Who thinks crouching tiger,hidden dragon is crap?

Page 2 - Seeking answers? Join the AnandTech community: where nearly half-a-million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.

Presence

Golden Member
May 8, 2001
1,121
0
0
CTHD was one of the best movies Ive seen period. Had everything from comedy, action and most of all a very tragic love story.

Chow Yun-Fat has a way a seeming very intimadating but at the same time have a peaceful serene aura about him
 

Bluga

Banned
Nov 28, 2000
4,315
0
0

For those who think this movie is crap, i feel sorry for you.

This movie has an incredible depth to it. If you watch it and thinks that the there's nothing special, than you are only skin deep. Perhaps you have been spoon feed by Hollywood crap too much.

Again, i feel sorry for you guys.
 

StormRider

Diamond Member
Mar 12, 2000
8,324
2
0
One of the reasons why I loved CTHD was because I thought it successfully blended Western production elements and acting styles with HK martial arts movies to create something truly beautiful and unique.

I loved the story -- it had a grandness of scale that I liked. It was different from the typical, "My kung fu style is better than your kung fu style" or "You killed my master! Now I'll kill you!" storyline that you see at those grade B kung fu flicks on Saturday afternoon TV.

As an older asian male, the love story between Chow Yun Fat and Michelle Yeoh's characters was something I could totally relate to. And I liked the pureness of that love as opposed to the "sex/lust" that passes off for love that I see in a lot of American movies.

Although it was criticized by a lot of people, I loved the fighting sequences in CTHD. I loved the beauty and speed of those sequences. I've always loved seeing women who can kick ass in movies! :)

I was especially pleased by how America seems to have embraced it. Because of this, it seems like I'm more accepted by society. It's cool to be asian now! ;)

In the past, I remember how I was always embarrassed whenever I saw an asian on the screen. I don't know why. Maybe because they were always portrayed as nerdy geeks with bowl haircuts and thick accents. Maybe I saw some of myself in them. Who knows? But I do remember watching Star Trek: The Motion Picture and the people in the audience snickered when they show Sulu gazing in wonder at V'ger. They did not snicker or giggle at the other actors gazing in wonder at V'ger -- only at Sulu. And I always felt like people were making fun of me whenever things like that happened.

Now, it's completely different! Tons of people go to see Jackie Chan movies now! And they're not laughing at him -- they're laughing with him! And it's really cool seeing non-asians admire Jackie when he does something cool on the screen. Chow Yun Fat is seen as a romantic figure by a lot of women. No longer are asians the object of ridicule on the movie screen. :)

Finally, CTHD was also refreshing because it showed asian women having romantic relationships with asian men. In the past, it seems whenever a movie has an asian theme, they always have to stick a non-asian (typically white) guy in it so that the movie will appeal to non-asians. And if there is a romantic subplot, it is with an asian woman and the non-asian guy.

As a result, I've grown up bombarded with images of asian guys being invisible or never being involved in a romantic relationship. No wonder a lot of asian guys my age seem to have no confidence when it comes to women! ;)

 

vec

Golden Member
Oct 12, 1999
1,213
0
71


<< One of the reasons why I loved CTHD was because I thought it successfully blended Western production elements and acting styles with HK martial arts movies to create something truly beautiful and unique.

I loved the story -- it had a grandness of scale that I liked. It was different from the typical, &quot;My kung fu style is better than your kung fu style&quot; or &quot;You killed my master! Now I'll kill you!&quot; storyline that you see at those grade B kung fu flicks on Saturday afternoon TV.

As an older asian male, the love story between Chow Yun Fat and Michelle Yeoh's characters was something I could totally relate to. And I liked the pureness of that love as opposed to the &quot;sex/lust&quot; that passes off for love that I see in a lot of American movies.

Although it was criticized by a lot of people, I loved the fighting sequences in CTHD. I loved the beauty and speed of those sequences. I've always loved seeing women who can kick ass in movies!
>>



I agree with StormRider on this part but w/o the endearing euphemisms. Character development in a Chinese martial arts flick? That alone should be worth the price of admission.
 

Jarwa

Golden Member
Jan 7, 2001
1,160
0
0
Just watched the dubbed version last night. Very good dubbing, by the way.

I enjoyed it, and I thought it was entertaining. Nothing more, nothing less. Worth watching.
 

mrCide

Diamond Member
Nov 27, 1999
6,187
0
76
I thought it was boring. Fight scenes were okay but, WTH? Even the so called award winning drama was boring as hell, and I didn't see anything special about it at all.

Directing was good though.
 

StageLeft

No Lifer
Sep 29, 2000
70,150
5
0
Well, DefRef, I was going to go by your opinion and go rent it until you called Matrix overrated. ouch! I'll still get this movie though.

I really really really loath &quot;kung fu&quot; jackie-chan style fighting and God help me if this is like that. By that I mean combat that nobody in real life would do because its totally impractical: whether its moves that are impossible to pull off or stupid crap like jumping in the air and kicking 3 times before hitting the ground. I hate that horses*it! Matrix was allowed to do it because they were not confined to real-world physics so I could enjoy it.I guess this movie (CTHD) has &quot;magic&quot; stuff so maybe it will be ok.
 

cdan

Senior member
Dec 30, 2000
530
0
0
What makes this movie different from others is that it has an actual plot and would appeal to non-action movie fans. And the fight sequences are more realistic unlike movies now where computers are used to make Jet Li jump 30 feet in the air and switch to some stupid x-ray shot.
 

StormRider

Diamond Member
Mar 12, 2000
8,324
2
0
I really really really loath &quot;kung fu&quot; jackie-chan style fighting and God help me if this is like that. By that I mean combat that nobody in real life would do because its totally impractical: whether its moves that are impossible to pull off or stupid crap like jumping in the air and kicking 3 times before hitting the ground. I hate that horses*it! Matrix was allowed to do it because they were not confined to real-world physics so I could enjoy it.I guess this movie (CTHD) has &quot;magic&quot; stuff so maybe it will be ok.

To me the world of CTHD is like the Chinese version of comic books where characters can fly etc. The sword fight between Michelle Yeoh's character and the young girl seemed very realistic to me (and very fast!). It's a great movie full of beautiful images.

Most Jackie Chan movies that I've seen actually does not use much wire work. Some of the Jet Li movies that I've seen seem to use a lot of wire work.
 

StormRider

Diamond Member
Mar 12, 2000
8,324
2
0
there was an actual story to boot

This is what my mom said. It has a story unlike a lot of Jackie Chan movies where the &quot;plot&quot; only serves to string along a bunch of action sequences.
 

kassy

Guest
Sep 13, 2000
1,603
1
0


<< To me the world of CTHD is like the Chinese version of comic books where characters can fly etc. The sword fight between Michelle Yeoh's character and the young girl seemed very realistic to me (and very fast!). It's a great movie full of beautiful images. >>


Very true, which is why I enjoyed CTHD.


<< you just described Pearl Harbor >>


Pearl Harbor should have been called *Harlequin Romance at Pearl Harbor*.
 

KameLeon

Golden Member
Dec 5, 2000
1,788
1
0
I thought it sucked, except for some of the fighting scenes. But hey! That's just my opinion! (I couldn't be wrong ;)).
 

Khameleon

Senior member
Apr 12, 2001
337
0
0
I loved it. I have always enjoyed fantasy Kung-Fu flicks. I saw one in Korea where the villain and hero took turns flying through the air and hurling huge boulders and trees, etc, at each other. It was fun, and completely unbelievable, but that was the point. CTHD had those same fantasy elements, coupled with good storytelling and characters that you actually cared about. I wouldn't say it was the best movie ever, or even the best martial arts movie ever, but it was fun and kept me interested all the way through. To me, that is what makes a great movie.
 

aniki

Senior member
Sep 4, 2000
538
0
0
I thought it was overrated but then again most movies are. I can appreciate its uniqueness. For the most part it wasn't interesting
 

bret

Platinum Member
Mar 14, 2001
2,099
0
76
<It's ballet dancing, for chrisakes>

whats wong with that? i happen to like ballet

lol