I had the same moment of indecision as you.
It took me 2 months of farting around, looking at reviews, etc.
Finally decided on Epson stylus 880. Cartridges are expensive, but I use duplicate cartridges - haven't looked back.
Of course, it depends on what you are using it for.
This is for everything from photos, to DTP, office work.
Wide range of settings from 720 X 360dpi to 2880! X 720 - excellent for photos.
No I don't work for epson, or have shares in their company.
