- Mar 12, 2000
- 8,324
- 2
- 0
I mentioned this in another thread (on why the US provides aid to Israel) but I think I want to explore the idea a bit further. Basically I said:
<<
I always thought it was because we were very sympathtic with what happened to the Jews during WWII (heck, throughout history it seems that everyone has hated the Jews) and when they established Israel we thought it was the right thing to do to help them. Their form of government and basic values are very similar to ours. I can't imagine not ever supporting them. They were surrounded by enemies who wanted to wipe them out. They're our friends so we help them -- that's what friends do.
Sometimes I wonder if it would have been better if all the Jews in Israel would have emigrated to the US though. They're a great people and I certainly would have welcomed them with open arms.
>>
From what I understand of the Jewish religion -- there has always been the promise that the Jews will be delivered to a "promise land" of some sort where they can live freely and without fear. It doesn't make sense for this land to be Israel because that's where they originally came from. Maybe this promise land is really the US!
If all the Jews from Israel emigrated to the US, we will receive the following benefits:
1) We don't have to worry about the Arabs nations slaughtering them anymore. Our friends would be safe here.
2) We don't have to spend a lot of money to defend Israel anymore. We can use this money to help our own poor.
3) The Israelis would not be a drain to our country -- most are well educated and can make major contributions to our society.
4) Our Air Force will get a bunch of top-notch fighter pilots -- so our national defense will be strengthened.
5) Hopefully, the Arab and Muslim world won't hate us as much anymore.
Is my idea too wacky?
<<
I always thought it was because we were very sympathtic with what happened to the Jews during WWII (heck, throughout history it seems that everyone has hated the Jews) and when they established Israel we thought it was the right thing to do to help them. Their form of government and basic values are very similar to ours. I can't imagine not ever supporting them. They were surrounded by enemies who wanted to wipe them out. They're our friends so we help them -- that's what friends do.
Sometimes I wonder if it would have been better if all the Jews in Israel would have emigrated to the US though. They're a great people and I certainly would have welcomed them with open arms.
>>
From what I understand of the Jewish religion -- there has always been the promise that the Jews will be delivered to a "promise land" of some sort where they can live freely and without fear. It doesn't make sense for this land to be Israel because that's where they originally came from. Maybe this promise land is really the US!
If all the Jews from Israel emigrated to the US, we will receive the following benefits:
1) We don't have to worry about the Arabs nations slaughtering them anymore. Our friends would be safe here.
2) We don't have to spend a lot of money to defend Israel anymore. We can use this money to help our own poor.
3) The Israelis would not be a drain to our country -- most are well educated and can make major contributions to our society.
4) Our Air Force will get a bunch of top-notch fighter pilots -- so our national defense will be strengthened.
5) Hopefully, the Arab and Muslim world won't hate us as much anymore.
Is my idea too wacky?