JJHendrix wrote:
>>the heat conducting properties of felt were close to nonexistent.
Just don't put the felt in between the CPU slug and heat sink. Mindless suggested that a hole should be cut in the middle, which should allow the CPU to contact the heat sink directly. You can also stack index card paper to the right thickness too. They are non-conducting electrically, thus very safe around the CPU.
If you must use copper shim, you can buy the stock of the right thickness from most hobby shops, where they sell HO train, RC airplane, rocket kit etc. You can cut a U-shape shim with an ordinary scissor. Copper is electrically conductive. Be careful not to short out anything. It actually offers no advantage over felt or paper as shim material.