are. To keep convincing people.

 

Turkish

Lifer
May 26, 2003
15,547
1
81
Originally posted by: NanoStuff
Originally posted by: Turkish
Originally posted by: EatSpam
Originally posted by: swaq
Bose is good. Bose is also very expensive. However, you can get better quality stuff for less. For car audio, I'd say Bose would be pretty high end for a factory system, but not that astounding for aftermarket.

In terms of sound and build quality, Bose seems to be right on the level of Koss, Craig, or any other Wal-mart level brand made in the dingiest sweatshop in China.

Yeah, right :roll:
I think we are in the presence of a naive Bose customer fellas.

Nope. Never owned one, can't afford one. But I've heard them, and to call them the equivalnt of Koss, Craig or any other Wal-mart level brand is naive ATOT bandwagonism. So think of it yourself.
 

imported_goku

Diamond Member
Mar 28, 2004
7,613
3
0
Originally posted by: Turkish
Originally posted by: NanoStuff
Originally posted by: Turkish
Originally posted by: EatSpam
Originally posted by: swaq
Bose is good. Bose is also very expensive. However, you can get better quality stuff for less. For car audio, I'd say Bose would be pretty high end for a factory system, but not that astounding for aftermarket.

In terms of sound and build quality, Bose seems to be right on the level of Koss, Craig, or any other Wal-mart level brand made in the dingiest sweatshop in China.

Yeah, right :roll:
I think we are in the presence of a naive Bose customer fellas.

Nope. Never owned one, can't afford one. But I've heard them, and to call them the equivalnt of Koss, Craig or any other Wal-mart level brand is naive ATOT bandwagonism. So think of it yourself.

So if I wasn't part of anandtech and came to that conclusion on my own, what would that make you? A tool? I'd say yes..
 

remagavon

Platinum Member
Jun 16, 2003
2,516
0
0
Originally posted by: goku
Originally posted by: Turkish
Originally posted by: NanoStuff
Originally posted by: Turkish
Originally posted by: EatSpam
Originally posted by: swaq
Bose is good. Bose is also very expensive. However, you can get better quality stuff for less. For car audio, I'd say Bose would be pretty high end for a factory system, but not that astounding for aftermarket.

In terms of sound and build quality, Bose seems to be right on the level of Koss, Craig, or any other Wal-mart level brand made in the dingiest sweatshop in China.

Yeah, right :roll:
I think we are in the presence of a naive Bose customer fellas.

Nope. Never owned one, can't afford one. But I've heard them, and to call them the equivalnt of Koss, Craig or any other Wal-mart level brand is naive ATOT bandwagonism. So think of it yourself.

So if I wasn't part of anandtech and came to that conclusion on my own, what would that make you? A tool? I'd say yes..

The only bose product that is comparable to a koss product is the entry level wave radio, which is utter garbage. Complete garbage. It should be taken off the market for being so horribly bad.

That aside, I actually don't mind bose. The large wave radio is really nice for a dining room, it looks great and sounds really good, especially for an all in one unit. I don't believe that I've actually heard an all-in-one tabletop radio that sounds as good as it, at any price.

The subwoofers on thier home theatres are pathetic, and their satellites aren't great for music (but are quite good for multimedia), but they're by no means terrible.

Obviously a $1200 home theatre in a box that has a lot of it's budget set aside for asthetics isn't going to sound as great as a pair of $5,000 B&W speakers running through a McIntosh amp, but it's really not that bad, especially for the general consumer which is their target audience.

Fanboys suck, and so do people who get bothered by what other people purchase. Re-evaulate your priorities in life people!
 

Fritzo

Lifer
Jan 3, 2001
41,920
2,161
126
Well, Bose products aren't garbage by any means. But on the other hand, other manufactuers make similar or better products for lower prices. Bose is like the Apple of the speaker industry.
 

Pacfanweb

Lifer
Jan 2, 2000
13,158
59
91
Originally posted by: Turkish
Originally posted by: NanoStuff
Originally posted by: Turkish
Originally posted by: EatSpam
Originally posted by: swaq
Bose is good. Bose is also very expensive. However, you can get better quality stuff for less. For car audio, I'd say Bose would be pretty high end for a factory system, but not that astounding for aftermarket.

In terms of sound and build quality, Bose seems to be right on the level of Koss, Craig, or any other Wal-mart level brand made in the dingiest sweatshop in China.

Yeah, right :roll:
I think we are in the presence of a naive Bose customer fellas.

Nope. Never owned one, can't afford one. But I've heard them, and to call them the equivalnt of Koss, Craig or any other Wal-mart level brand is naive ATOT bandwagonism. So think of it yourself.

Actually, Koss, Craig, and some Wal Mart stuff is about EXACTLY what Bose should be compared with, sound-wise.
That isn't Bose-hating, it's the truth.
Nearly anything sold at BB or CC that is home stereo is at least as good as Bose...just because Koss or KLH prices their stuff at what it's really worth rather than trying to fool people into thinking it's worth 5 times too much doesn't mean they aren't just as good.