Originally posted by: Canterwood
So how does this guy manage to do something MS says can't be done?
Fair play to him though if it works properly.
I don't think Microsoft ever said "it couldn't be done". From what I understand, it was originally a planned feature, but was later scrapped due to time and complications. The implication is that public support for "slipstreaming" your existing DVD just isn't a pri-1 scenario.
I'm not surprised that it got cut. It appears that SP1 has been a painful effort for Microsoft. The fact that a
"SP1 Prerequisite" patch exists is a good indicator that Microsoft probably had to fix some fundamental problems with the Patch Engine itself before the SP1 package could itself be rolled out. When the SP1 schedule slipped out, I'm sure it was one of the first cuts. (Sp1 was originally rumored to be due this past December, IIRC.)
Microsoft obviously is already mass-producing the official "Sp1-integrated" Vista installation media, and those will replace the RTM media for all retail copies in stores eventually. No doubt they want this media to be widespread. The question is whether they need to go to the trouble of supporting a mechanism for
end-users to slipstream their own media at home. Naturally, the question is how many home users actually do this?
Remember, the vast majority of Microsoft's customers get Vista from an OEM like Dell, who will of course have access to SP1-integrated media to put on new systems and package into "restore" media for customers buying new PCs. Most of these users have no idea what slipstreaming is, and even if they did, it wouldn't likely work on the restore media provided by their OEM. So slipstreaming really doesn't apply to this crowd.
IT managers at large corporations with volume-license agreements will automatically receive SP1-integrated media. And IT managers for smaller businesses will either download the integrated ISO with their MSDN/Technet subscription, or will eventually buy a new retail copy of Vista that has the SP1-integrated media already. So slipstreaming doesn't really apply to this crowd either (note that it used to be the main audience).
That leaves us with a much smaller segment of retail DVD purchasers. And only a portion of those would make use of slipstreaming, namely if:
- you are frequently wiping and re-installing Vista for some reason
- you don't and won't have access to a Sp1-integrated copy of Vista prior to SP2 (buying a new one for a 2nd PC, borrowing one from a friend, etc)
- you are technically savvy enough to know about slipstreaming and determined enough to learn how to do it 🙂
Apparently Microsoft was satisfied that this segment of customers is sufficiently small that they could stand to be disappointed until SP2. At least, that's how I see it.
Anyway, look at the bright side: at least there is an active community that fills in these gaps in Microsoft's priorities!
🙂