Which one is the best?

[Zysoclaplem]

Attempting to do a logo for Quality Month here at work, get a small prize, but I am not very interested in winning a prize, I just want to see my logo/slogan used.

Oh criteria is we have to include "quality month" or "Passion for Quality" in the logo.
And the slogan must have something to do with customer important.
It will go at the top of letter heads and in-plant newspapers and might be used for other things.
Sometimes simpler is better, but unfortunately it must relay a certain amount of info.

What does everyone think? Which one looks the best. Or do they all suck?

Logo 1
Logo 2
Logo 3
Logo 4

 

[dug777]

i like the shiny tyre ones...

 

[Zysoclaplem]

Originally posted by: dug777
i like the shiny tyre ones...

Our plant manager liked that one too.

 

[Ika]

they all suck, but #3 sucks the least.

 

[Zysoclaplem]

Originally posted by: Aflac
they all suck, but #3 sucks the least.

You should see the others that were made from other plants, and were accepted..lol.

 

[GDaddy]

3 is not bad, its clean and simple, you dont want a logo to be too busy.

 

[Zysoclaplem]

Originally posted by: GDaddy
3 is not bad, its clean and simple, you dont want a logo to be too busy.

I know, but they want to relay a certain image and a certain amount of info.
It's much harder to do than it seems.
I am turning in all four, they get to choose. I was just wondering what everyone thought.

 

[j00fek]

#4 FTW

 

[altonb1]

Originally posted by: j00fek
#4 FTW

I like #2 and #4, but with changes. I have a suggestion for you, and regardless of which you edit, it will result in the same thing.

I like logo 2, but I think the placement of the Goodyear winged foot should be in the same location as #4. I position is good in #4, but I think the blimp makes it too busy. So...you either move the winged foot down in #2 or you remove the blimp from #4, or just redo it from scratch with my suggestion.

If I have to choose one of them, though, I guess I'd agree and go with #4. I just think the blimp is TOO much.