Originally posted by: Vee
Originally posted by: Amol
...theyre phasing out the 754s...
(This rant is not necessarily directed at the above poster. Just a convenient tag in.)
That would be senseless. As far as I know AMD have never said or hinted that s754 is planned for any phaseout? On the contrary, as far as I know, AMD have always denied that s754 will be replaced by 939?
They have also hinted that s754 will see an upgraded HT link and memory interface. And while they have hinted that s940 may come in question for Opteron dualcore CPUs, they have never suggested s939 will be able to take a dualcore CPU.
Anyone have any links at all to any other contrary type of statements? From AMD?
Now AT OTOH, seem to have some crusade against s754 going, for some reason. Doubtless Anand is well underhand informed, but killing off s754 makes no sense. It performs too well, is too good value, to much volume (PC manufacturers), too great volume potential (64-bit budget and PC manufacturers). The s939 package is simply too expensive to ever be able to compete with 754 in the value segment. Only reason for AMD to "phase out" s754 would be if they intend to get out of the value segment.
Neither the introduction of the Sempron, A64 3300+, nor AMD's recent successes with some manufacturers, (like HP, Fujitsu, Packard) seem to indicate AMD have any plans to get out of the value sector.
Again and again I see the same senseless advice on these forums. "s754 will be phased out, get s939 and 3000+/3200+, because it's more future proof". What is the logic behind that idea?
s754 3400+, NF3-250Gb MB and 1GB PC3200 is about $410. Decent quality.
First s939 to beat its performance is the 3800+. At ~$600, CPU alone. And then by a measly 4.7%.
- And so what IF s754 is phased out?!
So the grand plan is to buy a s939 cpu/mb/ram setup for ~$500, and then in some future drop in a 3800+, 4200+ for another $250-$350? Why not get the 3800+ or FX right now and enjoy the performance from start? Won't be so much more $ in the end.
And what exactly do you save on by this exercice? - You don't have to replace the (obsolete) MB?! A $65-$100 item for those who don't bother with this nonsens, $120-$200 item for the *future proofs*.
Now me, I'm going to get a FUTURE MB, with real mature SATA/RAID support, mature PCIe, possibly DDR2/3, possibly socket 941. ...And I expect to pay about $80 for it.