What's worse..anorexia or morbid obesity?

Page 2 - Seeking answers? Join the AnandTech community: where nearly half-a-million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.
Jun 27, 2005
19,216
1
61
Does it matter? Both are incredibly self destructive. Either way you leave a really disgusting corpse. One is just easier on the pall bearers.
 

Atlantean

Diamond Member
May 2, 2001
5,296
1
0
Originally posted by: eits
Originally posted by: Atlantean
Morbid obesity/any obesity...

hehe that's why girls become anorexic in the first place... that viewpoint.

Perhaps... but obesity isn't just being a bit overweight... obesity is a bmi of 30-39.9 which is quite a bit overweight. That means around 25-30% body fat, which is a lot. Its not hard to lose weight or cut out a meal a day if you are in that weight range, and is probably something people should do if they are in that range.
 

Conky

Lifer
May 9, 2001
10,709
0
0
Originally posted by: Atlantean
Originally posted by: eits
Originally posted by: Atlantean
Morbid obesity/any obesity...

hehe that's why girls become anorexic in the first place... that viewpoint.

Perhaps... but obesity isn't just being a bit overweight... obesity is a bmi of 30-39.9 which is quite a bit overweight. That means around 25-30% body fat, which is a lot. Its not hard to lose weight or cut out a meal a day if you are in that weight range, and is probably something people should do if they are in that range.
Another stupid post.

Losing serious amounts of weight takes more than offering up the suggestion of skipping a meal once in a while. :roll:

I've battled being overweight and beat it but I will never look down on a person that wants to lose weight. It's harder than most thin people can imagine.

And for anyone who wants to lose weight, the key is a lifestyle change that includes regular exercise and eating in a more "normal way". It's not rocket science but it does take a slight amount of discipline.

 

eits

Lifer
Jun 4, 2005
25,015
3
81
www.integratedssr.com
Originally posted by: Beachboy
Originally posted by: Atlantean
Originally posted by: eits
Originally posted by: Atlantean
Morbid obesity/any obesity...

hehe that's why girls become anorexic in the first place... that viewpoint.

Perhaps... but obesity isn't just being a bit overweight... obesity is a bmi of 30-39.9 which is quite a bit overweight. That means around 25-30% body fat, which is a lot. Its not hard to lose weight or cut out a meal a day if you are in that weight range, and is probably something people should do if they are in that range.
Another stupid post.

Losing serious amounts of weight takes more than offering up the suggestion of skipping a meal once in a while. :roll:

I've battled being overweight and beat it but I will never look down on a person that wants to lose weight. It's harder than most thin people can imagine.

And for anyone who wants to lose weight, the key is a lifestyle change that includes regular exercise and eating in a more "normal way". It's not rocket science but it does take a slight amount of discipline.

yup. agreed (except for calling his post a stupid post... it wasn't stupid). for most obese people, cutting out a meal or two is a healthy lifestyle change.

for some, losing weight is pretty easy. for others, it's hard as hell.
 

smack Down

Diamond Member
Sep 10, 2005
4,507
0
0
Originally posted by: Wreckem
Originally posted by: Aflac
obesity. If you're mortally skinny, it won't really affect you in life much, while if you're mortally fat, you'll have trouble getting around. Plus, you can at least cover up anorexia through baggy clothes and whatnot.

Both have equally fatal outcomes unless treated. Actually you'll die sooner from aneroxia.

Yeah, but while dieing from aneroxia you will look alot better.
 

Alex

Diamond Member
Oct 26, 1999
6,995
0
0
dude... anorexia is fscked up but really you can just check yourself in somewhere get some IV minerals or whatever, learn how to eat and be normal again.... morbid obesity is kinda harder... you can't just loose all that weight like that... plus you become socially reprimanded kinda and have trouble moving around and such... :(
 

SonnyDaze

Diamond Member
Jul 31, 2004
6,867
3
76
Originally posted by: smack Down
Originally posted by: Wreckem
Originally posted by: Aflac
obesity. If you're mortally skinny, it won't really affect you in life much, while if you're mortally fat, you'll have trouble getting around. Plus, you can at least cover up anorexia through baggy clothes and whatnot.

Both have equally fatal outcomes unless treated. Actually you'll die sooner from aneroxia.

Yeah, but while dieing from aneroxia you will look alot better.

And it'll be easier to find a coffin for you. :) This thread reminds me of the Family Guy episode where Lois gains all that weight and Peter is all excited. Lol!!

 

jlbenedict

Banned
Jul 10, 2005
3,724
0
0
Brazil model who battled anorexia dies

A 21-year-old anorexic model who weighed only 88 pounds has died of generalized infection, a hospital said. Ana Carolina Reston, who had worked in China, Turkey, Mexico and Japan for several modeling agencies, died Tuesday, according to Sao Paulo's Servidor Publico Hospital.

The hospital said the infection that killed the 5-foot-8-inch model was caused by anorexia nervosa, a disorder characterized by an abnormal fear of becoming obese, an aversion to food and severe weight loss.

"Take care for your children because their loss is irreparable," Reston's mother, Miriam, told the O Globo newspaper. "Nothing can make the pain go away. No money in the world is worth the life of your child."

Reston began her modeling career at the age of 13 after winning a local beauty contest in her hometown of Jundiai, on the outskirts of Sao Paulo.

"I noticed something was wrong when she returned from Japan," Miriam told the Estado de Sao Paulo newspaper. "She was too thin when she returned and when I told her to eat something, she would say: 'Mom please don't fight with me; there is nothing wrong with me, I'm fine.'"

The model's cousin, Dani Grimaldi, told the Estado de Sao Paulo newspaper that Reston also battled bulimia, an eating disorder marked by binge eating that is followed by vomiting or the use of laxatives.

The world of high fashion and modeling has long been targeted by critics who say it encourages women and girls to emulate rail-thin models.

In September, a Spanish fashion show responded to such criticism by banning models with a body mass index of less than 18. Body mass index is a calculation doctors normally apply to study obesity, and anyone with an index below 18.5 is considered underweight.

Reston would have had a body mass index of 13.4 at the time of her death, according to a calculator on the Web site of the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention
 

AnitaPeterson

Diamond Member
Apr 24, 2001
6,038
593
126
Come on, this is easy... we're on AnandTech!
Most people here would sleep with either woman, just because it's their only chance to get laid :)

IMHO, between the two, obesity is definitely worse...
 

vi edit

Elite Member
Super Moderator
Oct 28, 1999
62,484
8,345
126
Anorexia is worse from the aspect that it is a *true* mental disorder that is self inflicted by societal pressure and portrayed images of beauty. And because it typically affects otherwise healthy teens and adults.

Not to say that the morbidly obese aren't suffering from depression, which many are. That's more of a chicken vs. the egg theory and is largely circular in logic.

I just think that anorexia is worse because it's not as preventable. You don't wake up overnight morbidly obese.