• We’re currently investigating an issue related to the forum theme and styling that is impacting page layout and visual formatting. The problem has been identified, and we are actively working on a resolution. There is no impact to user data or functionality, this is strictly a front-end display issue. We’ll post an update once the fix has been deployed. Thanks for your patience while we get this sorted.

which is better for a laptop?

I've never had any issues with PCMCIA or USB - not noticed any advantages of either. I find PCMCIA more convenient though
 
I'd say for a mobile unit, a laptop that gets moved around alot, the convenience of a slotted pc card or mini pci card vs a usb adapter you have to lug around is a big advantage. As far as performance no. As long as the device is USB 2.0 compatible there should be no discernable speed difference in duplicate radios and chipsets.
 
I'd go with the PC card, because with a USB you have to carry that peice of junk around, VS if you just had a card in it's slot already sitting there.
 
In general you are better of with PCMCIA.

However if you have a particular Distance Reception issue, using a USB Module that can be extended with a USB cable and placed in a Better propagation location, might be advantages.

:sun:
 
thanks, i went ahead with the pcmcia since i'm very close to my router anywhere in the house anyway. i have a d-link dwl-650 v3. now i just have to figure out how to install drivers for it in linux. 😛

/linux noob
 
PCMCIA can be better in that USB drivers of ten get corrupted with spyware/adware infections.

USB allows fora better signal range so nicer if you travel or visit hotspots/Internet cafes often.
 
Originally posted by: bryantp
PCMCIA can be better in that USB drivers of ten get corrupted with spyware/adware infections.

USB allows fora better signal range so nicer if you travel or visit hotspots/Internet cafes often.
Click to expand...



eh....I would disagree with this. I've never seen Spyware/adware corrupt drivers, and USB doesn't allow for greater range across the board.

I would also add that most pcmcia cards stick out far enough that I take them out when packing my laptop up, so you still have that to lug around.
 
Originally posted by: nweaver
Originally posted by: bryantp
PCMCIA can be better in that USB drivers of ten get corrupted with spyware/adware infections.

USB allows fora better signal range so nicer if you travel or visit hotspots/Internet cafes often.
Click to expand...



eh....I would disagree with this. I've never seen Spyware/adware corrupt drivers, and USB doesn't allow for greater range across the board.

I would also add that most pcmcia cards stick out far enough that I take them out when packing my laptop up, so you still have that to lug around.
Click to expand...

Agreed on both points.....
Spyware affect drivers? What did u do to your system.
Leave the PCMCIA in the slot, good way for it to get destroyed....

Some usb devices get better range because they have a larger area and therefore they can build in a larger antenne(sp?)

Before I went minipci I used pcmcia on my old lappy.
 
Originally posted by: NuroMancer
Originally posted by: nweaver
Originally posted by: bryantp
PCMCIA can be better in that USB drivers of ten get corrupted with spyware/adware infections.

USB allows fora better signal range so nicer if you travel or visit hotspots/Internet cafes often.
Click to expand...



eh....I would disagree with this. I've never seen Spyware/adware corrupt drivers, and USB doesn't allow for greater range across the board.

I would also add that most pcmcia cards stick out far enough that I take them out when packing my laptop up, so you still have that to lug around.
Click to expand...

Agreed on both points.....
Spyware affect drivers? What did u do to your system.
Leave the PCMCIA in the slot, good way for it to get destroyed....

Some usb devices get better range because they have a larger area and therefore they can build in a larger antenne(sp?)

Before I went minipci I used pcmcia on my old lappy.
Click to expand...


I work constantly with PC's/Laptop's and Internet connections. I often run into this being the issue. Why couldn't spyware corrupt USB drivers? Are the drivers not DLL files? Are there not registry entries? Not really to go tit for tat but I run into this often and resolve it by cleaning the system then reinstalling the USB drivers that there must be something other than coincidence.

As for the range factor most USB devices come with a bay that you can optionally use as well as plug it directly to your laptop/PC. This bay helps to extend the reach of the USB. Great for Hotels/hotspots/internet cafe's as your piece can be moved around to gather the best signal. Similiar to when you move around to get a better signal on the cell phone.

Nuromancer the range is impacted by the type of card, and actual components, itself not the size.
 
I'd go the USB route simply for the availability of ports; sure, most notebooks have PCMCIA slots, but nearly all notebooks AND PCs have USB slots, so that wireless card can be used in more devices. May not be relevant to your particular situation, but it's what I'd choose were I buying one.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

TRENDING THREADS

Back
Top