When super heroes fight, why do they get knocked flying

Page 2 - Seeking answers? Join the AnandTech community: where nearly half-a-million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.

Pacfanweb

Lifer
Jan 2, 2000
13,149
57
91
Originally posted by: chuckywang
Look at it this way.

Zodd weighs as much as a 200lb sack of potatoes. If Superman punches Zodd unaware (like from behind or something) so that Zodd can't react, it'll be as if Superman is punching a 200lb sack of potatoes. If Superman does indeed punch a 200lb sack of potatoes, it'll go flying a long way. So should Zodd.
But you're ignoring my previous example.

Zodd is NOT just a 200lb sack of potatoes, even unaware. Remember, Clark Kent walked out in front of a taxi without paying attention and totalled the car. He didn't even get scuffed, much less moved an inch.

So Superman, or Zodd, just standing on the sidewalk eating an apple is still like hitting the Rock of Gibraltar....he is in now way just a 200lb dead weight that isn't braced for impact.

Now take him and prepare him for a fight....he swings, misses, and then gets tagged.
Should be just like two boxers....head might get snapped around, a little spittle goes flying, maybe it's a really good lick and he gets knocked down or even back a couple of feet.
But he shouldn't go flying to the top of the tallest building. IMO
 

waggy

No Lifer
Dec 14, 2000
68,145
10
81
Originally posted by: Pacfanweb
Originally posted by: chuckywang
Look at it this way.

Zodd weighs as much as a 200lb sack of potatoes. If Superman punches Zodd unaware (like from behind or something) so that Zodd can't react, it'll be as if Superman is punching a 200lb sack of potatoes. If Superman does indeed punch a 200lb sack of potatoes, it'll go flying a long way. So should Zodd.
But you're ignoring my previous example.

Zodd is NOT just a 200lb sack of potatoes, even unaware. Remember, Clark Kent walked out in front of a taxi without paying attention and totalled the car. He didn't even get scuffed, much less moved an inch.

So Superman, or Zodd, just standing on the sidewalk eating an apple is still like hitting the Rock of Gibraltar....he is in now way just a 200lb dead weight that isn't braced for impact.

Now take him and prepare him for a fight....he swings, misses, and then gets tagged.
Should be just like two boxers....head might get snapped around, a little spittle goes flying, maybe it's a really good lick and he gets knocked down or even back a couple of feet.
But he shouldn't go flying to the top of the tallest building. IMO


yes but you are forgetting the strength of superman. he is (arguably) the strongest in the (comic) universe. the punches are so powerful they send him flying from the force of them. But considering how strong and invulnerable superman is while it hurts him it does not kill him.

also it helps to remember it is a comic or movie :D