What do you think...Carter or McNabb?

[Deeko]

I picked Donovan McNabb with my 2nd pick in my fantasy draft. He has pretty much sucked. I also have Brady and Culpepper, but the Vikings have a bye this week. I really don't feel like playing McNabb though...I picked up Quincy Carter(yea, of all the QB's...), he has 4 more TD's, 1 less interception, and twice the yards. They are also playing each other this week...Dallas is the #3 defense in the NFL, #10 against the pass, Philly is 2nd to last against the pass. As of right now, I have benched McNabb in favor of Carter....anyone else agree?

 

[GambiT]

I thought you meant Vince Carter and Donovan McNabb when I came in here. I was going to respond with 2 words:

OVER RATED!!

 

[LikeLinus]

Originally posted by: GambiT
I thought you meant Vince Carter and Donovan McNabb when I came in here. I was going to respond with 2 words:

OVER RATED!!

Thanks Rush, now STFU and stay on topic.

Honestly I don't see Carter playing as well as he has for much longer. I think the coach has brought a lot out of him, but I dunno he just doesn't seem to be that great of a QB. Donovan is just looking to come back large soon. It's really hard to tell though.

 

[Garet Jax]

Who is each playing this week?

 

[Deeko]

Originally posted by: LikeLinus

Originally posted by: GambiT
I thought you meant Vince Carter and Donovan McNabb when I came in here. I was going to respond with 2 words:

OVER RATED!!

Thanks Rush, now STFU and stay on topic.

Honestly I don't see Carter playing as well as he has for much longer. I think the coach has brought a lot out of him, but I dunno he just doesn't seem to be that great of a QB. Donovan is just looking to come back large soon. It's really hard to tell though.

I agree....Carter seems to be playing better than he should. And McNabb is a much better QB than his numbers suggest...but with the way both of them are playing NOW, I'm kind of inclined to play Carter.

Who is each playing this week?

Philly is at Dallas.

 

[waylman]

i'd start carter

 

[gistech1978]

i would start carter too
but thats also because i hate andy reid and the eagles and im desperately trying to trade mcnabb away. that team is going nowhere.
joey porter has scored more points than mcnabb in yahoo FF so far. and joey porter played what...1 or 2 games?

 

[Nitemare]

I'd start Janikowsky at QB before I started McNabb there

 

[digitalsm]

Yeah considering Dallas has the #1 ranked offense and #3 ranked defense, Id go with Carter.

 

[Kev]

don't forget that bobby taylor and troy vincent will probably be back for philly this week

 

[Kev]

Originally posted by: digitalsm
Yeah considering Dallas has the #1 ranked offense and #3 ranked defense, Id go with Carter.

rankings shmankings, dallas sucks ass

 

[PunDogg]

carter carter carter, #1 offence in the league you'll get points for sure

Dogg

 

[Kev]

by the way, where are you getting your stats? nfl.com has Dallas' pass defense at 18 with Philly's at 19 with the youngest secondary in the league.

 

[Deeko]

Originally posted by: Kev

Originally posted by: digitalsm
Yeah considering Dallas has the #1 ranked offense and #3 ranked defense, Id go with Carter.

rankings shmankings, dallas sucks ass

we'll see on Sunday. Eagles blow this year.

by the way, where are you getting your stats? nfl.com has Dallas' pass defense at 18 with Philly's at 19 with the youngest secondary in the league.

I don't even know if it is sorted when you first click it...I actually miscounted, and Dallas is 15, but Philly is a definite second to last. Yards per game is the stat that matters.

 

[TheNinja]

Don't listen to these people. Start McNabb. The phillies secondary is getting bobby taylor and troy vincent (as Kev mentioned). Philly D is no push over, I don't care what people say. I'd also check if Couch, Fiedler, or possibly Doug Johnson were available (atl will HAVE to air it out vs STL to keep up). Anyway, forget Carter, you used your 2nd round (probably a high 2nd round) pick on McNabb, I'd rather live and die by my high picks.

 

[Deeko]

Originally posted by: Staley8
Don't listen to these people. Start McNabb. The phillies secondary is getting bobby taylor and troy vincent (as Kev mentioned). Philly D is no push over, I don't care what people say. I'd also check if Couch, Fiedler, or possibly Doug Johnson were available (atl will HAVE to air it out vs STL to keep up). Anyway, forget Carter, you used your 2nd round (probably a high 2nd round) pick on McNabb, I'd rather live and die by my high picks.

Eagles D is very good. Problem is....McNabb hasn't done jack sh!t all season.

 

[Dragnov]

I'd go w/ McNabb personally.