Which song do you think is better.

[MrYAK]

For most of you, this is a no brainer.
Bob Seger, i think Metallica Fvcked it up.

The radio sparked me to make this thread.

On a related subject, is it just me or is classic rock way better than the "rock" of now?

Discuss

 

[coolred]

I actually prefered the metallica version. I am not a big metallica fan, and I do like classic rock. But for me the metallica version was better

 

[imported_Lucifer]

Bob Seger's is a lot better than Metallica's.

 

[eplebnista]

Bob Seger, cant beat an original :thumbsup:

 

[SWScorch]

That's a tough one. I really really like Metallica's version, and it was the first version I heard, but Bob Seger's is really good too, and it has a sax, which gives it points. I'd give them a tie. Bob Seger's version, being the first, of course is really good, but Metallica took it and gave it a whole new sound, that, while completely opposite of what Bob Seger had in mind, sounds cool.

 

[EyeMWing]

Tough one. Let me listen.

<Winamp>

:music:On the long lonesome highway, east of omaha:music:
.....
:music:Here I ammm on the road againnnnn:music:
etc.
:music:So you walk into this restaurant, all strung out from the road and you feel these eyes upon you shakin off the cold. you pretend it doesn't bother you, but you just want to explodeee:music:
d0d0d0d0d0dd0d0d0
</hetfield>
Metallica wins. Barely. I've always been partial to their covers over their original stuff, and their covers over the original songs. This one definitely isn't the landslide victory of Astronomy or any of the Mercyful Fate or Misfits stuff, but it's a bit better.

 

[Caesar]

Originally posted by: eplebnista
Bob Seger, cant beat an original :thumbsup:

But I like Metallica's version too. Its on virtually every disc in my car

 

[mpitts]

I hate Bob Seger.

 

[EyeMWing]

Originally posted by: CaesaR

Originally posted by: eplebnista
Bob Seger, cant beat an original :thumbsup:

But I like Metallica's version too. Its on virtually every disc in my car

Metallica turned it into a real driving song. Bob's version just seems more... Stationary.

 

[Zenmervolt]

It doesn't get any better than Seger.

ZV

 

[SWScorch]

Bob Seger's version is a "chillin" song. Metallica's is a driving song.

 

[1Master]

Originally posted by: MrYAK
For most of you, this is a no brainer.
Bob Seger, i think Metallica Fvcked it up.

The radio sparked me to make this thread.

On a related subject, is it just me or is classic rock way better than the "rock" of now?

Discuss

It's just you!!!! Both of them Suck!!!!!!!

 

[Iron Woode]

I hate to say this, but, Turn the Page sucks.

I can't stand that song.

Rambling Gambling Man? Now you're talking.

 

[MrLuckyPants]

Seger. You get more of the feel of the bleak monotony and boredom of life on the road with his version.

Rambling Gambling Man? Now you're talking.

For some reason, "Get Out Of Denver" has always been my favorite.

 

[CHfan4ever]

I have nothing wrong to say againt the original created by Bob, but you know what....METALLICA FVCKIN RULEZ!!!

 

[MrYAK]

Originally posted by: Iron Woode
I hate to say this, but, Turn the Page sucks.

I can't stand that song.

Rambling Gambling Man? Now you're talking.

ohhhh, those fight'n words where i'm from

 

[Iron Woode]

Originally posted by: MrLuckyPants
Seger. You get more of the feel of the bleak monotony and boredom of life on the road with his version.

Rambling Gambling Man? Now you're talking.

For some reason, "Get Out Of Denver" has always been my favorite.

My favourite is SunSpot Baby.

 

[LtPage1]

ive never heard either, but lars ulrich is flat out evil. so i voted for bob.

 

[MrYAK]

Originally posted by: LtPage1
ive never heard either, but lars ulrich is flat out evil. so i voted for bob.

very evil. OMG!! They killed Napster!! You bastards!!