First... before I say this, realize that I am a conservative. The whole sterilization argument sounds like a great idea until you think about the people on food stamps or welfare. YES, some have been on it all their life, but some have only just become part of the system. This recession has created welfare recipients out of entire families. Who is to say that those recently enrolled can't climb their way back to productivity again and therefore afford more children on their own some day?
What should be done, is mandating a cap on people receiving welfare and other benefits. That they will only receive benefits for the kids they currently have - whether that is zero or multiples. Most states offer free birth control for all and even offer surgical tube ties for habitual breeders. The message should be that if you are a ward of the state, you can not have children and will not receive additional support for them.
The problem with that is that the child gets punished for coming into this world...
Good post. Free birth control and sterilization for welfare people is a great idea, and we should definitely have a declining benefits structure to disincentivize women to have multiple children for higher benefits, but forced sterilization is creepy and morally wrong. I like the workfare thing too, although moving welfare people into camps I also find creepy and also probably counterproductive in the long run. And I'm also a conservative. We definitely need to revise the way we do welfare and public aid, but we need to avoid dehumanizing people too.
I don't have a problem with giving people food stamps. Most people use them properly and I see no reason to punish the majority for the misuse by the minority. I have less problem with the woman who has the 6 kids than the middle east/asian chick I saw last year in the store. That chick used a family first card, but she was pretty and had a little one in tow. Expensive jewlery on as well, then walked out into the parking lot and got into a brand new 5 series BMW. It still had the temp tag. But yet she was using a fmily first card to pay for food. Those are the ones I have a real problem with.
RACIST! We need MORE hot Asian and/or Middle Eastern chicks!
She probably has a well-off boyfriend she won't marry because then she'd lose her free stuff. This is fairly common from what I've seen, completely legal, and a good part of what is wrong with our system. It's very, very bad for our society because it weakens familial bonds, leading to more real single-parent households as well as more single-parent households for purposes of government goodies. It's hard to fix though. We need to stop rewarding irresponsibility and punishing marriage, but without forcing people to marry simply for the benefits.
Incidentally the last food stamp card user I followed out was a black lady, but otherwise similar to your description. Very pretty, very well coiffed, expensively dressed, nails well done, expensive-looking tasteful jewelry, two well-dressed, well-behaved children, buying a LOT of meat. When I came out, she was loading her groceries into a nice Lexus. I suspect she is the same type, with a well-to-do boyfriend and no visible income. But you never know. She could also be a big-time welfare cheat, or using someone else's card to pick up their groceries, or she could have just lost a good job and suddenly be income-poor without having lost her nice car or worn out her nice clothes.
I make no statement about how common this may be, simply because unless it's an attractive woman or someone who makes a fuss about what the food stamp card won't buy, I wouldn't notice how someone pays.