I you don't want any extras, then get the Creative Labs, UNLESS you find another brand cheaper.
I am really happy with this card! IT IS SO STABLE. I picked up a Voodoo5 5500 at one time and it gave me so many problems, that I went back to old faithful (TNT2 Ultra). Well, the Herc. Prophet 2 Ultra makes me feel the same way. I just know it will keep performing for me! The construction of the card is top notch!
Pic of Card
The drivers are sweet too. You can tweak the FSAA (which I have been doing tonight) from none to 4X and about 8 different shades between. You can tweek the speed of the memory of ram and processor, too. Of course you can do this with any GeForce 2 Ultra, but I feel like the Herc card it TOP NOTCH!
Let me know what you decide.