Originally posted by: CKent
Hrm, well... I was -really- high when I made that post. I apologize for the confusion it caused. Let me try to clarify:
1) I can't reinstate my old account. I made 4 figures off it ^_^
2) I am a power gamer. I would be lvl 80 within 2 weeks. I would -not- be playing with my friend who's willing to recruit-a-friend, since he plays on the shittiest server in WoW. I'm not interested in buying vanilla wow, playing it for 6 months, then buying bc, playing it for another 6, etc.
3) Is the cheapest way the battlechest + wolk? I'm not poor, I just suffer from cheapness to the point that it is a sickness rather than a virtue or even trait.
4) What I basically got sick of was Arenas. I don't think dueling for the best gear in the game is the best way to go about it. Some fucking little god damn 12 year old destined for a career in fast food would "pwn" me in battlegrounds because he liked arenas while I refused to do them on general principle, and so his gear was better than mine. Is this still the case?
2. You trying for a Horde character on Magtheridon EU? Last time I checked a month or so ago Ensidia was recruiting I think. If you dedicate that much time and effort on WoW, something like that may be right up your alley.
3. Probably. I actually always just bought just the CD keys from ebay seller and downloaded the clients. Instant WoW FTW.
4. Always depended on what you do. PvP gear wasn't the best from what I have experience in if you PvE. It's insanity to use PvP gear to raid as a man regen based healer (Priest, Druid), and for the same itemlevel, PvP gear is really below average for DPS and decently bad for tanking.
Just as an example for cat druids(since I play a dual spec feral/resto druid), the S6 and T8 sets compared (since they are within 6ilevels of each other (232 for S6, 226 for T8)
Furious Gladiator Dragonhide Robes
http://www.wowhead.com/?item=41661
596 Armor
+105 Agility
+138 Stamina
Red Socket
Yellow Socket
Socket Bonus: +6 Resilience Rating
Durability 120 / 120
Classes: Druid
Requires Level 80
Requires personal and team arena rating of 1750
Equip: Improves critical strike rating by 64 (1.39% @ L80).
Equip: Improves your resilience rating by 80 (0.98% @ L80).
Equip: Increases attack power by 120.
Conqueror's Nightsong Raiments
http://www.wowhead.com/?item=46159
591 Armor
+97 Agility
+119 Stamina
Red Socket
Blue Socket
Socket Bonus: +6 Agility
Durability 120 / 120
Classes: Druid
Requires Level 80
Equip: Improves hit rating by 49 (1.49% @ L80).
Equip: Improves critical strike rating by 66 (1.44% @ L80).
Equip: Increases attack power by 162.
What we see is the PvE gear actually provides slightly more dps at the expense of less resilience (which if you are DPS doesnt matter much[me, a little less DoT damage, yippie], and if you are Bear, again, doesn't matter all all due to crit immunity talent). That on top of the better socket and socket bonus (Red for agility, blue for a purple Agility/stam gem)
Also, the T8 set bonus actually helps your DPS while the Arena S5 set has resilience and movspeed bonuses (again pretty close to useless in PvE).
So really, PvE gear is best for PvE and PvP gear is best for pvp, it has not been the case where PvP gear outshone PvE gear since WoW 1.x. S2 gear though tradable for T5 badges was ridiculously bad for PvE, purely PvE statwise, being worse than T4 by quite a bit, it didn't really get to parity until S4 gear, at which point there was no Tier gear to compare it to item level wise so it was competitive with good PvE Gear. With the release of WoTLK, PvP gear has gained ground, become decent for DPS/Tank feral druids but still not as good as equal level PvE gear.
As a raid healer, its crazy to rely on something with 0+spirit and very low +mp5 as found on PvP gear. Sure you'll have creay +spellpower, but it doesn't mean anything if you run OOM and the guild cant rely on you to pull your weight in healing. Of course spirit got nerfed in 3.1, which means less mana regen (40% less) when out of 5 second rule and the same amount in 5 second rule, but as a main healer druid, I'm rarely out of 5 second rule so spirit still applies to me, that on top of the +heal bonus from spirit and it'd be crazy to go for 0+spirit gear, especially when at higher intellect, per item level point, spirit becomes fairly equal to pure +mp5 inside 5 second rule mana regen and still beats it outside 5 sec rule.
Of course my experiences are as I'm usually OT(so I prioritize Tank stats, don't get me started ranting about how the continuous bear nerfs have destroyed my toon, leaving all druids fairly worthless as the MT I used to be) and Main raid healer(so I went mana regen over +heal bonus) so your experiences may vary.