What's the normal Celsius on an Athlon XP 2400+?

Birger

Member
Jun 24, 2000
78
0
0
Hello to you, my "Temperature Gurus".

Important! If you don't have the patience to read all this go to the very end fast as a lightning.

I have now received the Athlon XP 2400+ (Thorton) CPU and the Spire WhisperRock IV CPU cooler that I recently ordered and I have just checked what temperatures I gonna reach with this setup when they are working hard and what I saw was, hmm, kind of worrying.

I will soon give you my temperatures on this combination but first a comparison to my earlier CPU and cooler.

Before I changed the CPU and cooler I used an Athlon XP 1700+ (Palomino) with a GlobalWin FOP 32-1 cooler and my motherboard gave that CPU a Vcore of 1.824. A little too high Vcore since it's meant to only have 1.75 volt, but that's the way Asus build their motherboards.
And when that combination was idle the CPU reached a temp of either 44 or 45 degrees Celsius and the temp in my computer case were always either 25 or 26 degrees Celsius.
When that combination was working really hard my CPU reached a temperature of 51 C.

And now with my new CPU, my motherboard have lowered the Vcore to 1.728 volt but it's still 0.078 volt to much, or almost 5 % too high Vcore, since this CPU is only meant to have 1.65 volt.
Anyway, with this CPU in idle mode I get a temperature of 51 C while the temperature in my computer case still is around 26 degrees C. But those temps don?t bother me that much, what bothers me is the temp this CPU and cooler/fan reach when it's working really hard.

One favourite thing I like to do when I want to know how high the CPU temperature can go when it?s working hard is to make a 192 kbps MP3 of Mike Oldfields Amarok in a program that?s called Cool Edit Pro 1.2. The Amarok track is just over 1 hour long.
When I checked the temperature of my CPU when Cool Edit Pro 1.2 had come to the very end of converting the Amarok.wav file to a MP3 file my CPU had come to an amazingly warm 63 C. That means that the CPU temp had had a rising of 12 C.

I mean a rise of 12 C, when my 1700+ only got a rise of 7 C.
Is that normal for a 2400+ Thorton CPU running at a Vcore of 1.728?

One theory that I got is that I didn't put enough Artic Silver 3 on my new CPU but since I don't want to put to much Artic Silver on my CPU either I thought of that it would be best to ask you first before I do something stupid with my new CPU and cooler.


My system looks like this.

CPU: Athlon XP 2400+ (Thorton) on 1.728 volt.
Motherboard: Asus A7V266-E with Bios 1015 Beta 002
Big Tower: Aopen HQ 08 with 3 case fans.
Memory: 1024 Mb PC2100 on 2 DIMMs
Hard disk: Western Digital 1000BB
Thermal Paste: Artic Silver 3
CD-RW Burner:
DVD Burner:
DVD Player:


Is my 2400+ normal when my 1700+ behaved like this?

Athlon XP 1700+ (Palomino) with Vcore 1.824 = 44 C in idle mode and 51 C when it's working hard = Rise of 7 C.
Athlon XP 2400+ (Thorton) with Vcore 1.728 = 51 C in idle mode and 63 C when it's working hard = Rise of 12 C.
 

myocardia

Diamond Member
Jun 21, 2003
9,291
30
91
No, that's not normal at all. It sounds to me like you don't have your heatsink seated correctly. I would take it off and put it back on, making sure that it "seats" completely flush with the cpu's core.
 

diggerbucket

Member
Dec 6, 2003
56
0
66
Well those temperatures are not critical, but you should be able to get them a lot lower. Maybe the heatsink is not seated properly or you have too much thermal compound on.

Try it again following the guide on the arctic silver website for applying the compound.
 

Birger

Member
Jun 24, 2000
78
0
0
I have now removed my Spire WhisperRock IV CPU cooler from my Athlon XP 2400+ and cleaned both the CPU and the heat sink really carefully and then put them back to my motherboard with rather much Artic Silver 3 between the CPU and the heat sink, but I still have the same temperatures as before, Case temp = 25 C and the CPU temp = 63 C.

I also was really careful about how I placed the cooler on the CPU so that they would have a perfect contact with each other.

Since it seems to bee impossible to get a lower CPU temperature than 50 C idle and 63 C at hard work for me I would REALLY like to have some input about what temperatures you guys get with this CPU. And, don't forget about this, it would be preferably if you run your CPU overvolted like me. Example, you could run your Vcore at = 1.725.

PLEASE !!! Give me some info on what temp you got with an Athlon XP 2400+ CPU and what kind of cooler you use with your CPU.

I can't be the ONLY one in the whole world that has ever used a 2400+ CPU running with a bit too much volt.

And thanks to you diggerbucket, but I have now tried with both little and with much Thermal Paste but I still get the same results.
Funny thing, you suggested that I would use Artic Silvers web site as a help on how to properly apply my Artic Silver 3 to my CPU and cooler and I have just done that, but it didn't get any better after that either.
 

uo7

Senior member
Jun 23, 2002
450
0
0
My current 2400+ is 37 somewhat idle and gets to 48or so load 27 system @1.8 volts 2255 mhz. I'm using a not so good Volcano 9+ heatsink fan.
I read some reviews on your heatsink it doesn't seem to be to bad. Looks like the average is 51 load with 1.75 volts.
What are you applying your arctic silver 3 with ? Only apply the paste to the core not the whole cpu :)
Are you looking under the heatsink after install to make sure it is seated exactly square with the core?
Something is definatly wrong with your temps. And make sure you have the fan blowing on the heatsink not sucking.
 

Birger

Member
Jun 24, 2000
78
0
0
I have now put my Spire WhisperRock IV cooler on my CPU a third time and this time I didn't settle just for a good montage. No, I didn't give up before I had a REALLY PERFECT montage of my cooler on my CPU, and the result of that is amazing. No, not only amazing, I mean really ULTRA amazing, that's correct.

After I had put my cooler on my CPU (for the last time in my life) I left my computer switched on for an hour, but I didn't do anything with it, I just had it powered on so that I could see what temp I was gonna have after an hour and here comes the result.
The temp was now only..............51 C. That's right, the same as before.

I'm starting to think that my motherboard is crazy now and that it doesn?t matter how I do with this CPU, I'm always gonna have some high temps with this setup.

Unless, unless someone of you have some smart and good advices to me on how I could possible solve this "mystery".

Btw, uo7, if you see this.
You wrote that I would make sure that the fan on my CPU cooler was blowing on the heat sink and not sucking, but now I may be a bit stupid because I'm not sure what you mean now. Anyway. I'm not from England or the USA so I'm maybe a lamer on the English language because I don't know what you mean with "not sucking" on the heat sink.
But, the way my fan directs the air is TOO the heat sink and the CPU. It blows air on the heat sink so if you have your hand just above my CPU cooler you won't feel anything since my fan blows the air in the opposite direction.
Is that how you meant it should blow?

Hmm, another thing. I downloaded the AIDA32 program you gave me a link to because I thought that maybe the program that I used, AsusProbe, had gone mad so maybe AIDA32 would show me some nice and low temperatures but it didn't. AIDA32 gave me the same temperatures as the program AsusProbe did.
 

Birger

Member
Jun 24, 2000
78
0
0
Hello to everyone that's reading this off topic post.

I couldn't access Anands main page or this forum on Saturday, does someone of you had the same problem as I did?
 

Palmer

Junior Member
Feb 29, 2004
5
0
0
My Athlon XP2400+ runs at 31C according to ABIT EQ. Case shows 24C.

I am presently only reading the forums. But under intensive use can go up to 42C.

I have three case fans on my full tower, one sucking in and two sucking out.

HTH

Palmer
 

NYHoustonman

Platinum Member
Dec 8, 2002
2,642
0
0
Mine is usually around 46 idle, 50-52 load. Lowering that VCore should do at least something, though... I know on my A7V333 for 1.65v it had the vcore at like 1.7 (stability feature thingy, apparently), so I put it at 1.6 and it shows up 1.65 now. Everything is stable (I literally never get hard lockups), and I don't remember how much exactly the temps went down but I know they went down fairly far to where they are now (I think I was getting like 58 load before).