Can I have Samantha without her crazy family baggage? She was pretty well adjusted by witch standards, it was her relatives that caused all the problems. Good looking, powerful and pretty dang nice too, she's #1
Ellie May was hot and rich, she'd be my #2
Jeannie was hot, but she never truly grasped the master/servant relationship. Not a good thing for someone with that kind of power. She's #3
Marilyn was very under-rated and it would be cool to have a pet dragon. But ultimately she's got the same trouble as Samantha, a bat-shit crazy family without the witch powers to make up for it. So she's dropped down to #4
Grandpa Munster only as a friend.
Mostly because she had the largest part of any of the four in their respective shows. The others were one-trick ponies. You could probably type all of their combined dialog from every episode they appeared in on a single sheet of paper.Samantha is the most adorable and intelligent of the bunch. She also has the most interesting personality. Marilyn I'm not familiar with but Jeanie and Ellie May are more typical 60's tv characters. Maybe not one dimensional but not as much depth. Not that Bewitched was deep by measure, but Samatha had a much broader range I think.