Which of these two LCDs is better?

[aka1nas]

Hi all,
the wife is letting me get a flatpanel upgrade for my birthday. I am on a tight budget, so I am looking at a 19inch w/ DVI in the sub $250 range. I will be gaming on this monitor, so response times are a factor. Both of these monitors seem to have decent specs, and I really can't tell if one is better than the other. I'd really appreciate it if you guys could weigh in and give me an idea which I should get or another in this price range.

Acer AL1917ABMD

BenQ FP91V

Edit: Forgot to add links

 

[VanTheMan]

See if this deal is still going on at PC Connection. I got that 19" LCD and I'm really happy with it. FarCry looks wonderful on it with settings maxed out at 12x10 resolution.

 

[cdjr]

No experience with either, but here are a couple of reviews for the BenQ:

Review
Review

 

[xtknight]

I'd choose BenQ over Acer. I've heard reasonably good things about the FP91V so I'd go with that if nothing else. But what about the FP91G+? That's a good display for under $250/DVI. http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.asp?Item=N82E16824014090
I know of at least three people on the forums that love their FP91G+.

 

[aka1nas]

Hehe, ok, I ended up going up a model and ordered the BenQ FP93GX, which is a presumably newer 2ms panel for about $30 more. Thanks for all the feedback though, as it got me to lean towards BenQ over Acer. I will post a review once the panel gets here if anyone is interested.