<<
I think 550 is the highest non-coppermine, correct? >>
Supported by your motherboard?
That is correct if you look
here, the highest is not the P3-550 based on the older Katmai .25u core. It has the older 512k L2 cache clk'd at 225 Mhz. That crown goes to the P3-600B w/c was Slot-1, 133 Mhz FSB, and 2.05V Vcore.
Cheapest I've seen the Katmai P3-550 is $111 on PriceWatch, whereas the majority of the Celeries are less than $80 including the 100 Mhz FSB Celeries.
850/100
800/100
766/66 = 11.5 (X 100 = 1150)
633/66 = 9.5 (X 100 = 950)
600/66 = 9 (X 100 = 900)
566/66 = 8.5 (X 100 = 850)
If you choose the slotket converter route:
Well, from what you've been telling us, the only logical choices are the 100 Mhz FSB Celeries or the 533A/66 and 566/66 w/c can oc to 800 and 850 respectively.
I think the majority of the retailers that are selling the latest Celerons should be based on the cCO core w/c is at least a minimum voltage of 1.7V Vcore (for the cCO Celeron 566 anyway).
If you're comfortable with oc'ng w/c it seems you are, I would go for either the 533A/66 or the 566/66 and oc it from 66 to 100. These procs are dirt cheap now. I personally would grab the 566 and have it do the dance at 850.
I just sold my 1 yo iC-566/66 w/c was based on an older cBO stepping. Default voltage for this proc was 1.5V Vcore. I installed it on a Slotket (settings were done with Abit jumperless bios) and it oc'd to 850 at 1.65V.
I've never done the tape trick, but I'm sure it's viable. I wish I could help you out on that one

.
If all is lost, you can contact Biostar support
here.
You may also consider upgrading your current motherboard/proc setup to maybe an Amd-based alternative.
Just a thought.
Good luck.