Which to Buy? >Gainward FX5600 Ultra 256MB or FX5600 Ultra 128MB?

[Hyperlite26]

Hey all. Im trying to determine which card to go with. Logic seems to point to the 256MB Ultra but I know that isnt always the case where the more MB's the better the performance. Which one is going to give the best fill rate, fps, performance? Price is not an issue as its just $16 difference. Thanks for the help!

 

[NYHoustonman]

I would say the 128, there's not much benefit to the 256...And, I know I may be bashed for it, but I must recommend that you look at ATI's solutions (9600pro, 9700) as well.

 

[modedepe]

128mb. The extra doesn't memory doesn't help.

 

[nRollo]

Neither. This card is a bad deal for the money.

 

[Hyperlite26]

Quick reply NY..lol Thx. Yea I compared 2 different brands of the 256 vs 128 Ultra's specs (FX) and the 128 had better performance specs it seemed. Gainward's sight doesnt give great feedback and specs on both cards so I cant compare side by side.

As far as the ATI card... I know they are very popular now. I have looked at them but I have to tell you.... EVERY ATI card I have ever dealt with has been nothing but a pain in the *#@ on getting the drivers loaded for it. I have never had a problem with Nvidia stuff. You may as well format your computer if you want to put in a ATI card after Nvidia stuff. Whereas w\ Nvidia, it's always worked flawlessly. Remove the ATI thru control panel, put the Nvid in, point it to the driver and a reboot and she's rolling. They may be good cards now and have that problem fixed but Im gun shy. And the last 1 I bought I swore i'd never buy another.lol If I did and it gave the same problems like the others..... I'd spontaneously combust this time I think.lofl

Appreciate the advice. It's always welcomed.

 

[Tab]

Originally posted by: Rollo
Neither. This card is a bad deal for the money.

Agreed go with A R9600Pro

 

[Hyperlite26]

Hmm, well it seems as I was answering more beat me to the draw.lol Maybe drop down to a 5200 Ultra in another brand? Is it the manufacturer of the card that makes it a bad deal Rollo or the FX5600 itself? What do you suggest? A Ti Series? I really dont want to go ATI. All recommendations are welcome.

 

[Corporate Thug]

Originally posted by: Rollo
Neither. This card is a bad deal for the money.

 

[NYHoustonman]

The FX5600 Ultra just generally isn't as fast as other cards in the same price range (9600 Pro). If you are into gaming, stay away from the 5200/Ultra, I guess a Ti would be OK, but really ATI is ahead in this class.

Best value for Nvidia

 

[nRollo]

If it's GOT to be nVidia (and after 3 of their evil "PR" people wouldn't even return an email about my nV30, I'm not exactly pointing wood in the direction of Santa Clara , CA) the ONLY part that makes any sense at all right now is this one:
DX9 or not, $237 shipped for a 5900 from a good vendor is a lot of performance for a little money

Only other thing I'd consider is a blowout price on a used 5800 like $150.

Hmm, looks like MYHoustonman beat me to it. Kudos.

 

[INemtsev]

Maybe u should get non pro FX5600 by Leadtek...I have one and it overclocks like a crazy mot&#%ucker....I overclocked it like 24% from original and performance is better than the Pro edition.....

 

[Mloot]

Hyperlite26, I know someone who is selling their Gainward 5600 Ultra 128mb card (flip chip design) for $160/shipped. If you're interested, PM me and I'll get you his contact info.