OP = Class of '10 Alumnus who is tired of watching his alma mater's team self destruct EVERY season. Oh, and in 5 years of school I attended EVERY SINGLE HOME GAME. Don't you dare call me a fair weather fan.
Well you may be a lifelong die-hard fan, I don't know, but the fact that you happened to use your free/cheap student tickets during 5 of the best years in your football program's history doesn't exactly prove your case. I say this because a lot of people in my state became LSU "fans" in the last 10 years when they rose to become a nationally competitive program, people who weren't fans before, and won't be fans when/if they decline back to a 6-8 win team that finishes in the middle/bottom of the conference.
Maybe I'm ignorant, but it appears to me that Frank Beamer put VT football on the map, and may have done just about as much as is humanly possible to maximize what that university can do in major college football. It's a rural setting, regionally you're competing for recruits against bigger schools and better football conferences, and I'm assuming you have somewhat higher admission standards than the typical state U.
He's come close to winning it all and expectations are just unrealistic. Yes? If you get rid of him, are you really going to get somebody significantly better to come to Blacksburg, someone of a Saban/Meyer caliber?