Whats your opinion on this video?

Page 3 - Seeking answers? Join the AnandTech community: where nearly half-a-million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.

Gurck

Banned
Mar 16, 2004
12,963
1
0
Originally posted by: gigapet
He didnt make a mistake, he got a dangerous driver/CRIMINAL off the road while keeping the other cars on the road free from danger. He should be rewarded and promoted for a perfectly executed maneuver. You on the other hand should be punished and demoted for a perfectly executed idiotic babble.

 

jimmygates

Platinum Member
Sep 4, 2000
2,134
2
81
Originally posted by: virtueixi
I don't think the cops took the passenger into account. For all they know he wanted her to stop the car. This is why I think they should have tried to shoot out the tires or something else.


Sorry, the police cannot "shoot out" tires. All shots fired is considered deadly force and must be justified.



Here in California, the PITT is being reconsidered. For some departments, the PITT manuver is considered deadly force. Others have guidelines where you cannot PITT a vehicle going over 35mph. CHP just recently lost the PITT because the state couldn't repair/replace the car's fast enough.



Spike strips are rarely effective for a couple reasons. Spike strips have to be manually deployed on the street/highway. I don't know about you guys but they don't pay me enough to stand in FRONT of the pursuit vechile to throw a spike strip. Also, you can't really pre-lay spike strips because the suspect would just avoid it. Covering the whole street would spike strips would disable the suspect's vehicle but in the same time disabling police vehicles. City doesn't like to pay for damages they can avoid.


Spike strips at that rate of speed probably would have generated the same outcome. If a SUV can flip with 1 Firestone flat, image 4 :Q



-Jimbo
 

SuperTool

Lifer
Jan 25, 2000
14,000
2
0
Originally posted by: gigapet
Originally posted by: SuperTool
Originally posted by: gigapet
Originally posted by: SuperTool
Originally posted by: gigapet
Originally posted by: SuperTool
Originally posted by: gigapet
Originally posted by: SuperTool
Originally posted by: gigapet
Originally posted by: SuperTool
Originally posted by: Crucial
Originally posted by: IHYLN
Originally posted by: Crucial
I don't think people are trying to justify the actions of the girl. I agree that the pit was not the right thing to do at those speeds. The cop knew exactly what would happen if he used it at that high rate of speed. There were no weapons shown or any other show of agression by the driver other than the high speeds. I hope the parents sue the state for wrongful death. The girl wasn't ramming cops or other cars in her attempts to get away. There are definately other ways to try and stop the vehicle at those speeds that wouldn't result in such a catastrophic crash. Now if she had just killed someone or tried shooting at the cops and was running I could see them using such force but this was not the case.

In any case the girl was stupid but she didn't deserve to die and neither did her passenger. Just take alook at the "What's the fastest mph you went?" thread. Plenty of us have gone faster, should we have been spun out of control at speed by a cop because of it? We were all guilty of the same thing as this girl at that point, driving fast.

I can't speak for the people driving fast in that thread you mentioned but if I cop does find me and want to pull me over I'm not going to continue to endanger lives by not pulling over. Either way thats neither here nor there but the kids got what they deserved :beer:

You have got to be kidding me. They deserved to die because of trying to run from the cops. That is just fvcked up.

I forgot running from police is a capital offense :roll:


if you play with fire sometimes you get burned....

Yes, but this is like a fireman pouring gas on you while you play with fire.
I could see if they were hitting other cars, but they weren't even going that fast.

no no.....they were pouring on the gasoline themselves when they refused to pull over.

Would they be dead if the cop didn't do the pit maneuver? Their top speed was what, 86? People do that on I-5 here all the time.

would they be dead if they pulled to the side of the road like they are required to do by law?

your login name says it all about you.

Well, they didn't know any better, but the cop should have.


they didnt know any better? Stop making excuses for irresponsible retards.

I am not, but they paid for their mistakes, the cop should pay for his.

He didnt make a mistake, he got a dangerous driver/CRIMINAL off the road while keeping the other cars on the road free from danger. He should be rewarded and promoted for a perfectly executed maneuver. You on the other hand should be punished and demoted for a perfectly executed idiotic babble.

WRONG. It was exessive force resulting in unnecessary deaths of two people. He should be reprimanded.
 

Haps

Member
Nov 22, 2001
138
0
0
Whne I first saw it I was surprised that they would pit at that speed. That's insane. I would have tried to box and slow the driver down and then pit.

But then after hearing it was a 70 mile chase. How long do they let it go on? There was a window of opportunity and they took it. Give it a few more seconds and the driver could have been in traffic again endangering other lives.

Seems severe but I think it was justified considering the length of the chase. The cop knew that there was a good chance they would get hurt with a pit at that speed. But he can't necessarily have known they would have died. The car could have easily flipped and rolled down the highway or it could have just spun in circles and come to a stop. There's no telling exactly what is going to happen.
 

DannyLove

Lifer
Oct 17, 2000
12,876
4
76
That is total bullsh|t. Pit move @ High Rate of Speed = BAD MOVE. What did they think was going to happen? Death was probably the only thing that would happen and DID happen. Idiot cops. That never happens here in Los Angeles, and we have a sh|t load of high speed chases. They always wait until they hit the streets where they aren't going as fast to cause more harm than good.

danny~!
 
May 31, 2001
15,326
2
0
Spike strips are typically used on sections of road that have no other traffic on them at the moment, or where cops have closed off access to the road. Attempting to use spike strips on a busy highway would have been insanity.
 

flexy

Diamond Member
Sep 28, 2001
8,464
155
106
WRONG. It was exessive force resulting in unnecessary deaths of two people. He should be reprimanded.


whoever runs from the police in a car is a FOOL. Learn to deal with your own consequences. If you behave like a retard/fool etc...then be prepared regarding the outcome.
 
May 31, 2001
15,326
2
0
Originally posted by: Crucial
I don't think people are trying to justify the actions of the girl. I agree that the pit was not the right thing to do at those speeds. The cop knew exactly what would happen if he used it at that high rate of speed. There were no weapons shown or any other show of agression by the driver other than the high speeds. I hope the parents sue the state for wrongful death. The girl wasn't ramming cops or other cars in her attempts to get away. There are definately other ways to try and stop the vehicle at those speeds that wouldn't result in such a catastrophic crash. Now if she had just killed someone or tried shooting at the cops and was running I could see them using such force but this was not the case.

In any case the girl was stupid but she didn't deserve to die and neither did her passenger. Just take alook at the "What's the fastest mph you went?" thread. Plenty of us have gone faster, should we have been spun out of control at speed by a cop because of it? We were all guilty of the same thing as this girl at that point, driving fast.

No, she was actively fleeing the cops. There is a big difference between that and speeding. :roll:
 

Gurck

Banned
Mar 16, 2004
12,963
1
0
Originally posted by: SuperTool
WRONG. It was exessive force resulting in unnecessary deaths of two people. He should be reprimanded.

She was endangering others' lives. Same situation as a gunman firing into a crowd.
 

lukatmyshu

Senior member
Aug 22, 2001
483
1
0
Correct .. I've been an idiot and driven way too fast in the pass. At the sametime whenever a cop has flashed turned on a siren behind me I got over to the side RIGHT away. I know I can't run from the police. I know that if I start running I might get killed. And I know that if I keep running I might kill someone else. It is too bad that these guys got killed ... but it'd be even worse if they'd killed someone else.

This somewhat reminds me of the talk a few years ago of Police not being allowed to pursue high-speed chasers (because of the potential damage that the guy running would cause while he was fleeing plus the fact that they might kill him while trying to make him stop). At what point do we say that it's okay to let someone go because the only way to stop him/her MIGHT kill her. No ... everybody knows that the cops will always keep after you. It makes no sense to keep running.
 

mugs

Lifer
Apr 29, 2003
48,920
46
91
No one was preventing her from pulling over, it was her own fault.
 

GasX

Lifer
Feb 8, 2001
29,033
6
81
I think anyone nesting 400+ posts should be run off the road by a PITT @ 100mph
 

JeffCos

Golden Member
Mar 10, 2003
1,615
5
81
Originally posted by: Citrix
yes they did the right thing.

i never will understand why people feel the need to start a high speed chase. It looks like after years of watching Cops, Most dangerous police chases... that these morons will know that they will not get away. you cant out run a two way radio, and the cops are not going to just say. "ok, we have chased you too long, we are going to get a donut now".


I've only seen that happen once...Guy was driving an MB and doing 120, the cops could barely keep up and the chase had gone on for so long their radios were getting out of range.
 

SuperTool

Lifer
Jan 25, 2000
14,000
2
0
Originally posted by: Gurck
Originally posted by: SuperTool
WRONG. It was exessive force resulting in unnecessary deaths of two people. He should be reprimanded.

She was endangering others' lives. Same situation as a gunman firing into a crowd.

You endanger everyone's lives when you drive. Let's shoot you.
She was going 86 mph tops. People speed 86mph on highways all the time. I would agree with you if she was going the wrong way on the interstate or ramming cars. But in this case, I think if the cop didn't kill them for kicks, noone would get hurt. Are you saying the cops who chased them before georgia cops took over were irresponsible by not doing a PIT earlier?
 

gigapet

Lifer
Aug 9, 2001
10,005
0
76
Originally posted by: SuperTool
Originally posted by: gigapet
Originally posted by: SuperTool



if you play with fire sometimes you get burned....

Yes, but this is like a fireman pouring gas on you while you play with fire.
I could see if they were hitting other cars, but they weren't even going that fast.

no no.....they were pouring on the gasoline themselves when they refused to pull over.

Would they be dead if the cop didn't do the pit maneuver? Their top speed was what, 86? People do that on I-5 here all the time.[/quote]

would they be dead if they pulled to the side of the road like they are required to do by law?

your login name says it all about you.
[/quote]

Well, they didn't know any better, but the cop should have.[/quote]


they didnt know any better? Stop making excuses for irresponsible retards.
[/quote]

I am not, but they paid for their mistakes, the cop should pay for his.[/quote]

He didnt make a mistake, he got a dangerous driver/CRIMINAL off the road while keeping the other cars on the road free from danger. He should be rewarded and promoted for a perfectly executed maneuver. You on the other hand should be punished and demoted for a perfectly executed idiotic babble.
[/quote]

WRONG. It was exessive force resulting in unnecessary deaths of two people. He should be reprimanded.[/quote]

what part was i wrong about?
1) he got the drivers off the road....he did the video proves it
2) kept civilians out of harms way.....he did the video proves it
3) performed the maneuver perfectly....he did the video proves it
4) you spout idiotic babble....you do, all your posts in this thread prove it
 

MrDudeMan

Lifer
Jan 15, 2001
15,069
94
91
Originally posted by: SuperTool
Originally posted by: Gurck
Originally posted by: SuperTool
WRONG. It was exessive force resulting in unnecessary deaths of two people. He should be reprimanded.

She was endangering others' lives. Same situation as a gunman firing into a crowd.

You endanger everyone's lives when you drive. Let's shoot you.
She was going 86 mph tops. People speed 86mph on highways all the time. I would agree with you if she was going the wrong way on the interstate or ramming cars. But in this case, I think if the cop didn't kill them for kicks, noone would get hurt. Are you saying the cops who chased them before georgia cops took over were irresponsible by not doing a PIT earlier?

doesnt it say in the video she was going over 100?

and cant you two idiots (supertool and gigapet) delete all of the crap quotes and just quote that last one you are replying to? man that is annoying...you would think people with over 7 posts would figure that out.

edit: she was clocked at 86 you tard...it says RIGHT after that she was going over 100
 

gigapet

Lifer
Aug 9, 2001
10,005
0
76
Originally posted by: SuperTool
Originally posted by: Gurck
Originally posted by: SuperTool
WRONG. It was exessive force resulting in unnecessary deaths of two people. He should be reprimanded.

She was endangering others' lives. Same situation as a gunman firing into a crowd.

You endanger everyone's lives when you drive. Let's shoot you.
She was going 86 mph tops. People speed 86mph on highways all the time. I would agree with you if she was going the wrong way on the interstate or ramming cars. But in this case, I think if the cop didn't kill them for kicks, noone would get hurt. Are you saying the cops who chased them before georgia cops took over were irresponsible by not doing a PIT earlier?

No you are forgetting that they REFUSED to pull over....therefore forfeiting there rights to not getting shoved off the roadway....similar to me waving a gun in a crowded movie theater....if the cops come in and tell me to put it down and i dont.....do i have a right to bitch if they shoot me between the eyes? of course not.

look up responsibility in the dictionary..its clear you dont have an understanding of its meaning.

 

MattCo

Platinum Member
Jan 29, 2001
2,198
2
81
Spike strips would have caused the same effect at that speed. Driving straight on for rims is very difficult. Any episode of cops where a driver loses a wheel will demonstrate that. They always end up spinning.

-MC
 

Ime

Diamond Member
May 3, 2001
3,661
0
76
Give the cop a :cookie:.

I've no sympathy for those who run from the law. You run, you pay the price.
 

SSP

Lifer
Oct 11, 1999
17,727
0
0
Originally posted by: SuperTool
Originally posted by: Gurck
Originally posted by: SuperTool
WRONG. It was exessive force resulting in unnecessary deaths of two people. He should be reprimanded.

She was endangering others' lives. Same situation as a gunman firing into a crowd.

You endanger everyone's lives when you drive. Let's shoot you.
She was going 86 mph tops. People speed 86mph on highways all the time. I would agree with you if she was going the wrong way on the interstate or ramming cars. But in this case, I think if the cop didn't kill them for kicks, noone would get hurt. Are you saying the cops who chased them before georgia cops took over were irresponsible by not doing a PIT earlier?

Yah, they killed her for sh!ts and giggles. :roll:
 

Rogue

Banned
Jan 28, 2000
5,774
0
0
They could have just kept following until that gas guzzler ran out of gas. I'm sure that wasn't too far off when the pit was executed (no pun intended).
 

Andrew111

Senior member
Aug 6, 2001
792
0
0
You can you justify the stupidity of the damn driver? She is the one endangering other people's lives...NOT the cops. Are they supposed to do nothing? Others have made very good arguments on why spike strips weren't used....and you don't know what they did before the finale. She had 70 damn miles to stop her freaking car and she didn't.....you don't let idiots like that endanger other peoples lives. You'd all be screaming why nothing was done if she killed other people later on in the chase. The cop did the right thing and the bottom line is.....don't run from the cops. I would buy the cop a beer for cleaning up the gene pool after giving the retard PLENTY of time to give themselves up.
 

Rogue

Banned
Jan 28, 2000
5,774
0
0
Oh yeah? And were they wearing seat belts? Not that it likely would have made a difference, but if they weren't, that's a double fvck them for breaking the law yet again. ;)