Which Memory is better?

[deadken]

Hi, I am considering a Memory upgrade (quite possibly the last upgrade for this rig, then it's off to an A64). I typically use Corsair memory, but have been tempted to try some more Patriot.

I already have a 512MB stick of Corsair 2,2,2,5 and am most likely going to buy a matched set to bring me up to 1.5GB. THIS is the matched set for about $185 shipped.

THIS is the Patriot memory with the same specs I had also been considering. It is only about $15 cheaper, so price isn't a real issue here.

Which do you guys think is the better set of memory, and why?


-Thanks, Ken

 

[NokiaDude]

I always try to get the same RAM as possible. I have the Corsair XMS-XL 2-2-2-5 RAM too and it's the best DDR400 RAM out there.

 

[deadken]

Yeah, I am pretty sold on getting the Corsair, but I haven't followed memory in a while and wasn't sure if the Patriots were 'TCCD' or whatever is the hottest memory right now.

I also am not sure if this memory will be used in my next rig (A64 probably in 6 months). I am not trying to be 'future-proof', but still want to be open to the possibility. I have a lot of research to do before setting up my next rig and if it wasn't for me enjoying BF2 so much, I probably wouldn't even be upgrading my memory (although, I kinda do have $200 burning a hole in my pocket).

If anyone wants to comment about using PC3200 in a A64, please feel free to. From what I can see if I stick with my AGP 6800GT, I will most likely re-use my PC3200. If I go to PCI-E, I will probably get DDR2. That's just a guess, but I am betting that it will either be a brand new rig, or I will use some parts from my current rig.

 

[RussianSensation]

Both seem to be pretty Good

Patriot is pretty good and Here

Since they are both using TCCD chips, I'd go with the cheaper one.

In terms of overall effect on memory for A64, please see this:

Not that Important

 

[NokiaDude]

DDR400 runs great with an A64. I have 1GB of Corsair XL RAM and it's a sweet combo with my SKT939 3200+. Latency doesn't matter that much with the A64 though. But the low latency allows for a great deal of OC'ing.

 

[deadken]

Thanks, I appreciate the info.

I do dis-agree with the statement "Since they are both using TCCD chips, I'd go with the cheaper one". Since the price difference is so modest, I will go with the Corsair. I just prefer knowing that more then likely, I will be able to take them up on their lifetime warranty. I do like the Patriot products, but who knows how many years they will be around?

Thanks for the links, there is a lot of info that I need to read up on in them. I was surprised to read of some of the stats. they show (I just looked them over quickly).

Thanks for the suggestions.

 

[deadken]

OK, I just ordered the Corsair from Newegg for $186 shipped. I'll probably post when I get it and run it (let's see what it'll do!).