Which reciever do you think will have a better year?

[MrDingleDangle]

I have a trade possibility

he offered, Rudi Johnson and Andre Davis for Roy Williams and Bennett

right now Roy is my 3rd WR after stallworth and c. johnson

but I have chambers on the bench

i offered him the same trade but chambers instead of williams, he is thinking about it, but made it clear he is looking at other teams offers too

my RB's right now are Holmes and Foster


I am thinking of accepting his trade, roy williams had a great game sunday and a decent game 1, but they were against the Bears and the Texans


alright he countered my Chambers offer with a Stallworth/bennett combo

so My team would be C.Johnson, Chambers, Williams, Holmes, Rudi/Foster

 

[pyonir]

IMO Andre Davis is worthless. I would like to have Rudi Johnson...but you'd probably have to start Chambers rather than Davis...and Miami sucks this year...so Chambers might not have a good year. If he takes Chambers and Bennett you are set.

 

[MrDingleDangle]

Originally posted by: pyonir
IMO Andre Davis is worthless. I would like to have Rudi Johnson...but you'd probably have to start Chambers rather than Davis...and Miami sucks this year...so Chambers might not have a good year. If he takes Chambers and Bennett you are set.

yeah thats def. what i want, but he made a post asking for more trade offers so i am thinking he would only take that if he doesnt get anything better

if i give him roy williams i can def. get him, I just dont know what to think about how williams will play the rest of the year

 

[pyonir]

You really can't put too much weight into what anyone will do this year. Donovan McNabb could not throw another touchdown pass this year...it's unlikely, but it could happen. Ya know? I say Williams is performing better than Chambers or Andre Davis...and you have two good RBs already...even when S. Davis comes back Foster will still get carries. So...

 

[MrDingleDangle]

updated

 

[imported_Strang]

Originally posted by: pyonir
You really can't put too much weight into what anyone will do this year. Donovan McNabb could not throw another touchdown pass this year...it's unlikely, but it could happen. Ya know? I say Williams is performing better than Chambers or Andre Davis...and you have two good RBs already...even when S. Davis comes back Foster will still get carries. So...

I agree. Williams > Chambers > Andre Davis.

Williams might not be consistant, but since Charles Rogers went down, he'll be the main target in Detroit (and has already proven that he's a playmaker).

I'm not sure that I would be all that confident in Foster, though. He'll get carries, but I think Stephen Davis will get more TDs by virtue of more goal line chances.

Given that you have two good receivers already, Williams might be expendable (also depending on how the bye weeks shape up). Of course, if you trade him, Chad Johnson or Stallworth will get injured. 😉

 

[MrDingleDangle]

Originally posted by: Strang

Originally posted by: pyonir
You really can't put too much weight into what anyone will do this year. Donovan McNabb could not throw another touchdown pass this year...it's unlikely, but it could happen. Ya know? I say Williams is performing better than Chambers or Andre Davis...and you have two good RBs already...even when S. Davis comes back Foster will still get carries. So...

I agree. Williams > Chambers > Andre Davis.

Williams might not be consistant, but since Charles Rogers went down, he'll be the main target in Detroit (and has already proven that he's a playmaker).

I'm not sure that I would be all that confident in Foster, though. He'll get carries, but I think Stephen Davis will get more TDs by virtue of more goal line chances.

Given that you have two good receivers already, Williams might be expendable (also depending on how the bye weeks shape up). Of course, if you trade him, Chad Johnson or Stallworth will get injured. 😉

who would u think would be a better trade, stallworth or williams...he would accept either one

stallworth is #2 reciever, but withouth mcallister they will be throwing a lot more

 

[CTrain]

If I was to make a trade it would be Bennettt and Chambers for Rudi and Crap Davis.
If he doesn't want that, then don't make the trade.

S Davis is out for around 4-6 weeks. So you got 2 solid starters until Davis come back.
By that time, Bennett will also be back.
NOTE: Carolina is high on Foster so no guaranty that Davis will get his starting job back anyway.

You have 4 quality receivers(no superstar) so you can play matchup every week.
I wouldn't give away Williams, Stallworth or Johnson.

I'm a Dolphins fan and let me tell you that they have the worst offense in the league.
They're offensive line is attrocious so the QB will not have time to throw.