I got the transcoder hooked up last night.. I originally posted my results in another thread.. out of lazyness, here is a quick copy/paste 🙂
<< As Promised, the transcoder arrived & here is an update..
Honestly, It works just as I figured it would.. True VGA output quality and identical to the picture on true HDTV's. If you have owned a Dreamcast with a VGA adapter, the picture output is very similar in quality. The current generation of xbox games are locked at 480p, which equates to 640x480@60hz. If I recall correctly, this is also what the Dreamcast VGA also output.
One thing to note is that this transcoder will not output a 480i signal, so you will not be able to see the xbox intro or setup screens on your monitor. You can bypass this by hooking up the Y component cable (Green) to a composite input, setup your xbox, & move the connection back over to the transcoder. I have mine setup a little differently. The transcoder has component pass thru, so I run a composite cable from the Y pass thru to my TV card. If I need to setup my xbox, I use the TV Card, which eliminates the need for cable swapping.
Anyway, Here is a real quick breakdown of what I see to be the +'s and -'s.
+'s
-Image much sharper
-Textures much clearer
-Items in the distance are easier to make out.
-Text much easier to read
-'s
-Some Aliasing can occur...again, if you have seen a Dreamcast on a TV and VGA monitor you know what to expect.
-Any inherent artifacting that is masked by a TV, will become much more noticeable (i.e. Sprite popup, misaligned polygons, texture flashing)
-No xbox setup menu's
In closing, this Item is not for everyone.. Getting the xbox on a VGA monitor is a luxury & you pay for it. Am I glad that I spent the money? Yes. Is the picture quality better than on my 32" Wega (s-video)? Yes. Would I rather be playing on a large HDTV? Yes, but as stated earlier, this is not an option for me right now.
Before purchasing one of these transcoders, I would recommend that you..
1) Get a good look at the Dreamcast outputing VGA. The ouput quality is very, very similar.
2) Get a good look at a xbox running @ 480p on a 4:3 HDTV.
>>