Whats better, LCD or Plasma?

Dimkaumd

Senior member
Dec 1, 2003
335
0
0
I am getting ready to buy a TV in about 2 months. I have a very old bulky TV and Im ready to switch to a 40"-50" flat screen.

I went to circuit city the other day, and I have no idea where to start? I saw LCD's, Plasma's, DLP's...

What do you think is better for a TV that size? My budget will be approx $1500, +/- $200

Any useful advise? Thanks!
 

krotchy

Golden Member
Mar 29, 2006
1,942
0
76
I really think this is one of those, what do you want to do sort of things. From my POV the pros and cons are below. Personally I prefer LCD's alot at this point.

LCD's
Pros -
Prices have been dropping alot on 1080p models
Look great with computers attached (at 1080p, 720p with a computer is very meh)
Easy to view in a bright room.
Great for gaming and no burn in

Cons
Poorer black levels (minus samsung 81 series which are too expensive)
Lower Static Contrast ratios

Plasma
Pros
Great black levels
Tend to be more vibrant
Great Contrast ratios

Cons
Heavy
May still experience burn in (rare)
1080p models are very expensive
Shiny Screen can be tough to view in bright room
Dont work very well as computer screen


I dunno much about plasmas to make a suggestion in your range.

For LCD's though I Can personally suggest the Philips 47PFL7422/37 from costco for 1700 with the lovely costco return policy/warranty
Vizio's 47in is also nice, although I personally had my HDMI inputs go bad so I returned to costco for the phillips. It is 200 dollars cheaper than the phillips which is a plus.

overall id suggest browsing avsforum.com for better info

on a side note...
Dont touch Sceptre with a 10 foot pole.
 

cheesehead

Lifer
Aug 11, 2000
10,079
0
0
I personally don't much like plasmas. I've seen quite a few of them deteriorate after a few years' heavy use, and while a plasma is great if you just want to use it for watching movies, you can usually get an equally good projector at a slightly cheaper price. That said, I'm one of those wackos who don't like to replace things more than once a decade.

I'm not an expert on which brand is the best, but the only non name-brand (Philips, Sony, Pioneer, etc.) producer of flat-panel TVs I can vouch for is Syntax-Olevia, which makes some nice stuff indeed. Aside from that, I reccomend bringing a good source of HD video (perhaps a laptop with a DVI output?), and plugging it into each TV in turn; most of the cheaper stores have one absolutely awful video signal routed through about eight distribution doohickeys, making a $10,000 Pioneer Elite look about the same as a $100 Sanyo.

Also, make sure to get the requisite number of features. Unless you've got a reciever with HDMI switching (about $300+, or more like $400 for one with decent sound quality) or want to buy a HDMI switch ($80+ for a 2-port switch, IIRC), it might be worth spending a few bucks extra for a TV with two or more HDMI inputs. Furthermore, some TVs have low-quality analog inputs; if you're stuck with RGB or composite for TV or use with a Wii, this is something to watch out for.
 

jlfirehawk

Senior member
Jan 10, 2005
417
1
81
I went to costco intending on getting a 60" Vizio for 2199 but couldnt get over the 50" Vizio that was only 1299 so I bought that and Xbox 360 Elite for my new house instead. For the price and the fact that it is in the basement it works well having a plasma. I was going to get a hitachi at hhgreg but the vizio was too good of a deal.
 

montypythizzle

Diamond Member
Nov 12, 2006
3,698
0
71
Wow, I couldn't imagine getting a flat panel 60" of any type, WHOAH, I am used to 27" and 48" in the living room.
 

Schadenfroh

Elite Member
Mar 8, 2003
38,416
4
0
Originally posted by: montypythizzle
Wow, I couldn't imagine getting a flat panel 60" of any type, WHOAH, I am used to 27" and 48" in the living room.

Same here, although I use a 27" in the bedroom and a 36" in the living room. Both of them are 480i televisions.
 

spidey07

No Lifer
Aug 4, 2000
65,469
5
76
Originally posted by: montypythizzle
Wow, I couldn't imagine getting a flat panel 60" of any type, WHOAH, I am used to 27" and 48" in the living room.

meh, I sit 11 feet from my 65". It really allows you to truly enjoy HD for what it is. I notice in most peoples homes they have a severely undersized TV to take advantage of HD.
 

kalrith

Diamond Member
Aug 22, 2005
6,628
7
81
Originally posted by: AnitaPeterson
Plasmas also typically consume A LOT of power...

It is true that 50" plasmas consume a lot relative to a 27" CRT TV; however, I assume you're saying that plasmas consume A LOT of power, while LCDs consume very little. This is absolutely NOT TRUE. Look at the "Juice box" at the bottom of the more recent CNET reviews. You'll see that some TVs consume more than others, but in general plasmas only consume a little more (like 10%) than LCDs of similar size. Some plasmas actually consume less than comparative LCDs.

Example: The Vizio 50" plasma (review link) consumes 317 watts at default picture settings and 197 watts when calibrated. The Toshiba 52" LCD (review link) consumes 322 watts at default picture settings and 215 watts when calibrated.