• We’re currently investigating an issue related to the forum theme and styling that is impacting page layout and visual formatting. The problem has been identified, and we are actively working on a resolution. There is no impact to user data or functionality, this is strictly a front-end display issue. We’ll post an update once the fix has been deployed. Thanks for your patience while we get this sorted.

WD Raptor up-to-date

The Raptor is outdated. Even the newer Velociraptors today aren't much better than some of today's 7200rpm HDDs like Samsung F4's and WD Black's.

Yeah. MY 150gb raptor X is a little dated in the raptor family, but it gets about the same read/write speed as my 2tb wd green drive.

The 600gb wd velociraptor has the best bench results and highest capacity but is still much slower than SSD's.

fffblackmage : That's a nice article to show where the raptors stand w\ other drives.
 
Last edited:
Thanks for answers, i know good times for my raptor model passed away.Even it fails vs my WD green but those access times re still remarkable i think.Im going to replace it with a Samsung F3 and considering the money i will get for my raptor i think i should keep it and using it for some apps that could take some benefits from raptors specs like access time or rpms but what apps? Somebody even recommended me to use it just for OS and maybe install games in F3 so im a bit lost at this.

Reading benchmark fffblackmage provided reminds me when i got raptor back in dec'05.It was a nice piece of hardware but honestly i wont pay that money again for a hdd unless there is a big step in performance.
 
If you are impressed by the Raptors access time you should look at a SSD. They make the Raptor's access times look incredibly slow in comparison.
 
but remember this model is Sata 150Gb/s

And that has nothing at all to do with access times.

SSDs have near-instantaneous access times. No heads to seek, no platters spinning that you have to wait on.

.1 ms access time is a huge difference from ~5-7ms
 
U all making me green with envy lol pity im actually setting up a medium system config and cant afford one ssd atm, maybe in about 2 years and hopefully by then prices will be stablished.Right now im happy if able to find an usefull space for my raptor next to a samsung F3 in my future i5 built.
 
Somebody even recommended me to use it just for OS and maybe install games in F3 so im a bit lost at this.
That's what I'd be doing just to have the OS by itself in case of screw-ups and most SSD users also have this type of configuration.

The access times on Raptors/Velociraptors are much better than most mechanical drives but overall you probably won't notice if you just loaded everything on the Samsung.
 
I have an old 36GB Raptor, now retired and living in a cupboard. It was in an older machine until recently, but modern drives - even cheap ones - are much faster. The Samsung F3's are great.
 
Raptors are pretty outdated. That being said, if you are looking into purchasing a Velociraptor, then there is still some use for it.

The velociraptors are great for game drives where you still want fast access, but need plenty of space. The modern gaming config standard that a lot of people use is to have an SSD as the boot volume (or two SSD's in raid-0 or raid-1 if you want redundancy instead), have a velociraptor as the game drive, and have a big 2 TB WD black or some such as the media drive. The sustained throughput on the WD black drives is pretty decent but the access time is slow, making it great for watching movies or streaming media but not that great for gaming.

SSD's tear up a raptor in terms of performance but they are expensive and don't have that much room. Modern games, if you take into account all the mods you can plop on, can easily hit the 20 GB for a single game nowadays (as an example, FakeFactory is a mod that is something like 11+ GB for the mod alone).

On my new rig I was installing games right to the SSD and realized suddenly that I hardly had any room left and had to start uninstalling. At least this will hold true until the larger SSD's hit the market in 2011, such as the Intel G3, which supposedly will be 600 GB for the largest size. Keep in mind it will still cost a ton though to get that much space.
 
Also... velociraptors have gotten very cheap. You can pick up the 300gb velociraptors all day for $99-125 on ebay.
 
Back
Top